For AI4: SUPPOSEDLY 2000-2005...here is the IDF thread

http://idolforums.com/index.php?showtopic=312814

NOTE: This is NOT official, but that seems to be what everyone is saying the theme is. If it turns out this is not the theme, the "real" theme will be posted here.

It is real.

Ok I wasnt sure :lol: We're finding out EARLY this week though, usually we dont find out till Sunday or Monday :eek:

I found out from a friend. She was told personally by one of the Idols. But I'm not really supposed to talk about it, so that's all I can say.

Very interesting. I hope Carrie picks a very good recent country song.

Wow... there are loads of options for all the idols in that one! Ahh I wanna predict what they'd sing! Hmm....I have no idea right now.. gotta think about that one haha.

Alright I have a few ideas. I took some of them from what people said on IDF.

Carrie: Beautiful by Christina Aguilera. Sure, it's not country, but it's such a sweet song and the two of them have similar voices. I think everyone would love it!

Constantine: I Believe in a Thing Called Love by the Darkness. It's a fun rock song which seems to be his specialty these days. Or oooh.. The Middle by Jimmy Eat World.

Bo: She Hates Me by Puddle of Mudd. Yeah sure, some MAJOR editing will have to be done to the song :lol: but I think he'd do great with it.

Anthony: Hero by Enrique Iglesias. The Latin thing worked for him once before... so I think he could pull this off haha I dunno I couldn't really come up with one for him.

Vonzell: Lady Marmalade Christina Aguilera, Lil' Kim, Mya & Pink...ohhhhh man that would be amazing! Another one I think she could pull off is Lose my Breath by Destiny's Child.

Scott: Sorry 2004 by Ruben Studdard :p no seriously uhh.. Where is the Love by Black Eyed Peas. I dunno, it just seems like a song that he'd sing.

Very interesting. I hope Carrie picks a very good recent country song.

Same here. If she goes the Martina route, I REALLY hope she chooses Where Would You Be.

Same here. If she goes the Martina route, I REALLY hope she chooses Where Would You Be.

If I had to pick a Martina song for her, it would be Concrete Angel. I love that song and I think she would do well with it :D

Alright I have a few ideas. I took some of them from what people said on IDF.

Carrie: Beautiful by Christina Aguilera. Sure, it's not country, but it's such a sweet song and the two of them have similar voices. I think everyone would love it!

Constantine: I Believe in a Thing Called Love by the Darkness. It's a fun rock song which seems to be his specialty these days. Or oooh.. The Middle by Jimmy Eat World.

Bo: She Hates Me by Puddle of Mudd. Yeah sure, some MAJOR editing will have to be done to the song :lol: but I think he'd do great with it.

Anthony: Hero by Enrique Iglesias. The Latin thing worked for him once before... so I think he could pull this off haha I dunno I couldn't really come up with one for him.

Vonzell: Lady Marmalade Christina Aguilera, Lil' Kim, Mya & Pink...ohhhhh man that would be amazing! Another one I think she could pull off is Lose my Breath by Destiny's Child.

Scott: Sorry 2004 by Ruben Studdard :p no seriously uhh.. Where is the Love by Black Eyed Peas. I dunno, it just seems like a song that he'd sing.
Great choices, esp. for Scott :lol:

But Vonzell would do GREAT with Lady Marmalade, and I can also see Anthony doing well with Enrique.

If I had to pick a Martina song for her, it would be Concrete Angel. I love that song and I think she would do well with it :D
I really like that song as well. :)

Here are my choices.

Carrie - Can't Fight the Moonlight // LeAnn Rimes ((she MUST sing this.))
Constantine - Harder to Breathe // Maroon 5
Anthony - Hero // Enrique Iglesias ((even though I know he's not. I know he's not singing anything Latin or anything by a boy band. But I don't know WHAT. It's driving me crazy.))
Bo - One Last Breath // Creed OR Hero // Uhh the one from Spiderman
Vonzell - More Than a Woman // Aaliyah ((she MUST sing this.))
Scott - I still haven't been able to think of anything. I like Kristina's choice.

If I had to pick a Martina song for her, it would be Concrete Angel. I love that song and I think she would do well with it :D

I do love that song also and I agree she would sing it well, but since it's a story song and they don't have the time to do the entire song, I'm not sure if it would work. I guess she could sing the second verse and the chorus.