haven't had a new idol thread in a while!

so there's the question -- how do you think each american idol should have layed out, in terms of where each contestant gets voted off. you can base this on how much YOU like the contestant. it doesn't have to be unbiased.

season 1
1. kelly clarkson
2. tamyra gray
3. rj helton
4. justin guarini
5. nikki mckibbin
6. christina christian
7. ryan starr
8. ejay day
9. aj gil
10. jim verraros

season 2
1. clay aiken
2. kimberley locke
3. kimberly caldwell
4. trenyce
5. ruben studdard
6. carmen rasmusen
7. joshua gracin
8. rickey smith
9. julia demato
10. vanessa olivarez
11. charles grigsby
12. corey clark

season 3
1. diana degarmo
2. latoya london
3. jasmine trias
4. george huff
5. fantasia barrino
6. jennifer hudson
7. jon peter lewis
8. john stevens
9. amy adams
10. camile velasco
11. leah labelle
12. matt rogers

season 4
1. carrie underwood
2. anthony fedorov
3. bo bice
4. vonzell solomon
5. jessica sierra
6. mikalah gordon
7. anwar robinson
8. lindsey cardinale
9. nadia turner
10. constantine maroulis
11. nikko smith
12. scott savol

Hww well i've only seen the complete seasons of AI3 and AI4 so I'll only do those ;)

AI3
1. Diana DeGarmo
2. Jasmine Trias
3. LaToya London
4. George Huff
5. Jon Peter Lewis
6. ehh...Fantasia Barrino
7. Jennifer Hudson
8. John Stevens
9. Amy Adams
10. Camile Velasco
11. Matt Rogers
12. Leah LaBelle

AI4
1. Carrie Underwood
2. Bo Bice
3. Anthony Fedorov (2 and 3 could be switched)
4. Jessica Sierra
5. Vonzell Solomon
6. Constantine Maroluis
7. Nikko Smith
8. Anwar Robsinson
9. Nadia Turner
10. Lindsey Cardinale
11. Mikalah Gordon
12. ...Scott Savol. Definitley

Aaah I cant wait until AI5! 29 days...or something :p

season 1
1. Kelly Clarkson
2. Tamyra Gray
3. Christina Christian
4. Justin Guarini
5. RJ Helton
6. Nikki McKibbin
7. Ryan Starr
8. Jim Verraros
9. AJ Gil
10. Ejay Day

season 2
1. Clay Aiken
2. Kimberley Locke
3. Trenyce
4. Rickey Smith
5. Joshua Gracin
6. Ruben Studdard
7. Kimberly Caldwell
8. Charles Grigsby
9. Carmen Rasmusen
10. Julia Demato
11. Vanessa Olivarez
12. Corey Clark

season 3
1. Diana DeGarmo
2. LaToya
3. George Huff
4. Jennifer Hudson
5. Jon Peter Lewis
6. Fantasia
7. John Stevens
8. Amy Adams
9. Jasmine Trias
10. Matt Rogers
11. Camile Velasco
12. Leah LaBelle

season 4
1. Bo Bice
2. Carrie Underwood
3. Anthony Fedorov
4. Constantine Maroulis
5. Vonzell Solomon
6. Nikko Smith
7. Jessica Sierra
8. Nadia Turner
9. Scott Savol
10. Mikalah Gordon
11. Anwar Robinson
12. Lindsay Cardinale

And I didnt base mine [fully] on strictly my favorites, since we've already done threads on those and everyone knows who we all favor. :) I tried to base it on overall vocal talent and personality.