Who do you thhink will always will remeber of TAmerica Idol SerioSeason 1,season2,season,4season3, and who would be the best and the worst,or trying there best, And did you think that Clay should of won instead of Rubeb for being the next American Idol


Number 2 season I thought Clay Atkin was one of the best singers in part 4, Why would any aboy wanted Ruben is being me.Clay Atkin has done work scince he left the show,Ruben has his own bus,and band members smoking pot, now how do we tell rubens fans that some of his band members smokes this was laset year, and I have not hear anything bad from Clay,Fantasia she can't read,but she can get help for it and yes she is the greatest singer from 3. Kelly Clarkson will always be Kelly Clarkson, she is a songbird.

Carrie + Kelly= Happy Joe

I think Clay, Kelly and Carrie will always be remembered most for AI. Ruben too, but mostly because of the whole Clay vs. Ruben ordeal. I agree when you said Clay shouldve won, but oh well. In a way Im glad he lost, though it wouldve been nice for him to win because he truly deserved it.

I think a lot of people will remember John Stevens too. And Constantine. As for all other idols, theyll be remembered but all the other names will come to minds beforehand, IMO.