The thread of spoilers :D :D it's the girls tonight!!

I can't wait. At least I'll be able to vote without being distracted (I'm a big 24 fan)

Vonzell was good.
Amanda was... okay?
Janay was very shaky.
Carrie was fantastic :D :D :D

Mikalah was cool :cool: :D haha (1866IDOLS09!)
Nadia was better than i expected.
Sarah was not as good as i had expected.
Celena was in my opinion, better than what the judges thought of her
Lindsey wasn't WOW, but I still liked her. (1866IDOLS10!!)

i know im forgetting one of them. but oh well!

Ditto to all that

Although Sarah pciked a great song

Even tho Carrie bugs me, I liked her tonight. Overall the show was pretty blah, tho. :-/ I did like Mikalah. haha. She's awesome. :lol:

CARRIE WAS AWESOMEEEEEEEEE! I loved Vonzell too.

but... omg I think Mikalah looks like plastic surgery gone wrong. So glad Simon told her she was a bit young to be flirty with him.

Even tho Carrie bugs me, I liked her tonight. Overall the show was pretty blah, tho. :-/ I did like Mikalah. haha. She's awesome. :lol:

I liked Carrie a lot too :D :D She blew me away.

But yeah, Mikalah is so funny :lol:

Carrie: Holy CRAP! I am so glad they found her.
Vonzell: I love her voice. She's awesome.
Jessica: I really like her voice. I'm rooting for her.
Amanda: I wish she could have done better.
Melinda: I liked the song she sang, but the performance was alright.
Lindsey: I'm rooting for her.

This is what I thought for tonight

Bold= im rotting for them


Vonzell- 7/10- she wasnt great, but she wasnt horrible either
Amanda- 8/10- I thought she was great
Janay- 6/10- not too great
Carrie- 10/10- She was awesome!
Nadia- 7.5/10- she was okay
Celina- 7/10- she was okay too...
Sarah- 5/10- i thought she was pretty bad
Mikialah- 3/10- sorry but i think shes horrible (no offense to anyone) her performance was fun though
Lindsay- 6/10- i didnt think she was too good
Jessica- 8/10- i thought she was pretty good
Aloha- 6.5/10- not the best
Melinda- 7.5/10- she wasn't bad

Mikalah Gordon was horrendous. She can't sing imo.

(comments after watching the show three times)

Wow.. Carrie blew me away. I did not think she had that sort of voice in her. It was a performance that made me feel good. Vonzell had a really fun performance. It reminded me a lot of Trenyce, which was good. I liked the soulfulness. Melinda surprised me too. I like her, but the problem is that we already have Kelly. Nadia reminded me of a rocker version of Tamyra. Aloha was cool. :cool:

But ugh.. Mikalah. I'm definitely in the 1/2 that is turned off by her. She seems so completely FAKE to me. She was constantly playing up to the judges. It isn't about the judges, it's about the audience. It also seemed like she kept on changing the words to the song. She has her weird personality overshine the fact that she isn't up to par with some of the other girls. To me, she's all fluff and no substance. And her flirting with Simon is disturbing because it's not just that. It's pretty obvious that she likes to use her sexuality to get her places. In her video on idolonfox, she makes a joke about boys liking the fact that she started singing in the tub. I'm worried about her.. she seems too loose, too young. And I seriously think she's had plastic surgery. Her face looks very unnatural. I guess that's Vegas for ya. Hopefully one of the make-up people can help her out with that too.

I LOVE LOVE LOVED MIKALAH!!! Whoo I voted for her all nite. I also liked Vonzell and Aloha. Carrie was really good too! I felt bad for Janay. I like her, and she was so nervous and aww I just hope she gets a second chance. The rest I could live without.

Wow, ummm... tonight was a huge disappointment.

I really didn't like ANYONE, but I voted for Mikalah, Sarah, and Celena.

(comments after watching the show three times)

But ugh.. Mikalah. I'm definitely in the 1/2 that is turned off by her. She seems so completely FAKE to me. She was constantly playing up to the judges. It isn't about the judges, it's about the audience. It also seemed like she kept on changing the words to the song. She has her weird personality overshine the fact that she isn't up to par with some of the other girls. To me, she's all fluff and no substance. And her flirting with Simon is disturbing because it's not just that. It's pretty obvious that she likes to use her sexuality to get her places. In her video on idolonfox, she makes a joke about boys liking the fact that she started singing in the tub. I'm worried about her.. she seems too loose, too young. And I seriously think she's had plastic surgery. Her face looks very unnatural. I guess that's Vegas for ya. Hopefully one of the make-up people can help her out with that too.

I hope no one kills me for this, but I COMPLETELY agree with you. She annoys me SOOOOOOO freaking much. I mean her voice is good, but she just seems like one of those people you'd want to slap if you ever saw them in person. I mean it's good to be energetic and upbeat, but she's just so loud and hyper and obnoxious that her energy is a little too much.

Wow, ummm... tonight was a huge disappointment.

I really didn't like ANYONE, but I voted for Mikalah, Sarah, and Celena.

Yeah, I agree with that too. No one really WOWed me. That's pretty much why I barely voted tonight. My favorite of the night was Vonzell, so I voted for her 3 times and my 2nd favorite was Jessica, who I voted for 3 times as well. I just feel like the guys are way better than the girls this year.

I agree with Jeff about Mikahlah. She has never impressed me from the start and she hasn't impressed me tonight. I don't know what the judges see in her. She's like a female Jon Peter Lewis: she's overrated, has only an average voice, and has good looks that will probably get her votes. She annoys me, too.

The girls were not impressive this year. Here's how I see it.


Vonzell Solomon - 6/10 (maybe 7 after watching the whole show)
Amanda Avila - 6/10 (originally a 7 but after watching it a second time, I didn't really like it as much to score it that)
Janey Castine - 4/10 (easily the worst tonight)
Carrie Underwood - 9/10 (easily the best woman in this competition this year)
Sarah Mather - 5/10
Melinda Lira - 6/10
Nadia Turner - 7/10
Celena Rae - 6/10
Mikahlah Gordon - 5/10
Lindsey Cardinale - 5/10
Jessica Sierra - 7/10
Aloha Mischeaux - 8/10

Vonzell - She was great!
Amanda - It was ok, better than Joseph though
Janay - Not good
Carrie - LOVED IT!
Sarah - Not the best, but she did pick a good song though
Melinda - It was ok
Mikalah -It was pretty good I thought
Nadia - Pretty good
Celena - She was good
LIndsay - Not WOW she's still got an awesome voice
Jessica - Pretty good
Aloha It was pretty good

I liked Carrie the best and Mikalah the least. She's only 16, but tries to act too old and comes across as fake, a show off, and "trampy"...IMO.

I don't understand how people weren't impressed?! So many of the girl performers were amazing! Much better than the guys if for talent. Here are my tops:

Nadia- wow, superpower

Aloha- awesome, a new glady knight (why does randy keep mentioning beyonce? he should mention gladys knight!)

Mikalah- Hilarious

Carrie- the ultimate wow, she's the star of the group. So many of my friends are totally in love with her.

I agree, I hate Mikilah too

I HATE Mikalah. Oh my god. I don't even think she can sing that well...she sounds like shes holding her nose.

I also hate Melinda. "The next Kelly Clarkson?" WTF?! No.

I loved Nadia...I had never really paid attention to her before.

But Carrie was the best. She's so good.

What has this turned into, the I Hate Mikalah thread?

I don't understand how people weren't impressed?! So many of the girl performers were amazing! Much better than the guys if for talent.

I agree! I thought the girls did better than the guys, but that's just my opinion.

What has this turned into, the I Hate Mikalah thread?

It's okay, I still love her :D

Me too. <3333