I found out something very interesting from the All That fan site, someone very important to the glory days of All That was going to return to his old job for the 11th season, which of course never happened.

Dan Schneider (who before the 10th season rehired Steve Holland) rehired Kevin Kopolow as a writer and on screen preformer. Kevin the stage manager character would have returned, and so would have the Big Ear Of Corn. The show would have to its old format, except they would have kept the Know Your Stars segment.

Probably the music intros wouldn't be as half ass as they have become. They used to put as much effort into creative and funny music into sketches as regular sketches.

Unfortunitely they might have been more remake sketches, the new Good Burger might return, and maybe there would be new Everyday French with Pierre Eascargot, and of coure Vital Information.

I wonder if Kevin could have returned the show to past glory, how good would he be without his old writing partner Heath Seifert.

What might have been? I doubt if any writer could have saved the show, but if anyone could Kevin Kopolow could.

Was All That cancelled?

Yes it was.