You know how IDF plays those "Best Of" games for every season? Where you start with a specfic number of points for each weeks, and add and subtract from certain performances untill you have a winner? (Look on IDF under American Idol Past Seasons if I didn't explain right) Would y'all want to play one here?

sure lol. those games entertain me :lol:

let's start off with best American Idol season

how would you do that one?

let's start with what we're on now - Season 5. I'll open a new thread. David, close this please

how would you do that one?

let's start with what we're on now - Season 5. I'll open a new thread. David, close this please
no i mean do it to see what people think is the best AI season