I'm starting a tournament of sorts (divided by each respective era of AT) with one being the best and another being voted the worst. To put it in another way, I'm trying to rank each cast member from worst to best. From there, I want to then pair the best member of the older cast against the best from the newer cast (in order to decide to best female AT cast member ever).

Cast #1:
Amanda Bynes

Lori Beth Denberg

Katrina Johnson

Alisa Reyes

Christy Knowings

Cast #2:
Chelesa Brummet

Lisa Foiles

Christina Kirkman

Jamie Lynn Spears

Giovonnie Samuels

I didn't put Angelique Bates up there because she was only on AT for one season. Plus, I needed to even out the lists down to five from each era.

I'm starting a tournament of sorts (divided by each respective era of AT) with one being the best and another being voted the worst. To put it in another way, I'm trying to rank each cast member from worst to best. From there, I want to then pair the best member of the older cast against the best from the newer cast (in order to decide to best female AT cast member ever).

Cast #1:
Amanda Bynes

Lori Beth Denberg

Katrina Johnson

Alisa Reyes

Christy Knowings

Cast #2:
Chelesa Brummet

Lisa Foiles

Christina Kirkman

Jamie Lynn Spears

Giovonnie Samuels

I didn't put Angelique Bates up there because she was only on AT for one season. Plus, I needed to even out the lists down to five from each era.


best: lori beth (katrina was good also)

worse: jamie lynn

Katrina