This was definitely a thread before but I'm too lazy to find it -.- so.. if you could put together your own top 12 using contestants from all 4 seasons, who would they be?

Mine:
1. Constantine Maroulis
2. Kelly Clarkson
3. Clay Aiken
4. Mario Vazquez
5. Bo Bice
6. Diana DeGarmo
7. Jon Peter Lewis
8. Anthony Fedorov
9. Vonzell Solomon
10. George Huff
11. Jessica Sierra
12. Carrie Underwood

This was definitely a thread before but I'm too lazy to find it -.- so.. if you could put together your own top 12 using contestants from all 4 seasons, who would they be?

Mine:
1. Constantine Maroulis
2. Kelly Clarkson
3. Clay Aiken
4. Mario Vazquez
5. Bo Bice
6. Diana DeGarmo
7. Jon Peter Lewis
8. Anthony Fedorov
9. Vonzell Solomon
10. George Huff
11. Jessica Sierra
12. Carrie Underwood

Mine would be:


1. Constantine Maroulis
2. Constantine Maroulis
3. Constantine Maroulis
4. Constantine Maroulis
5. Constantine Maroulis
6. Constantine Maroulis
7. Constantine Maroulis
8. Constantine Maroulis
9. Constantine Maroulis
10. Constantine Maroulis
11. Constantine Maroulis
12. Constantine Maroulis

Mine would be:


1. Constantine Maroulis
2. Constantine Maroulis
3. Constantine Maroulis
4. Constantine Maroulis
5. Constantine Maroulis
6. Constantine Maroulis
7. Constantine Maroulis
8. Constantine Maroulis
9. Constantine Maroulis
10. Constantine Maroulis
11. Constantine Maroulis
12. Constantine Maroulis

Hey, that's a great top 12 you've got there! :D

1. Kelly Clarkson
2. Jasmine Trias
3. Carrie Underwood
4. Diana DeGarmo
5. Clay Aiken
6. Mario Vazquez
7. Kimberly Caldwell
8. Kimberley Locke
9. Vonzell Solomon
10. George Huff
11. LaToya London
12. Anthony Fedorov

CLOSE ONES:
Mikalah Gordon
Jessica Sierra
Bo Bice

1. Kelly Clarkson
2. Diana DeGarmo
3. Carrie Underwood
4. LaToya London
5. Bo Bice
6. Clay Aiken
7. Vonzell Solomon
8. Kimberely Locke
9. Tamyra Gray
10. Constantine Maroulis
11. Nadia Turner
12. Jessica Sierra

Most of my top 12 are from this season because I really liked the top 12 this year.

1. Constantine Maroulis
2. Bo Bice
3. Jessica Sierra
4. Lindsey Cardinale
5. Kelly Clarkson
6. Clay Aiken
7. Kimberley Locke
8. Diana Degarmo
9. Jon Peter Lewis
10. George Huff
11. Mikalah Gordon
12. Carrie Underwood

HOLY CRAP ONLY 12?!

1. Clay Aiken
2. Mario Vazquez
3. Anthony Fedorov
3. Constantine Maroulis
4. JPL
5. George Huff
6. John Stevens
7. Diana DeGarmo
8. Kim Locke
9. Kelly Clarkson
10. Mikalah Gordon
11. Rickey Smith
12. Matt Rogers

Ugh no. Do semi-finalists count?! Damn I dont have any room for Nikko and Judd.

1. Bo Bice
2. Kelly Clarkson
3. Anthony Fedorov
4. Clay Aiken
5. Constantine Maroulis
6. Vonzell Solomon
7. LaToya London
8. Diana DeGarmo
9. Jasmine Trias
10. Nikko Smith
11. Ruben Studdard
12. Carrie Underwood

Ugh no. Do semi-finalists count?! Damn I dont have any room for Nikko and Judd.

Nikko was still part of the top 12.

Hey, that's a great top 12 you've got there! :D


Thanks! I like it!! :D

Nikko was still part of the top 12.
I know, I meant Judd, and then at the last minute I remembered Nikko too. Poo.

I just came across this thread now and I know its old but I have to post in it :p

1. Carrie Underwood
2. Kelly Clarkson
3. Diana DeGarmo
4. Bo Bice
5. Jasmine Trias
6. Jon Peter Lewis
7. Anthony Fedorov
8. Jessica Sierra
9. Vonzell Solomon
10. John Stevens
11. Constantine Maroluis
12. Camile Velasco

Close ones:
Lindsey Cardinale

1. Jessica Sierra
2. Camile Velasco
3. Lindsey Cardinale
4. Bo Bice
5. Constantine Maroulis
6. Kelly Clarkson
7. Nikki McKibbin
8. Julia DeMato
9. Vanessa Olivarez
10. Amy Adams
11. Diana DeGarmo
12. Anthony Fedorov