I understand why they have edited episodes, I know some fans were complianing or disappointed with the extras so the company decided that is it, we are bringing Rue, Betty, and Arthur to do commentaries on one condition...they will have to accept edited episodes so it is one way or the other, edited episodes and no commentaries from Rue, Betty, and Arthur or have uncut episodes but no commenetaries from Rue, Betty, and Arthur..it makes sense to me...you would probably think I am stupid or something...

I understand why they have edited episodes, I know some fans were complianing or disappointed with the extras so the company decided that is it, we are bringing Rue, Betty, and Arthur to do commentaries on one condition...they will have to accept edited episodes so it is one way or the other, edited episodes and no commentaries from Rue, Betty, and Arthur or have uncut episodes but no commenetaries from Rue, Betty, and Arthur..it makes sense to me...you would probably think I am stupid or something...


If you are a REAL FAN why would you prefer commenetaries over UNCUT EPS?????-LOL

If you are a REAL FAN why would you prefer commenetaries over UNCUT EPS?????-LOL

Uhh, I prefer uncut episodes, I don't care about commentaries because I can't hear what they are saying and yeah, I am deaf

I rarely ever watch the extras on dvd's anyways. I prefer uncut episodes.

Again what proof do we have to say that Season 5 is indeed edited?

I don't get it. Why can't they have both commentaries and uncut episodes??? They can't sit down for an extra 3 minutes or something???

I don't think they are edit episodes!