View Full Version : DVD+R or DVD-R. Which do you perfer?


KristinHerreraFan
01-24-2006, 07:46 PM
When burning dvd discs, which do you perfer to use? I for one choose DVD-R THAT'S DVD MINUS R!!! DVD+R wont play in every DVD Player and is very risky. Give me DVD-R over DVD+R's anyday!

Polniaczek033
01-24-2006, 08:21 PM
i don't know the difference. hahahaha.
but i chose dvd+r because adding is easier than subtracting.
:lol:

KristinHerreraFan
01-24-2006, 08:30 PM
LOL!

theshark8777
01-24-2006, 10:16 PM
I have never had a problem with DVD+R compatibility and that was the first drive I bought, but personally I don't care which I use now.

The real discussion we will be having is when they have the HD DVD, Blu Ray format war. That's just bad for the consumers.

dawsongirl
01-25-2006, 02:44 AM
When burning dvd discs, which do you perfer to use? I for one choose DVD-R THAT'S DVD MINUS R!!! DVD+R wont play in every DVD Player and is very risky. Give me DVD-R over DVD+R's anyday!
Actually it's the other way around.


But I use both and have never had compatibility trouble with anything but my laptop, which is junk anyway.

Brent88
01-25-2006, 03:52 AM
My Recorder only uses +R so that's what I use.

Oh and if you finalize the disc, - or + it should play in other players. If it's not finalized, it'll only play in the recorder it was made in.

swedeace
01-25-2006, 10:29 AM
I prefer DVD-R because that's what works to burn DVDs viewable on my DVD player.

robyrob
01-25-2006, 11:47 AM
whats on sale this week?

SBTB Geek
01-25-2006, 01:05 PM
Isn't DVD-R most compatible with other systems?

KristinHerreraFan
01-25-2006, 06:42 PM
DVD-R's are compatible with 90% of every DVD Player. DVD+R are only compatible with the newer systems, will play on about 60% of all DVD Players.

theshark8777
01-25-2006, 06:53 PM
DVD-R's are compatible with 90% of every DVD Player. DVD+R are only compatible with the newer systems, will play on about 60% of all DVD Players.

Well I don't know when that changed but when I got my first burner 3 years ago, the DVD+R played on more machines than the -R. Any new one should play both theroretically. Although my new DVD recorder won't play DVD+R DL discs burned in my computer, but plays DVD+R and -R, but my old DVD players play the DL and the regular ones.

Ireneparalegal
01-25-2006, 06:55 PM
This poll will close on Jan. 2022?????!!!!by then, it won't matter which DVD (+ or -) you prefer.:crazy:

EmoJoe
01-25-2006, 06:59 PM
i dont even know the difference :lookaroun

theshark8777
01-25-2006, 07:08 PM
Here is a little info on the DVD+R:

No other format can match DVD+R/+RW's functionality, simplicity and compatibility. DVD+R/+RW was designed from the beginning with both data and video recording uses in mind. Compatibility with existing DVD players and DVD-ROM drives is a major strength of the DVD+R/+RW format. Because there are no confusing recording modes, you don't have make trade-offs between compatibility and flexibility.

DVD+RW video recorders allow users to add, delete or divide titles, overwrite titles in whole or in part, create or modify play lists and make other changes without losing compatibility with existing DVD players, unlike other formats. DVD+R/+RW also allows instant use and instant eject - you don't have to wait for the disc to format or finalize. And DVD+R/+RW recorders offer the same type of operation you're used to seeing on DVD players.

For PC users, DVD+RW offers direct editing on disc, background formatting so you don't have to wait before you can use the disc, built-in defect management, multi-session writing, and other unique recording features. DVD+R/+RW uses the same disc for both video and data. You can share recordings between your home electronics and computer equipment, add new recordings or even edit directly on the same disc. Furthermore, DVD+R Double Layer technology allows for storage of up to 8.5 GB of data on a single sided disc.

Supported by leading companies such as Dell, HP, Philips, Sony, Ricoh and close to one hundred other hardware and software leaders, DVD+R/+RW is the smart format for beginners and experts alike.

MsOrange
01-26-2006, 07:38 AM
so +R means you do not have to finalize it? What does -R mean?

dawsongirl
01-26-2006, 02:58 PM
so +R means you do not have to finalize it? What does -R mean?
Yes, you still have to finalize +R. + or - RW doesn't have to be finalized. I don't know the difference between the two, except that +R is definetly more compatible, despite what people keep saying.

I also know my recorder that does both +R and -R finalizes the -R slower than +R. Don't know why though.

dawsongirl
01-26-2006, 02:58 PM
Here is a little info on the DVD+R:

No other format can match DVD+R/+RW's functionality, simplicity and compatibility. DVD+R/+RW was designed from the beginning with both data and video recording uses in mind. Compatibility with existing DVD players and DVD-ROM drives is a major strength of the DVD+R/+RW format. Because there are no confusing recording modes, you don't have make trade-offs between compatibility and flexibility.

DVD+RW video recorders allow users to add, delete or divide titles, overwrite titles in whole or in part, create or modify play lists and make other changes without losing compatibility with existing DVD players, unlike other formats. DVD+R/+RW also allows instant use and instant eject - you don't have to wait for the disc to format or finalize. And DVD+R/+RW recorders offer the same type of operation you're used to seeing on DVD players.

For PC users, DVD+RW offers direct editing on disc, background formatting so you don't have to wait before you can use the disc, built-in defect management, multi-session writing, and other unique recording features. DVD+R/+RW uses the same disc for both video and data. You can share recordings between your home electronics and computer equipment, add new recordings or even edit directly on the same disc. Furthermore, DVD+R Double Layer technology allows for storage of up to 8.5 GB of data on a single sided disc.

Supported by leading companies such as Dell, HP, Philips, Sony, Ricoh and close to one hundred other hardware and software leaders, DVD+R/+RW is the smart format for beginners and experts alike.
:thumbsup: Read this post, people.

gilligan fanatic
01-26-2006, 03:00 PM
DVD-R it's cheaper

theshark8777
01-26-2006, 05:06 PM
Actually I have to finalize DVD-RW to get them to play in other players. I don't have to do that with DVD+RWs though.

KristinHerreraFan
01-26-2006, 05:08 PM
I HATE RW'S I WILL NEVER USE THOSE!!

theshark8777
01-26-2006, 05:10 PM
I HATE RW'S I WILL NEVER USE THOSE!!

RWs are good for editing and whatnot, but after you have a finished product, I would always put it on an DVDR.

Michael [hXc]
01-26-2006, 07:52 PM
when i first saw the title of this thread i thought it was about DDR, that dancing game (Dance, Dance Revolution). :lol: :p