View Full Version : Overrated and Underrated Celebs


Sweet Brunette
03-10-2005, 06:07 AM
List all the male and female or male or female,celebrities you think are ugly and talentless and everyone else thinks is hot,and then list all the celebs you think are underrated.

Belair
03-10-2005, 06:23 AM
Overrated
KIRSTEN DUNST: I cant even say she's pretty.I dont think she is at all.
JLO
PARIS HILTON: See other thread,lol
BRITNEY SPEARS: Used to be hot,but now she's hideous.
Jennifer Aniston
Sienna Miller
Mischa Barton
Scarlet Johansson
Brad Pitt: Sory girls,but he IS.
ORLANDO BLOOM: I CANNOT STAND HIM.
Chad Micheal Murray
Tom Welling
Adrien Brody
Justin Timberlake
Usher
Jennifer Garner
Ben Affleck
Hilary Duff
Jessica Simpson
Ashlee Simpson
Nick Lachey
Will Smith
Tom Cruise
Nicole Kidman

Underrated
Kate Beckinsale
Alicia Silverstone
Julia Stiles
George Clooney
Jude Law
Josh Hartnett
Jim Caviezel
Charlize Theron
Christine Taylor
Avril Lavigne

HuntingtonM15
03-10-2005, 01:44 PM
There are a ton of overrated celebs, but two highly underrated celebs that stand out to me right now are Lili Taylor and Catherine Keener.

TheGreatPretender
03-10-2005, 04:20 PM
Overrated Pamela Anderson, Brad Pitt, Ben Affleck, Paris Hilton, Madonna, John Travolta, Tyra Banks, Britney Spears and every single reality show "star" .

Underrated Ralph Macchio, Oliva Hussey, Sissy Spacek, Danica McKellar, Kate Winslet, and Henry Winkler.

dawsongirl
03-10-2005, 06:54 PM
lol...so many overrated people...

I could almost sum this up by saying, "All people who are plastered all over the tabloids and magazines."

Britney- she is cute, but not much talent there.
Paris- yeah, we discussed this already...oh, throw her sister in there too
The Olsen Twins- they were cute on FH when they were 3, but then they grew up and forgot how to act.
Kirsten Dunst- Ever since I saw how dumb she is on Celeb Jeopardy, I have not been a fan.
The Simpson Sisters- They can't sing. And I'm tired of seeing Jessica's boobs everywhere. I don't care how big they are...cover them up.
Jennifer Garner- I don't care...I think she's ugly and annoying.
Ben Affleck- see his girlfriend's entry.
John Travolta- he ugly, end of story. I can't stand his voice either.
Kelly Preston- she makes me ill. And it doesn't even have anything to do with her husband. I just can't stand her.
Tom Cruise- someone make this little ugly thing go away
Puffy- wth...he's a dork
Any rappers
Madonna- she's past her prime by a long shot. And getting uglier by the minute
James Gandolfini- what an arrogant ass
Martha Stewart- oh yes...let's follow her as she goes under house arrest. NO ONE ****ING CARES.
Helen Hunt- she has one expression, and it's boredom. She can't act.

Underrated-
The entire cast of Wings. Especially Tim Daly.

I'll come up with more probably.

TJL
03-10-2005, 07:53 PM
Well, at the risk of incurring the wrath of the "Desperate Houswives" fans here at Sitcoms Online, I nominate Eva Longoria.

I'm sorry, despite all the magazine covers and soundbites, I can't help but think you're just another really pretty girl who got really lucky with a hit show.
Word on the street (and in the gossip pages) is that Eva's been flexing her diva muscles lately - is all the buttkissing from the "Access Hollywood" folks going to her head? Why do I have the feeling that Teri Hatcher's gargantuan pay raise has ticked her off (and even though she's put on a happy face with her other co stars) and she will be the first one to complain?

Of course that's just my opinion, I could be wrong.

;)

MaydayMalonesGirl
03-10-2005, 09:29 PM
Underrated-
The entire cast of Wings. Especially Tim Daly.

I completely agree. That show in general is EXTREMELY underrated.

snl75
03-11-2005, 01:47 AM
i agree about eva longoria im a big dh fan but out of all of them shes the only one on the show i dont like im not sure why but something about her bothers me. also im sorry but im sick of leanrdo dacrapeo and no the crap was not a misspelling his acting has in no way ever impressed me. also i totally agree about julia stilles she can make even the worst movie seem great by just being on the screen. same with kate beckensdale

dawsongirl
03-11-2005, 01:51 AM
dacrapeo

:rofl:

Belair
03-11-2005, 01:57 AM
i totally agree about julia stilles she can make even the worst movie seem great by just being on the screen. same with kate beckensdale

:yeahthat:
Julia and Kate are awesome!

Number 9 Dream
03-11-2005, 02:05 AM
Overrated: Paris Hilton(can't do much of anything), Jessica Simpson(can't sing), Ashlee Simpson(can't sing...cough...SNL), Brad Pitt(ok, he's DECENT looking but he's not THAT great, ladies!), Cameron Diaz(I dunno why but she's always annoyed me), Jennifer Lopez(snooty biatch).....I'm sure there's more out there but I can't think of any as of now.

Underrated: When he was alive, John Ritter. He's definately one of the greatest comedic geniuses we've had in a loooong time. I'd put him up there with the likes of Lucille Ball and Charlie Chaplin. He should've gotten more recognition.

~*Emma*~
03-11-2005, 03:19 AM
Underrated: Justine Bateman and Michael Gross (they were two hilarious people. What ever happened to them?)

Cherry Lips
03-11-2005, 04:40 AM
Overrated:
Paris Hilton
Avril Lavigne

Superstar
03-11-2005, 06:54 AM
Overrated:
Hilary Duff
Usher
Chad Michael Murray
Alicia Keys
Avril Lavigne
Johnny Depp
Orlando Bloom
Brad Pitt

Underrated:
Lisa Kudrow - Didn't get enough attention compared to the other "Friends"
Raven-Symone -I know most people wouldn't agree, there are alot of fans her at SO, but she doesn't get that much attention)
Amanda Bynes - Ignored because of the Hilary's and Lindsays of the world.
Nick Lachey - I think he's a decent actor and good singer, he should be known more as Nick Lachey than Mr. Jessica Simpson

Pitooey
03-11-2005, 08:54 AM
Overated
Paris Yuckton
Eva Longoria (I agree with TJL - I don't see the big deal)
Beyonce
Star (Ugly) Jones

Underrated
Josh Groban