Title says all :D Rank the winners debut albums

1. Carrie Underwood- Some Hearts
WOW!!!! This was an amazing debut! Defintiley the best Idol debut yet. It has AWESOME songs and I love the country/pop mix. I like every song (well...except IYH -_-)
Rating: 122232434343434/10
Favorite song: Starts With Goodbye

2. Kelly Clarkson- Thankful
I LOVE Kelly, and I really liked this CD, but I thought her 2nd CD was a lot better. There's a lot of good songs, but some of the songs are kinda boring and not in the same leauge as some of the better ones. I love Thankful, but Breakaway is a better CD.
Rating: 9/10
Favorite song: Just Missed the Train

3. Fantasia Barrno- Free Yourself
Havent heard the whole album, but from what I've heard...meh. I dont really like hip-hop music though.
Rating: 6/10
Favorite song: Free Yourself

havent heard any of Ruben's.

Clay Aiken - Measure Of A Man
10. My favorite CD ever. MY CD has been through hell and back, its in such poor shape... and I got 3 copies!!! :lol:

Kelly Clarkson - Thankful
9/10. Amazing CD, but when compared to Breakaway, it really doesnt come close.

Carrie Underwood - Some Hearts
9/10. This CD is amazing even though Im not a country fan by nature. I think if they forced her to go pop, the CD wouldve been crap.