Lets say they were to have an American Idols All-Stars special (like World Idol), who do you think theyd use to make the 12?

1. Kelly
2. Clay
3. Diana
4. Fantasia
5. Ruben
6. Kim L.
7. Tamyra
8. La Toya
9. Justin
10. JPL
11. Trenyce
12. Jennifer H.

Im not too sure of the last 3 though. Maybe John Stevens, Nikki M., or Josh G. Who knows. Hopefully someday down the road they'll def. do this!

What a coinkidink. I was about to start a thread just like this.

1. Kelly Clarkson
2. Clay Aiken
3. Kim Locke
4. Kim Caldwell
5. Diana Degarmo
6. Fantasia Barrino
7. Latoya London
8. Tamyra Gray
9. Amy Adams
10. Jennifer Hudson
11. George Huff
12. Ruben Studdard

I like JPL and Matt Rogers a lot but I honestly don't believe they would be in a competition like this.

1. Kelly
2. Clay
3. Diana
4. Fantasia
5. Tamyra
6. LaToya
7. Jasmine
8. Nikki
9. Kimberley Locke
10. Ruben
11. Fantasia
12. George

and maybe Jennifer and Kim Caldwell

1- Kelly
2- Clay
3- Kim Locke
4- Diana
5- Ruben
6- Justin
7- LaToya
8- Tamyra
9- Fantasia
10- Amy
11- Nikki
12- Trenyce

Originally posted by Brian
What a coinkidink. I was about to start a thread just like this.

1. Kelly Clarkson
2. Clay Aiken
3. Kim Locke
4. Kim Caldwell
5. Diana Degarmo
6. Fantasia Barrino
7. Latoya London
8. Tamyra Gray
9. Amy Adams
10. Jennifer Hudson
11. George Huff
12. Ruben Studdard

I like JPL and Matt Rogers a lot but I honestly don't believe they would be in a competition like this.

YEAH THAT!!!!!! AMY!!!!!!!!!

But replace Ruben (yeah, I know it'd never happen) with J Hud and we're set :D

Originally posted by Janet McFarland
1- Kelly
2- Clay
3- Kim Locke
4- Diana
5- Ruben
6- Justin
7- LaToya
8- Tamyra
9- Fantasia
10- Amy
11- Nikki
12- Trenyce

I like this list too... primarily cos it has AMY!!!!!!!! But again, I say replace Trenyce with J Hud.