Only about 10 minutes til showtime! :D

Showtime!!!

First up is Amanda Avila, i thought it was ok...id give it a 7/10

Randy: It was just ok, but thats not good enough
Paula: It was good, you have a good chance to stay in the Top 12
Simon: You may have a problem this week

Next up is Janay Castine...Eh, not great... i'd give it a 6/10...the judges agreed

Randy: One of your worst performences
Paula: It was really pitchy, not one of your best
Simon: You sounded horrible

Next up is Carrie Underwood, it was pretty good, id give it a 9/10

Randy: Not your best performance, but your one of the best girls
Paula: The spark is missing, but the vocals are good
Simon: I think your going to be in the Top 12, but it was a safe song

*cough1866IDOLS03!cough*

I thought Amanda was decent. It brought back memories of Diana on the tour.

Janay was .... her usual self. I loved the song though.

Carrie was good, I agreed with Simon, she's definately going to go far, but I want her to really connect with a great song, like "Coulda Been".

I thought Amanda was decent. It brought back memories of Diana on the tour.

Janay was .... her usual self. I loved the song though.

Carrie was good, I agreed with Simon, she's definately going to go far, but I want her to really connect with a great song, like "Coulda Been".Yeah I agree

I thought Amanda was decent. It brought back memories of Diana on the tour.

Janay was .... her usual self. I loved the song though.

Carrie was good, I agreed with Simon, she's definately going to go far, but I want her to really connect with a great song, like "Coulda Been".
Ditto


Janay...she's just. UGHHHHH Id sign a PETITION to get her voted off

Next up is Janay Castine...Eh, not great... i'd give it a 6/10...the judges agreed

Randy: One of your worst performences
Paula: It was really pitchy, not one of your best
Simon: You sounded horrible

What was Simon's comment to her?? Something about leaving in an airport?? I didn't understand the whole thing, but I know it wasn't good.

What was Simon's comment to her?? Something about leaving in an airport?? I didn't understand the whole thing, but I know it wasn't good.
Neither did I...but he was mainly saying she was horrible so i just put that there :lol:

Ditto


Janay...she's just. UGHHHHH Id sign a PETITION to get her voted off

lol she has a good voice, it just hasn't been coming out. her 3 performances have been a D+ at best.

Next up is Vonzell Solomon...it was pretty good, id give it an 8/10

Randy: Not your best, but i'm happy that you're back and having fun
Paula: Your a great girl, you have fun up there
Simon: It was an ok performance

lol she has a good voice, it just hasn't been coming out. her 3 performances have been a D+ at best.
Yeah she does have a good voice and ditto!

Next up is Vonzell Solomon...it was pretty good, id give it an 8/10

Randy: Not your best, but i'm happy that you're back and having fun
Paula: Your a great girl, you have fun up there
Simon: It was an ok performance
I thought it was fun, I laughed about the whole cowboy outfit/Simon "lasoo" thing.

Simon : All that was missing was a cow and a lasso

:rotflmao: Best Simon ocmment so far this season

Simon : All that was missing was a cow and a lasso

:rotflmao: Best Simon ocmment so far this season

:lol: Yeah that was funny

Next up: Nadia Turner

My Review: Eh its was ok, 7/10, the performance was good but i dont love her voice, the judges dont agree with me though

Judges Reviews
Randy: I love watching you
Paula: You've got "The X Factor" (in other words, she though she was good)
Simon: That was amazing

:lol: Yeah that was funny
:D Yeah

Next up: Lindsey Cardinale

My Review: It was pretty good...8/10

Judges Review
Randy: It was alright, it wasnt "da bomb" but it was better than your last few performances
Paula: I like your voice but i dont like the songs you choose
Simon: Something is missing with you

Oh, and Ryan tried to attack Simon :lol:

Next up: Mikilah Gordon

My Review: Not the best....7.5/10

Judges Review
Randy: A little pitchy
Paula: I think she said it was good...i didnt really catch what she said, someone wanna fill me in?
Simon: Your losing what we liked about you in the early stages

Oh, and Ryan tried to attack Simon :lol:
Yeah :lol:


An auditioner actually did attack him on AI3 he got SPLASHED!

Last up: Jessica Sierra

My Review: I thought it was good...8/10

Judges Reviews
Randy: It was one of the best performances of the night
Paula: I agree with Randy
Simon: I think he said something about the song title... :lol:

I'm waiting till the lines clear up.

But my rankgins for tonight --
1. Jessica Sierra - I was worried about her because she seemed to have a small fanbase, but she did amazing!!
2. Nadia Turner - A good change in the night, I don't think she's the best vocally, but she definitely has it going on.
3. Lindsey Cardinale - I actually liked her. She started off very well, and she used that amazing husky tone.

3 WAY TIE for #4
Carrie Underwood - Boring song, but there's no doubt that she can sing her booty off.
Mikalah Gordon - Another interesting song choice, sometimes she sort of fell flat and it was a weird transition at the end to go from slow and melodic to the power, but I thought it was good overall. I just want her to go back to being wild and crazy in her performances.
Vonzell Solomon - Good song choice, it was fun, but vocally it wasn't great at some parts.

7. Amanda Avila - There's something about her performances that turns me off. Her upper register is great, but... it's just all too Vegas-like and not Idol material.
8. Janay Castine - I love that song, but she was terribly pitchy.

Predictions for going home - Amanda Avila and Janay Castine
Who I want to go home - Amanda Avila and Janay Castine

I'm waiting till the lines clear up.

But my rankgins for tonight --
1. Jessica Sierra - I was worried about her because she seemed to have a small fanbase, but she did amazing!!
2. Nadia Turner - A good change in the night, I don't think she's the best vocally, but she definitely has it going on.
3. Lindsey Cardinale - I actually liked her. She started off very well, and she used that amazing husky tone.

3 WAY TIE for #4
Carrie Underwood - Boring song, but there's no doubt that she can sing her booty off.
Mikalah Gordon - Another interesting song choice, sometimes she sort of fell flat and it was a weird transition at the end to go from slow and melodic to the power, but I thought it was good overall. I just want her to go back to being wild and crazy in her performances.
Vonzell Solomon - Good song choice, it was fun, but vocally it wasn't great at some parts.

7. Amanda Avila - There's something about her performances that turns me off. Her upper register is great, but... it's just all too Vegas-like and not Idol material.
8. Janay Castine - I love that song, but she was terribly pitchy.

Predictions for going home - Amanda Avila and Janay Castine
Who I want to go home - Amanda Avila and Janay Castine

Damn, I think we're twins lol. You said everything I was gonna say about all them, and that's my order too. Plus I want Amanda and Janay to leave too. Janay more though...god Selena's "Dreaming of You" is one of my FAVORITE songs. I was hoping she'd pull it off, but nope she didn't. Also, I thought Mikalah was just okay...I think her performance last week was 85 million times better.

Here I go.....

Amanda - Pretty good
Janay - Ughh she cnat sing
Carrie - She was awesome
Vonzell- Awesome too
Nadia - Awesome
Lindsey - Really good
Mikalah - INteresting, i liked it
Jessica- Awesome!

Ugh. I hate girls nites.. its so boring.. they always sing really slow songs that I dont like. Mik did kinda bad, but shes my girl. Best part of the night? All the Ryan/Simon parts. :drool:

Tonight was boring. No one did GREAT, IMO. ahaha. I luuurved how Ryan threw water on Simon. :rofl: <3

Wow, okay. Anyone who knows me knows I want to be on Idol. And I had my top 24 songs all picked out. All three of them. "Queen of the Night", "At Last", and ... ready?


"RIVER DEEP, MOUNTAIN HIGH."

Now, again, anyone who knows me knows I love Simon. Therefore, I can't stand Amanda Avila.

Amanda + MY SONG = OMFG HATRED TIMES A MILLION.

I was so pissed that I actually started crying.

Wow.

Loved Lindsey. SO MUCH. *dies* Mikalah... ehh, I liked the end, but not the beginning. LOVED NADIA!! I was surprised. And I actually loved Jessica too, but not the fact that Simon FLIRTED with her (she looks like a man! The ****?!)

The others were either horrendous or just... not great.

Voted for Lindsey 631 times.

Janay is clearly the weakest. 3/10. I want her eliminated.

I'm voting for Carrie and Jessica. I liked them the best.