Rank the 7 Seasons of Charmed from best to worst. (If you dont think youve seen enough of Season 7 yet, you dont have to include it)

Anyway:

Season 4- Excellent
Season 3- Great
Season 7 (so far)- Great
Season 6- OK
Season 5 and Season 1 (tied)- Not the best
Season 2- Terrible

best to worst

3
4
1
2
6
5
7

Season 6-My fave
Season 5- Good
Season 7- Good
Season 3- Not Bad
Season 1 + 2- OK
Season 4- Boring

Originally posted by Superstar

Season 4- Boring :eek: IMO Season 4 is the best..but Season 3 is a close 2nd :)

Originally posted by RurryMicelli
:eek: IMO Season 4 is the best..but Season 3 is a close 2nd :)


I think its the worst. The Phoebe/Cole storyline was happening for way too long and innocents seemed to diseappear. That season should have been more about Paige getting used to her magic

Originally posted by Superstar
I think its the worst. The Phoebe/Cole storyline was happening for way too long and innocents seemed to diseappear. That season should have been more about Paige getting used to her magic Well there were a lot of episodes about Paige, and I thought it was really dramatic and suspenseful :)

A lot of people at the TV Tome boards say that Season 3 is the best, Season 2 is the worst, Season 4 is the 2nd or 3rd best, Season 7 the 2nd or 3rd best, Season 1 usually last or next-to-last.

Originally posted by RurryMicelli
Well there were a lot of episodes about Paige, and I thought it was really dramatic and suspenseful :)

A lot of people at the TV Tome boards say that Season 3 is the best, Season 2 is the worst, Season 4 is the 2nd or 3rd best, Season 7 the 2nd or 3rd best, Season 1 usually last or next-to-last.

I think season 1 + 2 are boring, season 3 was better, I love All Hell Breaks Loose. The season I love season 6 ib because of Its A Bad Bad Bad Bad World, I thought that it was really good

Originally posted by Superstar
I think season 1 + 2 are boring, season 3 was better, I love All Hell Breaks Loose. The season I love season 6 ib because of Its A Bad Bad Bad Bad World, I thought that it was really good :lol: I liked Bad, Bad World too

IMO Season 1 was pretty good, Season 2 was stupid, Season 3 was exciting, Season 4 was even more exciting, Season 5 was good, but kind of stupid, Season 6 was pretty good, and Season 7 is exciting.

Originally posted by RurryMicelli
:lol: I liked Bad, Bad World too

IMO Season 1 was pretty good, Season 2 was stupid, Season 3 was exciting, Season 4 was even more exciting, Season 5 was good, but kind of stupid, Season 6 was pretty good, and Season 7 is exciting.

I agree with you except for what you said about season 4, I think that the storyline was good except it went on for too long.

I find it fascinating how split older and younger Charmed fans are. The younger fans think season 7 is excellent, yet I know a ton of people (myself included) who loved it since Prue think the show is bottoming out right now and would be surprised if it comes back for a year 8.

scale of 1-10.

season 1. 8/10
season 2. 7.5/10
season 3. 10/10
season 4. 9.5/10
season 5. 4/10
season 6. 6.5/10
season 7. 3/10

who else thinks Shannen/Holly/Rose would be better than Alyssa/Holly/Rose? I am not one of the "Alyssa haters", but in essence, Rose plays the same character now that Alyssa did in seasons 1-3, but better.

Originally posted by BuffySlayer79
who else thinks Shannen/Holly/Rose would be better than Alyssa/Holly/Rose? I am not one of the "Alyssa haters", but in essence, Rose plays the same character now that Alyssa did in seasons 1-3, but better. I agree. Phoebe could maybe still be in the show, but not as a sister. Maybe a neigbor, or another relative.

And I think Alyssa is better on sitcoms than dramas.

Originally posted by BuffySlayer79
scale of 1-10.

season 1. 8/10
season 2. 7.5/10
season 3. 10/10
season 4. 9.5/10
season 5. 4/10
season 6. 6.5/10
season 7. 3/10

Season 1- 6/10
Season 2- 3.5/10
Season 3- 9/10
Season 4- 10/10
Season 5- 7.5/10
Season 6- 8.6/10
Season 7- 9/10

Season 6- 10/10
Season 5- 8/10
Season 7- 8/10
Season 3- 6/10
Season 1 + 2- 5/10
Season 4- 3/10

Originally posted by BuffySlayer79
who else thinks Shannen/Holly/Rose would be better than Alyssa/Holly/Rose? I am not one of the "Alyssa haters", but in essence, Rose plays the same character now that Alyssa did in seasons 1-3, but better.

I like it the way it is now.....That would be good to though

Originally posted by BuffySlayer79
I find it fascinating how split older and younger Charmed fans are. The younger fans think season 7 is excellent, yet I know a ton of people (myself included) who loved it since Prue think the show is bottoming out right now and would be surprised if it comes back for a year 8. My mom and a friend of hers watch Charmed and they think the Paige years are better than the Prue years, and they think this season is great. I dont get what's so bad about this season, it has a good plotline, none of them (except the mystery one) have really been too childish, but its your opinion.

Originally posted by RurryJoeMicelli
My mom and a friend of hers watch Charmed and they think the Paige years are better than the Prue years, and they think this season is great. I dont get what's so bad about this season, it has a good plotline, none of them (except the mystery one) have really been too childish, but its your opinion.

it's not so much that the scripts are childish. But Holly Marie Combs is just coming off so bored nowadays that it's dragging the show down with her. Plus, the only two characters I've cared about this season have been guest stars, Kerr Smith and Charisma Carpenter, and then they had to go and kill Charisma off when she was really getting into the character.

Originally posted by BuffySlayer79
it's not so much that the scripts are childish. But Holly Marie Combs is just coming off so bored nowadays that it's dragging the show down with her. Plus, the only two characters I've cared about this season have been guest stars, Kerr Smith and Charisma Carpenter, and then they had to go and kill Charisma off when she was really getting into the character. Yeah. I was sad when she died :(

Im suspisisios of Kyle.

I dont think Holly is coming across as bored, I think shes as good as she's always been

I didn't really like Charismas character but it made the show interesting

season 7 has improved a bit...

I'd change it to
3 - definately my fave cast of the show
4 - showed it still could manage without Prue
2 - when it was really beginning to get great
1 - an excellent beginning
6 - some great moments, some terrible moments... it did get the show back on track though IMO
7 - started out wretched, but had steadily gotten better as the season progressed
5 - a few good episodes, but the majority of the episodes were the worst in the shows history IMO

season 7 has improved a bit...

I'd change it to
3 - definately my fave cast of the show
4 - showed it still could manage without Prue
2 - when it was really beginning to get great
1 - an excellent beginning
6 - some great moments, some terrible moments... it did get the show back on track though IMO
7 - started out wretched, but had steadily gotten better as the season progressed
5 - a few good episodes, but the majority of the episodes were the worst in the shows history IMO
I agree with most of that but I'd rate season 6 and 7 much higher :lol:

who else thinks Shannen/Holly/Rose would be better than Alyssa/Holly/Rose? I am not one of the "Alyssa haters", but in essence, Rose plays the same character now that Alyssa did in seasons 1-3, but better.



Shannen/Holly/Alyssa have the best chemistry. They click together. Rose doesn't have any chemistry with Holly and Alyssa. I can't believe they picked her to replace Shannen. One of the worst cast changes on any show.

I love season one because Andy and Prue's relationship was fun to watch. They made a cute couple. I wish they would have kept him in the show another season or two. The guys they picked for Prue to go out with in season three were ugly.

I can only rank the first four seasons.

Season 1
Season 3
Season 2
Season 4

Season four is a good season, but it doesn't grab my interest like the Shannen seasons do. And as you guys know, I really can't stand Rose in this season. As soon as I finish watching seasons 5 - 7 on TNT, I'll be able to rank those seasons.

I know some of you are probably wondering why I am watching these seasons when I made such a big deal on how I hated Alyssa. Well after watching all of Alyssa's episodes on Melrose Place, it made me like her a little. She may have ruined Charmed, but she was great in MP.