SPOILER THREAD :D

so far the spoilers i have read stated that the boys songs are:

- niko: part-time lover
- scott: you are my lady
- travis: mi cheri amor
- constantine: kiss from a rose
- bo: drift away
- joseph mureno: how am i supposed to live without you
- jarred: how could i?
- david brown: never can say goodbye
- judd: playing in a travelling band
- anwar: moon river
- anthony: hold on to the night
- mario: do i do

this is probably wrong, so dont hurt me :lol:

Cool!

Drift Away? OMG! I LOVE THAT SONG!

I can't wait :D

they start it off with an introduction of the guys dancing =/ lol. its so corny. the girls are in the audience too.

nikko is 1st.
he has a very high voice sometimes. lol. i guess it's cool though.
randy - excellent
paula - stevie will be proud
simon - it was okay

scott savol is 2nd.
he was very impressive to me, because i dont remember him being that good.
randy - it was okay, pitchy, okay song choice
paula - interesting song choice, some pitch problems, interesting sound
simon - you dont look like an american idol. good not fantastic, choose better songs.

anthony fedorov is 3rd.
pretty good. wasnt exactly WOW, but it was the best so far.
randy - good, a little boring and safe, but good voice
paula - it was safe, im looking forward for you to really go for it
simon - dull as dishwater, predictable, not a star performance

[cough. 1866IDOLS03!!]

bo bice is 4th.
singing drift away. was never a fan. its just okay.
randy - i loved it, you know who you are, that was hot
paula - you sing on pitch, good to the soul, i felt great
simon - you did absolutely everything right, great recording voice, terrific, well done.

travis tucker is 5th.
hes singing "my cherie amour". he smiles a lot. its pretty good, very slow start. very uneventful performance overall.
randy - very safe
paula - magical, change the song, it didnt show off talent
simon - wasnt good enough for a hotel lobby, out of tune

contstantine maroulis is 6th.
song - kiss from a rose. i liked it. it wasnt wow, but it was good enough.
randy - out of tune, sharp, good song choice
paula - comfortable on that stage, unique, lots of fans, good job
simon - bo outsung him, but he has more charisma. i totally agree on the charisma statement, but i like constantine's voice a bit more.

david brown is 7th.
never can say goodbye. it was okay. not as good as before.
randy - pitchy
paula - fell into your groove midway through
simon - we had high hopes for you

wow paula 2 standing ovations in one night. there werent many standing o's last season.

overall, the boys were a disappointment. mario and anawar were best. =].

IM worried about Anthony getting cut :( With no willdcard round and everything :(

IM worried about Anthony getting cut :( With no willdcard round and everything :(
Anthony won't get cut. Jared and Joseph or ... whatever there names are... are probably going to get cut, because they haven't had much air time, unlike the other contestants.

Constantine, Anthony, Bo, Mario, Anwar fans have nothing to worry about

Anthony won't get cut. Jared and Joseph or ... whatever there names are... are probably going to get cut, because they haven't had much air time, unlike the other contestants.

Constantine, Anthony, Bo, Mario, Anwar fans have nothing to worry about
Yeah

Ok cool!:D

but make sure to vote for him anyway!! 1866idols03!

Tonight was good. The only people I can remember not liking was Joseph and Anthony. Anthony was the worst tonight, IMO. Boring and cheesy. :grr: But then again, I don't really care for him. I really liked Anwar and Mario. Alltho David and Travis were somewhat dissapointing, I still like them both. Bo Bice really impressed me, also. Thus far I hadn't really remembered him. Judd sorta reminds me of JPL, only a better singer. :lol:

Tonight was good. The only people I can remember not liking was Joseph and Anthony. Anthony was the worst tonight, IMO. Boring and cheesy. :grr: But then again, I don't really care for him. I really liked Anwar and Mario. Alltho David and Travis were somewhat dissapointing, I still like them both. Bo Bice really impressed me, also. Thus far I hadn't really remembered him. Judd sorta reminds me of JPL, only a better singer. :lol:

hahaha i pretty much agree with everything you said.
1. i liked anwar and mario
2. i like david and travis, but they were disappointing
3. judd does remind me of JPL ... with a better voice. but at the same time, i liked jpl better.

Judd sorta reminds me of JPL, only a better singer. :lol:
Ditto!

And actually Anthony's my fav, dont get mad please

hahaha i pretty much agree with everything you said.
1. i liked anwar and mario
2. i like david and travis, but they were disappointing
3. judd does remind me of JPL ... with a better voice. but at the same time, i liked jpl better.
I used to like JPL, I don't anymore tho. :lol:

Ditto!

And actually Anthony's my fav, dont get mad please
Mad? :lol: I dunno, Anthony is just boring to me. An ok singer, tho.

If I had to rate everyones performances, this is what i would rate them

Bold= Im rooting for them

(Didnt see Scott and the 1st one)

Anthony- 9/10- he was pretty good, not his best performance- but i still voted for him :D
Bo- 8/10- he was pretty good
Travis- 8/10- see bo
Constentine- 6/10- NOT his best performance at all- im still rooting for him though
David Brown- 4/10- i thought he was bad...
Anwar- 6/10- he was alright
Judd- 5/10- i didnt really like him
Joseph- 7/10- i thought he was pretty good
Mario- 6.5/10- im probably the only one that thinks this, but i didnt like him

And actually Anthony's my fav Mine too :D

Here's what I thought of everyone...

Nikko: I thought he was good and that he picked a good song.

Scott: Bleh.

Travis: Pretty good...but it was kinda boring.

Constantine: I thought he was really good actually (and not just saying that cuz he's my favorite) but it definitely wasn't his best performance.

Bo: GREAT!

Joseph: He was okay. I don't really like the song that much though... lol it reminds me too much of this one episode of Saved by the Bell...

Jared: Meh.

David: Yeah.. I thought he was the worst one tonight.

Judd: He's pretty good.

Anwar: OMG AMAZING. I LOOOOOOOVE his voice. It's so...peaceful. lol

Anthony: Good, but he's done so much better before.

Mario: THE BEST ONE OF THE NIGHT. He was GREAT. And it was bugging me for awhile what the "what do I do, what you do" etc part of the song was from cuz I knew it was something current. At first I thought it was something by Usher but then I realized it's that one Ja Rule song.

Tonight I voted for...

Constantine: 50 times
Anwar: 20
Anthony: 20
Mario: 20
Bo: 10

I was really lazy about voting tonight though cuz it's really really obvious who's gonna be safe...so after awhile I almost felt like I was wasting my time but ya know just to make sure haha.

WOOOOOOOOO MARIOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!! TOUCHDOWN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I voted for Mario the whole time.. well except the first ten minutes when I wasn't home. Pretty impressive show tonight.. can't wait to see the girls!

I love Mario. Hes my favorite of the boys. And where did Judd come from?! He bugged me before, but now.. wow. He totally reminded me of the whole JPL/Elvis thing which Im really missing ( :( ), but JPL is still 4332432x's better. I used to like Anthony a whole lot, but he was doing a lot of Clay motions tonight and they just bugged me. And Nikko was good too. As was Bo, who Im not really a fan of.

Let's see. I looooooooved Constantine, Bo, and Judd. The rest were ehh in my mind. I voted for Judd 3 times, but ... ready for my Constantine number???






497.

Would have gotten 500 but the stupid voting line closed :cuss:

Let's see. I looooooooved Constantine, Bo, and Judd. The rest were ehh in my mind. I voted for Judd 3 times, but ... ready for my Constantine number???






497.

Would have gotten 500 but the stupid voting line closed :cuss:
are you excited for carrie tomorrow?!?! ;)

Here are my ratings.


Nikko - 9/10
Scott - 5/10
Anthony - 6/10
Bo - 8/10
Travis - 6/10
Constantine - 7/10
David - 8/10
Jared - 5/10
Anwar - 8/10
Jud - 7/10
Joseph - 6/10
Mario - 8/10

Mine too :D
Awesome!:D


Here;s what I thought

NIkko : Pretty good I liked it a lot

Scott- Bleh, I like him, but now he's starting to be my Leah LABelle this season

Anthony - Not his BEST but still it was good, kinda Clay-ish though, maybe he should pick a faster song

Bo - I loved this one! He did a great job with it!

Travis - Not the best one
Constantine - IT was pretty good, but Id like to see him to more of a rock song, he wouldve done good with Drift AWay too

David - Pretty good, not his best though

Anwar - He was awesome as usual

Jared - Ehhhh

Judd - AWESOME! He's one of my top favs now

Joseph - Ehhh, not so good

Mario - He was awesome too

WOOOOOOOOO MARIOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!! TOUCHDOWN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I voted for Mario the whole time.. well except the first ten minutes when I wasn't home. Pretty impressive show tonight.. can't wait to see the girls!

Yeaaaaah Mario!! :D :D

I voted for him like crazy too. I also gave a few to Anthony, Travis, David, and Anwar.

Yeaaaaah Mario!! :D :D

I voted for him like crazy too. I also gave a few to Anthony, Travis, David, and Anwar.
I didnt know we could vote more than once :grr: I would have voted for anthony more

I liked Mario's performance, the best for last :D Anwar, I just love him. Representing NJ proudly. Umm I liked Bo and Constantine. I find them really interesting with their rock backgrounds. Scott has a good voice but he didn't really show it off in his song (I hope I'm not confusing him with someone else). Same with alot of the other guys. Well that was my rant. I can't wait to see the girls!

Ditto!

Anthony's my fav
Same here!