For tonight! :woohoo:

David, please sticky. :)

I'm excited! I am now voting for Taylor. I hope he does good tonight. I would vote for Katherine but I know she will be safe.

I wish everyone GOOD LUCK tonight!

I'm excited! I am now voting for Taylor. I hope he does good tonight. I would vote for Katherine but I know she will be safe.


Taylor has a way higher shot at being safe than Katharine, in my opinion.

But anyway.


Taylor - Jailhouse Rock

8.5/10

I liked it! Again, Simon's right about it not being good in the real world and whatever, but it was definitely entertaining, and was a good way to kick off the show.

Where's eveyrone?

Taylor Hicks-Jailhosue Rock

AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I cnat believe Ims ayign this ,but he did a better job with it than JPL! :eek:

Chris Daughtry - Suspicious Minds

I can't say anything other that I liked it, and that it looks like it's gonna be a really intense night.

9/10

Elliott Yamin - If I Can Dream

AMAZING. Strongest vocal, by far. LOVEEED IT.

9.8/10

Katharine McPhee - Hound Dog/All Shook Up

Strong start, but sort of had an error in the middle. Overall, it was good, but I'm expecting her to do 100x better than that for her second song.

8.5/10

ok, i JUST got home...but my mom taped the first half for me :D

Taylor Hicks
"In the Ghetto"

i thought it was pretty good.

Randy: THAT WAS HOT! That's the type of record you should make
Paula: It showed a different side of you
Simon: Perfect song, much better then the first.

Chris Daughtry

really good performance!

Randy: THAT WAS HOT! It was the right key.
Paula: I loved it
Simon: It wasn't "you". It was ok

Chris Elliott ansd Kat were aaweosme

Taylor
s second, awesome, Chris AWESOME!!!! he did better than JPL

simon is so stupid...it's a low key song! he HAD to sing it that way.

Eliott Yamin

"Trouble"

hmm carrie sang this last year on top 5 week.

pretty good, but i think carrie did it better :lol: 9/10

Randy: Your best performance yet.
Paula: This is your best performance ever.
Simon: You deserve to go through to the next round

oh no, i have a feeling that kat is gonna be out now :(

Elliott, my fav from his, AWESOME!!!!!!!!!! but not as great as Carrie's though


I think Chris woulda done good with it too, but Elliott did awesome

Elliott, my fav from his, AWESOME!!!!!!!!!! but not as great as Carrie's though


I think Chris woulda done good with it too, but Elliott did awesome

Blah...I don't know if I liked Elliott's "Trouble"..I think I actually preferred the way Carrie did it, maybe because she had that fast part in it, so I was kind of looking forward to Elliott doing that too.

i'm really nervous for chris :(

Katharine McPhee

"Can't Help Falling in Love"

wow, really good! 9.5/10

Randy: Some pitchy problems, better then the first.
Paula: I thought the first one was better, I liked seeing you move.
Simon: Not your best night. The middle was so over-the-top. It was like apple pie with whipped cream (?).

Katahrine=AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!!

Damn Elliott was by far the BEST tonight. Most consistent, best vocals.. he really wants to win! I loved Carries Trouble, but man his was just so much better. I cannot wait for the MP3s of this.. by far my favorite AI episode! I really enjoyed Chris tonight, though JPL will always be the best at 'Conversation'. Taylor was amazing too. And Kat was horrid, eeeek. I was worried for Elliott, but after tonight I hope shes gone.

Katharine McPhee

"Can't Help Falling in Love"

wow, really good! 9.5/10

Randy: Some pitchy problems, better then the first.
Paula: I thought the first one was better, I liked seeing you move.
Simon: Not your best night. The middle was so over-the-top. It was like apple pie with whipped cream (?).
LOl the appie pie with too much extra cream meant she did it well, but then added 'too much cream'. In other words, she overdid it with all her singing and such instead of just singing the song straight forward.

Ienjoyed Chris tonight :D

I actually thought he did ALLC better than JPL, probably cause I liek Chris better

Elliott was superb tonight :D

I liked Taylor's second song more than his first.
I liked Chris's first song more than his second.
I liked Katharine's second song more than her first, and I don't think it was THAT bad. It was a very off night for her though.

Damn Elliott was by far the BEST tonight. Most consistent, best vocals.. he really wants to win! I loved Carries Trouble, but man his was just so much better. I cannot wait for the MP3s of this.. by far my favorite AI episode! I really enjoyed Chris tonight, though JPL will always be the best at 'Conversation'. Taylor was amazing too. And Kat was horrid, eeeek. I was worried for Elliott, but after tonight I hope shes gone.

You made me very happy by saying that, Crystal. :hug:

Anyway, I'm still watching the show, so I'll offer my critiques after I finish voting. :lol: Great show so far though! :woohoo:

i'm really nervous for chris :(

According to DialIdol, Chris is in last place. If any of you in the West Coast are reading this, please vote for Chris! He really needs the votes.

According to DialIdol, Chris is in last place. If any of you in the West Coast are reading this, please vote for Chris! He really needs the votes.

:eek2:

You made me very happy by saying that, Crystal. :hug:

Anyway, I'm still watching the show, so I'll offer my critiques after I finish voting. :lol: Great show so far though! :woohoo:
:lol:. My 'hatred' for Katharine is so strong, I dont have enough energy for Chris. I still dont like him, but he did sing my fav. Elvis songs and pretty well.

:lol:. My 'hatred' for Katharine is so strong, I dont have enough energy for Chris. I still dont like him, but he did sing my fav. Elvis songs and pretty well.
Good enough. :lol: It's nice to hear some positive comments from a non-Chris fan. :thumbsup:

To sum it all up...

Taylor was great! I hated Simon's comment about Jailhouse Rock...I personally loved all of it. :D And I LOVED how he toned it down with In the Ghetto.

Chris was :biglove: . I actually liked his second song better than the first...that was hot.

People are going to jump all over me for saying this, but I honestly don't think Elliott's performance was as good as most people are making it out to be. :o It was a reaaallly good vocal, but not his best (I'll probably change my mind after rewatching it though :lol: ). However, Trouble was AMAZING!

Katharine was just good. It wasn't her night tonight.

Anyway, DialIdol is showing that Kat and Chris are in the bottom two, with Chris leaving. I'll be VERY upset if that happens...he'll be the most robbed Idol contestant EVER if he leaves now, IMO. :cuss:

Sorry Kat, I love you and all, but you go bye-bye. :wave:

I really felt Elliot shined the brightest during last night's performances... Taylor's second song was great. I am a bit afraid for Katharine tonight, however...

I hope u all voted like CRAZY last night for Katharine!!! She did the best, IMO, but I couldn't get through for her at all!

Sorry but I voted for Taylor. He did great last night. I only got in 75 votes on the second line. The first line I couldn't get through.

According to DialIdol, Chris is in last place. If any of you in the West Coast are reading this, please vote for Chris! He really needs the votes.

I just looked at it and I am absolutely shocked. :eek: omg:

I hope u all voted like CRAZY last night for Katharine!!! She did the best, IMO, but I couldn't get through for her at all!
i was too busy voting for chris...but chris and katharine are the bottom 2 according to dialidol :(

1-2
Taylor Hicks 29.749 1.533 -
1-2
Elliott Yamin 29.181 1.539 -
3-4
Katharine McPhee 25.623 1.577 -
3-4
Chris Daughtry 25.241

man, it sure is close. at this point any of them could be in the bottom 2.

I actually never vote, but I tried at various times for Elliott.

I could not get through once over the course of 2 hours using both lines.
(of course I don't have the patience to keep redialing more than five times at a clip)

I assume that's a good sign for him.

I just looked at it and I am absolutely shocked. :eek: omg:


Remember when Kellie and Paris were in the bottom 2. Also Bucky and Lisa. But Kellie and Lisa went home instead of Paris and Bucky. So I think, no I KNOW for sure that Chris is SAFE. It just look like he's going home. Don't worry Chris fans. Keep the faith.

I hope u all voted like CRAZY last night for Katharine!!! She did the best, IMO, but I couldn't get through for her at all!

I voted for Chris. :p I'm really worried for him though. :(

I actually never vote, but I tried at various times for Elliott.

I could not get through once over the course of 2 hours using both lines.
(of course I don't have the patience to keep redialing more than five times at a clip)

I assume that's a good sign for him.
Awesome! Yeah it was really busy up here, and I live in such a small town my lines are hardly ever busy. I was able to get through so easily last year, but this year not so much.

I didn't get a chance to post last night after voting, so I will post my thoughts now.

Taylor - First song was ok, and his second song was great.

Chris - Both songs were great, but I liked his first one better.

Elliott - Both songs were great! I thought his version of "Trouble" was much better than Carrie's.

Katharine - First song was terrible. I thought her second song wasn't as bad as the judges said, I thought it was pretty decent.

I voted for the whole two hours for Elliott. I really hope he does not leave tonight, it would be really unfair. I'm not a Chris fan, but I don't want him to leave tonight either. He did very well! I think Taylor will be safe, as always. Sorry, but I think it's Katharine's time to go.