View Full Version : Harry's tv trick...bogus??
McFly121 11-04-2005, 03:31 AM Seemed really far-fetched, his responses pre-taped to Mrs. Cunningham, perfectly timed and with the right questions.
I think a more realistic approach would've been to have him talking live in the hallway, and pre-tape the "Am I the real Harry Stone?" I thought he might have but he said "I taped this just a few minutes ago." Well, which part? The questions, or "Am I the real...."?
ekkostar 11-04-2005, 01:17 PM I actually thought he was filming out in the hallway until he said otherwise.
By the way, I loved how Dan kept breaking TV's 4th wall by talking directly to the camera. It reminded me of Malcolm in the Middle, but he was hamming it up. :)
HaskellGirl 11-04-2005, 04:05 PM I agree with ekkostar...I think he was filming in the hallway until the end there...it WAS pretty tricky and something not everyone could pull off, but the fact that Harry is a magician means he can do cool tricks that most people can't...he can fool someone and get away with it. I mean, it was obviously taped for the show, but I think if someone else had tried to do it, it woudln't have made much sense. But since its Harry, I'm not surprised it went so smoothly, if that makes sense.
nitcrt1 11-04-2005, 05:22 PM I thought the process was a bit odd myself. I know there is a trick to it. I'll pose this question to my brother. (He used to work for a local news station.) He may know how this could have been done. I'll get back to you all if I get an answer.
ClassicTVGal 11-04-2005, 09:01 PM I actually liked it. I've seen it preformed on other programs on TV. Of course it *is* a television show, so they can fake a lot of things. lol
MikeLutton 11-04-2005, 09:49 PM anyone Notice she used her last name on Night court as she did on Happy days Miss Cunningham did she mention Happy days or refrences in her list of shows that would been funny
HaskellGirl 11-04-2005, 09:59 PM anyone Notice she used her last name on Night court as she did on Happy days Miss Cunningham did she mention Happy days or refrences in her list of shows that would been funny
She did refer to Happy Days...when she was listing off characters, she ended with "The Fonz", which got a big laugh, although I thought it was kinda cheesy.;)
nitcrt1 11-05-2005, 02:31 PM Ladies and gentleman....what Harry did is not bogus. According to my brother, who has a degree in communications and worked for a lacal tv station, what Harry did is absolutely possible. He said if Harry anticipated certain questions Mrs. Daley was going to ask I believe he did have an inkling), he would have had no problem taping open ended responses. All you would have to do is leave pauses for any type of resopnse on her end. Now, if they were having a full conversation (like you would person to person) then it would be far fetched. However, Harry's comments and responses were very logical to the situation. Therfore, I feel he knew what he was doing given the situation. I think he did know or feel what she was going to ask. The trick was in knowing what order she was going to ask the questions. There is where he took a gamble.
So, in short, what Harry did was not bogus. It was smart!
nitcrt1 11-05-2005, 02:34 PM Ladies and gentleman....what Harry did is not bogus. According to my brother, who has a degree in communications and worked for a local tv station, what Harry did is absolutely possible. He said if Harry anticipated certain questions Mrs. Daley was going to ask (I believe he did have an inkling), he would have had no problem taping open ended responses. All you would have to do is leave pauses for any type of resopnse on her end. Now, if they were having a full conversation (like you would person to person) then it would be far fetched. However, Harry's comments and responses were very logical to the situation. Therfore, I feel he knew what he was doing given the situation. I think he did know or feel what she was going to ask. The trick was in knowing what order she was going to ask the questions. There is where he took a gamble.
So, in short, what Harry did was not bogus. It was smart!
McFly121 11-06-2005, 02:06 AM I'm not doubting it was smart (it proved to Mrs. Daly that tv and reality are two different things), but if you watch the sequence, if he pre-taped his responses, they were awfully perfect to be real. "Was he sick..no...did he die...no" all came so quick. His questions were appropriate like being sick, or dying, and "What happened to him?". My real complaint was with the timing of it all. And there seemed to be no wire leading into the courtroom. Though there would have to be a tv plug wire, but I've already erased the ep so I don't remember.
nitcrt1 11-06-2005, 09:17 AM Again, I don't disagree with you here either. I'd have to watch the episode again. Yet, I think there may have been a possible connection with the fact that they were filming on closed circuit TV during the episode as well. It's a good question to investigate further. The writers had to know what they were doing technically though. They worked in television, so I imagine they had an idea of how something like this could be pulled off.
McFly121 11-07-2005, 08:13 AM Yeah, sometimes they're funny on sitcoms. Family never has a tv visible, then when something tv-related is shown, all of a sudden a tv is there, then the next episode its gone. Plus you can see no wires leading off-camera, I guess it looks tacky. Hehe.
|