Of all the seasons, all the top 12, out of 60, who would be your definite top 12?

1. Chris Daughtry
2. Clay Aiken
3. Josh Gracin
4. Kelly Clarkson
5. Fantasia
6. Anthony Federov
7. Bo Bice
8. Carrie Underwood
9. Constantine Maroulis
10. George Huff
11. Carmen Rasmusen
12. Latoya London

In no particular order...

Kelly Clarkson
Clay Aiken
Constantine Maroulis
Ace Young
Taylor Hicks
Elliott Yamin
Kellie Pickler
Carrie Underwood
Bo Bice
George Huff
JPL
Diana Degarmo

Kelly Clarkson
Carrie Underwood
Jasmine Trias
Katharine McPhee
Elliott Yamin
Diana DeGarmo
Clay Aiken
Chris Daughtry
Kellie Pickler
George Huff

1. Carrie Underwood
2. Chris Daughtry
3. Kelly Clarkson
4. Diana DeGarmo
5. Bo Bice
6. Katharine McPhee
7. Kellie Pickler
8. Anthony Fedorov
9. Jasmine Trias
10. Jon Peter Lewis
11. Kevin Covais
12. Eliott Yamin

....in that order

1. Carrie Underwood
2. Chris FREAKIN Daughtry
3. Kelly Clarkson
4. Bo Bice
5.Katahrine McPhee
6. Diana DeGarmo
7. Kellie Pickler
8. Clay Aiken
9,l Eliott Yamin
10. Consatine Maroulis
11. Anthony Fedorov
12. Jon Peter Lewis

Honorable mentions : George Huff , Kevin Covais,LaToya London, Jasmine Trias,K.Lo,Kim Caldwell



In no particular order, except the top 5

Kelly Clarkson
Carrie Underwood
Jasmine Trias
Katharine McPhee
Elliott Yamin
Diana DeGarmo
Clay Aiken
Chris Daughtry
Kellie Pickler
George Huff
No Kim Caldwell?!?!?!?!?:eek:

Chris Daughtry
Elliott Yamin
Kelly Clarkson
Bo Bice
Jasmine Trias
Carrie Underwood
Katharine McPhee
Anthony Fedorov
Constantine Maroulis
Taylor Hicks
Mandisa
Diana DeGarmo

I no particular order:

Anthony Fedorov
Elliott Yamin
Clay Aiken
Scott Savol
Vonzell Soloman
Mandisa
Taylor Hicks
Nadia Turner
Constantine Maroulis
Paris Bennett
Lisa Tucker
Bo Bice

1. Clay Aiken
2. Kelly Clarkson
3. Mario Vasquez
4. JPL
5. Kevin Covais
6. Diana DeGarmo
7. Elliott Yamin
8. Taylor Hicks
9. Ace Young
10. Rickey Smith
11. Matt Rogers
12. George Huff

1. Clay Aiken
2. Kelly Clarkson
3. Mario Vasquez
4. JPL
5. Kevin Covais
6. Diana DeGarmo
7. Elliott Yamin
8. Taylor Hicks
9. Ace Young
10. Rickey Smith
11. Matt Rogers
12. George Huff
Kevin overTaylor and Eliott?!?!?:eek:

I like all 3 but id put Elliott and Taylor first

Kevin overTaylor and Eliott?!?!?:eek:

I like all 3 but id put Elliott and Taylor first
not everyone has the same taste as you, jack :)

not everyone has the same taste as you, jack :)
I know

But she wasl ike all wanting an Eliott and Taylro final 2 and stuff ad LOL

I know

But she wasl ike all wanting an Eliott and Taylro final 2 and stuff ad LOL
that was after kevin left :lol:

that was after kevin left :lol:
Oh right :lol:

1. Elliott Yamin
2. George Huff
3. Anthony Federov
4. Bo Bice
5. Clay Aiken
6. Jon Peter Lewis
7. Paris Bennett
8. Mandisa
9. Diana Degarmo
10. Kelly Clarkson
11. Nadia Turner
12. Vonzell Solomon

No Kim Caldwell?!?!?!?!?:eek:

Oh gasp, let me redo this then

Kelly Clarkson
Carrie Underwood
Jasmine Trias
Katharine McPhee
Elliott Yamin
Diana DeGarmo
Clay Aiken
Chris Daughtry
Kimberly Caldwell
Kellie Pickler

1. Carrie Underwood
2. Chris Daughtry
3. Kelly Clarkson
4. Diana DeGarmo
5. Bo Bice
6. Katharine McPhee
7. Kellie Pickler
8. Anthony Fedorov
9. Jasmine Trias
10. Jon Peter Lewis
11. Kevin Covais
12. Eliott Yamin

....in that order

I thought you hated Kevin Covais? :confused:

FAVORITES EVER:
1. Kelly Clarkson
1. Chris Daughtry
1. Constantine Maroulis

THEN:
4. Vonzell Solomon
5. Elliott Yamin
6. Diana DeGarmo
7. Jon Peter Lewis

the rest are in no particular order

Kevin Covais
Paris Bennett
Anthony Fedorov
Anwar Robinson
Clay Aiken

I thought you hated Kevin Covais? :confused:
i changed my mind :lol: well, a little bit. i couldn't think of who else to put o_O

i changed my mind :lol: well, a little bit. i couldn't think of who else to put o_O
Constantine? Goegre Huff?

Oh gasp, let me redo this then

Kelly Clarkson
Carrie Underwood
Jasmine Trias
Katharine McPhee
Elliott Yamin
Diana DeGarmo
Clay Aiken
Chris Daughtry
Kimberly Caldwell
Kellie Pickler
I like that :D
Dont like K.Lo?

I like that :D
Dont like K.Lo?
I do, but I guess I like 10 others better :lol:

I do, but I guess I like 10 better :lol:
Ah

Well yes Chris ansd Carrie are the two best contestants EVER

Constantine? Goegre Huff?
lol wasn't big on either of them...kinda liked constantine but not a lot.

lol wasn't big on either of them...kinda liked constantine but not a lot.
Ah

Wow, i loved George LOL and Constantine

1) Katharine Mcphee forever lol.
2) Carrie Underwood
3) Kelly Clarkson
4) Tamyra Gray
5) CLAY AIKEN.
6) Paris Bennett
7) Lisa Tucker
8) Justin Guarini
9) Kellie Pickler
10) Mikalah Gordon
11) Leah Labelle
12) Bo Bice

Okay, these first ones are in order.

1. Jessica Sierra
2. Taylor Hicks
3. Camile Velasco
4. Melissa McGhee
5. Vanessa Olivarez
6. Diana DeGarmo
7. Amy Adams

The rest are in no order.

8. Constantine Maroulis
9. Bo Bice
10. Carrie Underwood
11. Kelly Clarkson
12. Lindsey Cardinale

Why do my favorites get such low places? With the exception of like four of them.

Okay, these first ones are in order.

1. Jessica Sierra
2. Taylor Hicks
3. Camile Velasco
4. Melissa McGhee
5. Vanessa Olivarez
6. Diana DeGarmo
7. Amy Adams

The rest are in no order.

8. Constantine Maroulis
9. Bo Bice
10. Carrie Underwood
11. Kelly Clarkson
12. Lindsey Cardinale

Why do my favorites get such low places? With the exception of like four of them.

Nice. I would have expected to see Amy higher though :eek:

Nice. I would have expected to see Amy higher though :eek:
Amy sort of lost some respect from me a few summers ago. I still love her, but that whole thing just kind of spoiled it. And when I listen to her Sin Wagon, it's no longer better than Carrie's. Oh well.

Amy sort of lost some respect from me a few summers ago. I still love her, but that whole thing just kind of spoiled it. And when I listen to her Sin Wagon, it's no longer better than Carrie's. Oh well.

Aw may I ask why she lost some respect from you?

Aw may I ask why she lost some respect from you?
Do you remember the whole amy-adams.com debacle? Basically, she told this girl JJ that they were friends, and then just used her and ditched her. JJ was really upset and freaked out and deleted the site, and then Amy like, never came out to see her fans at the tour and it was just really bad and yeah. I mean, she still has my respect, but it's lowered.

Why do my favorites get such low places? With the exception of like four of them.

It's cuz you like the really underrated ones most. :D

Do you remember the whole amy-adams.com debacle? Basically, she told this girl JJ that they were friends, and then just used her and ditched her. JJ was really upset and freaked out and deleted the site, and then Amy like, never came out to see her fans at the tour and it was just really bad and yeah. I mean, she still has my respect, but it's lowered.

Oh wow :( That sucks. I definitely see why it lowered for you.

My top 12 in no order

Clay Aiken
Kelly Clarkson
Diana DeGarmo
Taylor Hicks
Tamyra Gray
Kellie Pickler
Ruben Studdard
Kimberly Caldwell
LaToya London
Justin Guarini
Chris Daughtry
Vonzell Solomon