Out of all the possible idols this year, which one do you think would actually be able to make it and have a long successful career? The only ones you really hear about these days are Kelly and Clay, and Ruben and Tasia seem to be MIA. They kept going on and on about Tasia and how great and unique she was and how good shed do.. yet she aint here! :lol: So out of them all, which do you think will be most successful?

I think Carrie would be really successful even if she didnt win as long as she stuck to the country thing. I dont think shed be that popular as a 'pop artist', but I think shed do great as a country artist.

Bo Bice would probably do pretty well, thought probably not as well as say Kelly, etc. But I do think the public would prefer him over Constantine once the show is done.

Mario is great and I think hed do really well, just as long as he did what hes good at and not try to change it all up a bit. Ruben made his CD are R&Bish and more umm... urban? I think as opposed to the show and obviously people didnt really like that. People dont like when they completely change once the show is done.

I think Mikalah would do pretty decent, but I think shed probably make it as more of an actress or comedienne.

I dont think Anthony would be able to make his career last once the show is done. Hes got a huge fanbase now, but I dont think thatd last forever. He keeps getting compared to Clay and that bugs me. Ill be really really PO'd if the public and critics love Anthony while all they hate on Clay. </rant>

I think the rest are pretty forgettable.

I pretty much agree with what you said. Mario is the obvious star here, and I do think Carrie will make it as well. And I 100% agree with..
Bo Bice would probably do pretty well, thought probably not as well as say Kelly, etc. But I do think the public would prefer him over Constantine once the show is done.

I do think that this will happen, because Bo has outshined him the past 2 weeks, according to many. I'm neutral about those 2.

Probably Carrie and Mario, since they're the favorites in a way. I love them both and I would be really happy if they went far in the business.

I think Lindsey could do a lot.