There are just certain shows that can't go on without "ONE" person in particular. The biggest star of "Tree Hill" is Chad Michael Murray as Lucas. So we know the show is toast without him....Anyway, LOL, my question is, who CAN the show go on without? (of the kids)

Nathan
Peyton
Hailey
Brooke

I choose Brooke. She's a great character, and Sophia's hott, but I think if she left, it wouldn't really affect the show.

All of these characters are vital parts of the show. But my choice goes to Nathan, since without him, the core center of the storyline wouldn't be there...the relationship between two brothers.

Who do you think they could get rid of and it won't affect the show that much?

Who do you think they could get rid of and it won't affect the show that much?

I don't think there is a character they could get rid of and not have the show affected too much. I want them to bring Keith back by the way, but since he has been absent for a while, and the show is still going strong, I guess he would be their weakest link??! But I love Keith!

I kinda miss Kieth too. I think they are stalling to bring him back because we're supposed to believe it was him who set the place on fire.

I don't think it would lose much if Brooke left, they could always change Lucus's love life over