Just out of curiosity, because I've noticed the Kelly/Carrie fandemonium here, but no love for the other two Idols!

If no one responds to this thread with anything positive to say about Ruben or Fantasia...then that's kinda :(. I'm already assuming that no one here likes either of them. :lol:

i think everyone here was a diana fan last year. there were a few ruben fans. i obviously didnt get along with them very well back then.

to be honest, they both grew on me after the competition ended. i didnt like fantasia in season three because she was the competition of diana. i didnt like ruben in season 2 because he was the competition of clay. that's just how it works. but, they are pretty good. i actually got ruben's CD (soulful), i have yet to get fantasia's.

to be honest, they both grew on me after the competition ended. i didnt like fantasia in season three because she was the competition of diana. i didnt like ruben in season 2 because he was the competition of clay. that's just how it works. but, they are pretty good. i actually got ruben's CD (soulful), i have yet to get fantasia's.
Good to hear. Even though I liked Clay and Diana better (Like most of you), Ruben and Fantasia have both grown on me as well. But...I think I like Ruben's voice better and I think Fantasia's music is better. :)

I LOVED both of them right from the very beginning! I could see something special in both of them. Fantasia blew me away. I swear I'm Simon Cowell's sister or something - I've loved the same ones he has. :lol:

I like the both. I adore Ruben's song "I need an Angel" I play that over and over and over. I do the same with Fantasia's "Still in Love with You" I wasn't into American Idol during their seasons. I just got hooked this year. Although, I was in favor of Bo Bice, he can sing anything from Pop, to Rock, to Soul, and R & B. If he hooks up with the genious "Clive Davis", the sky is the limit for him.

I really liked Clay so I didn't like Ruben that much but he was pretty good. I never really liked Fantasia.

I don't like Ruben at all and Fantasia is just ok IMO