this doesnt ALL have to do with the girls, but some song choice spoilers

source:
http://www.mjsbigblog.com/

Ayla Brown - a Celine Dion song

Will Makar - "Lady" by Lionel Richie

Ace - "If You're Not the One" by Daniel Bedingfield

David Radford - "The Way You Look Tonight" - Standard, by Frank Sinatra and others, recently done by Rod Stewart

Taylor Hicks - "Easy" - by The Commodores, I believe

my opinion on the spoilers

- i think ayla can pull off celene, bit she's gonna have to work hard at it. i just hope its not "power of love" or "my heart will go on".
- david should do awesome with his song
- will should do well with his song
- ace should be awesome at his song
- taylor is the only one im "iffy" about. i think he couldve picked a better song, but we'll see.

Awesome song choices :D


Taylor, ehh his is iffy

eeeeeekkkk yay!! :woohoo:

I can't wait!!! So far I think my favorite girl singer is Kellie & Lisa!

^mine are katherine and ayla, i like kellie too though

my favorites of the whole season are chris and david though

From the Fox boards -

Kellie Pickler- "I Hope You'd Dance" by LeAnn Womack
Ayla Brown- "All By Myself" by Celine Dion
Melissa McGhee- "Concrete Angel" by Martina McBride
Heather Cox- "Knock on Wood" by ____
Kinik Sky- "Neither One of Us" by Gladys Knight
Katharine McPhee- "Wind Beneath My Wings" by Bette Midler
Lisa Tucker- "When You Believe" duet by Whitney Houston and Mariah C
Paris Bennet- "A Moment Like This" by Kelly Clarkson
Brenna Gethers- "Black Velvet" by ?
Mandisa- "Lean On Me" by several people. not sure who originially sang it.

A Moment Like This? O______________________________O

hint for paris: NEVER....EVER...CHOOSE....A KELLY CLARKSON SONG.

ESPECIALLY if it was her WINNERS SINGLE from the show!!

the others seem like good choices

Kellie Pickler- "I Hope You'd Dance" by LeAnn Womack
good song choice, she can do amazing with this
Ayla Brown- "All By Myself" by Celine Dion
ambitious song choice...shes gonna have to work HARD at it...but i think she can pull it off
Melissa McGhee- "Concrete Angel" by Martina McBride
im guessing we'll be hearing martina every week this season? oh well...at least its not "a broken wing", which is probably the most overdone country song on AI. ANYWAY...i think she can pull it off and it could potentially be AMAZING...
Heather Cox- "Knock on Wood" by ____
mehh this song is so overdone. but i think she can do well with it.
Kinik Sky- "Neither One of Us" by Gladys Knight
ehh weird choice. i dont think it'll be anything special. she'll do well with it but it wont be OMGOGMGOGMGO and will probably be forgetton by the end of the night
Katharine McPhee- "Wind Beneath My Wings" by Bette Midler
agh, im not a fan of this song at all. but...i think she can do a great job with it.
Lisa Tucker- "When You Believe" duet by Whitney Houston and Mariah C
she can do well with this
Paris Bennet- "A Moment Like This" by Kelly Clarkson
wow, what an awful song choice. its gonna be compared to kelly majorly. not a good choice..she'll do well with it, but it wont really matter since it'll be compared so much. -_-
Brenna Gethers- "Black Velvet" by ?
ehh this song doesnt really show off her "wild side", but she can do ok with it
Mandisa- "Lean On Me" by several people. not sure who originially sang it.
i absolutley hate this song with a PASSSSSSSSSSSSSSION. aaaaagh. i hope she does well with it...but i dont know. the judges are probably gonna call it safe too

david, can you sticky this?

katherine and kinnik first...

way to brag, judges :p

yay showtime!

Kathatine McPhee

"All is Fair in Love"- Stevie Wonder

its not as good as last week IMO. she's taking it slower. but very good vocals. i give it a 9/10...down from last week, when i gave her a 10/10

Randy: Safe song, it wasn't your best. Not a good song choice. It was just ok
Paula: You're gifted, but it was a bad song choice, however, it will still a nice performance.
Simon: You were in your own world. It was forgetable.

:eek:

i didnt love katharine, but i didnt think it was as bad as the judges thought

i dont think t'll hurt her though, carrie's last 2 semi performances werent the best either

I thought she was doing Wind Beneath My Wings?


Anyways, wasnt as awesome as last week, but stil lgood

katharine - all in love is fair

she sings it pretty straight and does it well, but compared to last week, it kind of fell short. the song didn't really allow her to be amazing. definitely good, but it wasn't spectacular.

I thought she was doing Wind Beneath My Wings?


spoilers arent always right :lol:

Kinnik Sky

a Gretchen Wilson song

good performance. much better then last week. not forgettable, thank god. vocals are kinda "ehh", but she's performing it well. 8.7/10

Randy: Good energy. Good song, but it didn't show your range. But it was entertaining
Paula: It was fun, but you need to showcase your range. Take a risk.
Simon: Last week you were forgotten. This week, you stood out of the crowd. But on the down side, it was like something I would see when I get off of Magic Mountain in Disney World. It was a "theme park performance".

Paula: I would love to see Simon on a roller coaster :lol: Would you smile?

spoilers arent always right :lol:
Right :lol:


Kinnk was pretty good , better than last week

RANKINGS:
Katharine- 9/10
Kinnik- 8/10

so far, no one's "wowed" me. i hope this show isnt a disapointment...

Kinnik was okay. She didn't really stretch vocally, it was like all in one 5-note range, so it sounded basically the same the whole time. Not great.

OT but this underground cave show looks so dumb. lol

Lisa Tucker

some Micheal Jackson song.

eck, another not so great performance. but its probably the best so far. it just gets off to a rough start. it gets better towards the middle/end. 9/10

Randy: You can sing, this song choice didnt show it. Just "aight"
Paula: You've got it. I forgot that you're 16, you're an amazing performer, you're a star.
Simon: You'll sail through tonight

lisa = best so far

Melissa McGhee

"Why Haven't I Heard From You"

ehh. ok vocal...good performance. gets better towards the end. 8.9/10

Randy: That song fit you perfectly, you can make a record with that. Your "smoky voice" returned. That was HOT
Paula: You came out of your shell, I love your voice, I can hear you on the radiop
Simon: Love your voice, wrong song. You haven't made a connection yet. It didnt have the "wow" factor.

SAULA FIGHT!!! :woohoo: :rofl:

he called her a child :eek:

RANDY AND PAULA CHANGES SEATS :rotflmao:

very blah show. not impressed so far. im not even sure if im gonna vote...

i might give a few votes to katharine, but she didnt impress me...so im not sure.

RANKINGS:
Lisa- 9/10
Katharine- 9/10
Melissa- 8.9/10
Kinnik- 8/10

Heather Cox

"Hero"- Mariah Carey

:rofl: SHE'S IDOL OBSESSED LIKE US!!! she tapes every episode and re-watches it

lol she had a snake around her neck in Hollywood

oh wow, MUCH better then last week. like...MILES better. its kind of a boring song, but she's singing it well. she's good this week. 8.6/10

Paula: Improvement from last week, but there's one big problem, but you ran a huge risk of being compared to Mariah, you did a good job, but it wasnt great
Randy: You're gonna pale in comparison. Not a good song choice
Simon: It was like a ghastly paegent

i didnt even think it was that bad, but ok...

Rankings
Lisa- 9/10
Katharine- 9/10
Melissa- 8.9/10
Heather- 8.7/10
Kinnik- 8/10

what a boring episode. this episode proved my point of why the girls dont impress me this season.

so far this show has been bleh. =( hopefully paris, kellie, ayla, and mandisa can make it better.

so far this show has been bleh. =( hopefully paris, kellie, ayla, and mandisa can make it better.
yeah aggh, if none of them do well, i dont know if im even gonna vote more then 5 times

need to get my voting figures rested for MAJOR VOTING tomorrow anyway :D

Brenna Gethers

"Last Dance"- Donna Summer

isnt that a "cursed" song on AI? :lol:

she reminds me SO...MUCH of Mikalah...:lol:


vocally, not good. but at least its more exciting then last week. but honeslly, vocally, its not that good. 6.5/10

Paula: I dont see that "magic" happening from you.
Randy: Attitude and vocals werent there. Vocally pitchy. Not inspired.
Simon: It was your last chance, and you blew it. It was like someone singing a Donna Summer song at a bar.

LISA WAS AWESOME!!!


Heather was great too

Melissa too was great

Brenna.........goodbye


and Simon YOU ARE MY ****ING IDOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Paris Bennett

"Wind Beneath My Wings"

boring song, but she's singing it well. i dont really like her, but probably one of the best so far. 9/10 (thank god shes not singing A Moment Like This though -_-)

Paula: You're an amazing performer, a young one who "glows". You make this competition in celebrate. But you need to celebrate the fun and the youth
Randy: You've got it, you can sing. But you played it safe this week. You need to be "the hot young one", not as good as last week, but you're still hot
Simon: You were boring. You turned this show into "I'm 17 and I sing like I''m 50".

ack, even paris got bad song judges comments...bad night tonight.

Where are you people?


Paris was good, but yeah I agree, if youure 17 dont sing a song that makes you look 50

Where are you people?


Paris was good, but yeah I agree, if youure 17 dont sing a song that makes you look 50
But yeah one of the best so far

Rankings

Lisa- 9/10
Katharine- 9/10
Paris- 9/10
Melissa- 8.9/10
Heather- 8.7/10
Kinnik- 8/10
Brenna- 6.5/10

AGH -_-

Where are you people?


Paris was good, but yeah I agree, if youure 17 dont sing a song that makes you look 50
lol didnt simon say almost the same thing to fantasia on top 11 night in AI3?

anyway im here :) :wave:

Ayla Brown

something by Celine Dion...

ayla starts out good. then she gets AMAZING. probably the best so far. 9.5/10

Paula: You want this really bad, another week you pleasently surprised me. You're growing, if I could put my knees on you I could do everything I could do
Randy: Love the backstory (where you admitted you were a tomboy), good song choice, nice package, i liked it
Simon: You're working hard then anyone, you can do anything you put your mind too. But sometimes, you are a bit ____ to something (didnt catch what he said). I'll remember you as being good, but won't remember the song. Kind of mechanical.

i think she was the best so far

Kellie Pickler

"Something to Talk About"- Bonnie Wright

DOGS WITH CLOTHES :rofl: AND CALAMARI


really good for kellie. one of the better ones of the night. very good. good performance and vocal. 10/10...BEST OF THE NIGHT! :)

Paula: Can you get any cuter? Good song choice, you made us smile and dance, great song choice, I enjoyed this performance.
Randy: WE GOT A HOT ONE TONIGHT!!! You did your "thang"
Simon: You're so likable, but it wasnt the best vocal. But I think you're "calamari" thing will get a lot of votes. America will fall in love with you

i love her, but dont want her to win

Oh Kellie Pickler. She cracks me up. I think she was the best so far tonight, even though it wasn't like unbelievable.

lala blah night. kellie and ayla were the best of the night so far. hopeully, mandisa will close the show with a "bang"! :)

lol didnt simon say almost the same thing to fantasia on top 11 night in AI3?

anyway im here :) :wave:
I think so


Ayla and Kellie were AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!

My rankings so far

1. Kellie Pickler
2. Paris Bennett
3. Katharine McPhee
4. Ayla Brown
5. Lisa Tucker
6. Melissa McGhee
7. Brenna Gethers
8. Kinnik Sky
9. Heather Cox

I'm sure Mandisa will come in my top 3 though :)

i hope david does well tomorrow (kinda OT though)

Final Rankings
1. Kellie Pickler
2. Paris Bennett
3. Mandisa
4. Katharine McPhee
5. Ayla Brown
6. Lisa Tucker
7. Melissa McGhee
8. Brenna Gethers
9. Kinnik Sky
10. Heather Cox

Mandisa

ROFL at the dog jaw trick :rotflmao:

VERY good. probably the best of the night. 10/10. ended with a BANG...shes gonna go far

Paula: You're one of a kind, you're needed in this competition, you put your own flavor in songs
Randy: Rough verses, but it got better when you belted it. You have great vocals. Not a great song choice. I didnt hear it "all"
Simon: I think America will keep you around for a while, but bad image this week. Not the right song ch oice. But you are the best female singer in this competiton

best of the night IMO :)

Final Rankings

1. Mandisa- 10/10
2. Kellie Pickler- 10/10
3. Ayla Brown- 9.5/10
4. Lisa Tucker- 9/10
5. Katherine McPhee- 9/10
6. Paris Bennett- 9/10
7. Melissa McGhee- 8.9/10
8. Heather Cox- 8.7/10
9. Kinnik Sky- 8/10
10. Brenna Gethers- 6/10

MANDISA WAS AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!


To the dogjaw thing LMAO:rotflmao:

I'm voting for Kellie, Katharine, and Mandisa :)

i voted for kellie, katharine, and ayla a little bit. i gave katharine and ayla like 20 votes and kellie like 5. no one wowed me, so i didnt do any power voting tonight

i tried voting for mandisa, but her line was busy, so i gave up

My ranking:
1. LISA!!!!!!
2. Mandisa
3. Ayla
4. Paris
5. Katharine
6. Kellie
7. Melissa
8. Heather
9. Kinnik

GINORMOUS GAP


10. Brenna

I thought Lisa was great tonight! I don't know what the judges are talking about. Mandisa was great too and I agree with the judges that Ayla is really showing improvement. I was a little disappointed with Katharine though... it was a bad choice of song for her. Speaking of bad choices, or just bad in general, I can't stand Brenna. I'm sorry, but I just want to slap that girl silly and then some. To me, she's like the female version of Scott Savol... but prettier and sometimes funnier. I am hoping she leaves on Thursday...PLEEEASE!

was paris flapping her arms like wings when she sang the word "flyyyyyyyyyyy"? the view was a little too close up to tell but that's what it looked like, me and my brother were laughing like crazy.

i hope david does well tomorrow (kinda OT though)
Me too, and Will too.

Anyway, my favorites of the night were Paris and Madisa. They did really well!!! I also thought Heather did a pretty good job...I didn't think it was bad like the judges said. I also liked Kellie. My predictions are that Brenna and Kinnik are going to leave (I thought Kinnik did really well last week, but this week wasn't very good, IMO).

AYLA ROCKS YOUR WORLD YO.

My favorite last night was Kellie! :D
She did AWESOME!!!

omg am I the only one who spent an hour and a half trying to vote but couldn't get in once?! lol oh well I guess that means people are doing good voting for Kellie!!

AYLA ROCKS YOUR WORLD YO.
she was awesome last night. i think shes gonna be the darkhorse this year

omg am I the only one who spent an hour and a half trying to vote but couldn't get in once?! lol oh well I guess that means people are doing good voting for Kellie!!
kellie's line was busy for me, but katharine's line was really clear. i voted for a whole 30 minutes and was probably able to get in 15-20 times

I think I voted too many times.... 938 for Ayla :eek:

I voted for Kellie and couldn't get in half of the first hour and some in the second hour.