Ok, we all have our favorite American Idols, and then theres out guilty pleasures. You know, that one song you cant get enough of- no matter how bad it is. Whether its A.) by someone you love to hate B.) Your least favorite-- and your favorites competition or C.) They just plain suck, you still love that one song by them- and sometimes hate to admit it. So, what are they?

My guilty pleasures:

Ruben Studdard - Flying Without Wings :eek:
Justin Guarini - Pretty Young Thing (PYT)
Kimberly Caldwell - Still Rock & Roll To Me
Fantasia Barrino - Knock On Wood/Way You Look Tonight
La Toya London - Aint Nobody/Dont Rain On My Parade
Leah LaBelle - You Keep Me Hanging On
Josh Gracin - Piano Man/His solo in the top 5 60s medley lol.. Young Girl?
Carmen Rasmussen - Turn The Beat Around

I used to like John Stevens- Crocodile Rock, but now I dont at all


I Have Nothing - Leah LaBelle
Knock On Wood - Fantasia Barrino
Love You Inside and Out - LaToya London

Almost any song sung by LaToya London
Carmen Rasmusen - Hopelessly Devoted to You

Hmm... I have more. Just can't think of them.

Matt Rogers- Amazed
Leah LaBelle- I Have Nothing
Ruben Studdard- Sweet Home Alabama

Ruben Studdard- If Ever Your In My Arms Again
Leah LaBelle- You Keep Me Hanging On
Diana DeGarmo- I'm Still Standing [lots of Diana fans consider this her worst performance... i really like it though :lol: ]
Carmen Rasmusen- Call Me
Camile Velasco- Desperado
Nikki McKibbin- Always Something There To Remind Me
Fantasia Barrino- Knock On Wood

Originally posted by David
Ruben Studdard- If Ever Your In My Arms Again
Leah LaBelle- You Keep Me Hanging On
Diana DeGarmo- I'm Still Standing [lots of Diana fans consider this her worst performance... i really like it though :lol: ]
Carmen Rasmusen- Call Me
Camile Velasco- Desperado
Nikki McKibbin- Always Something There To Remind Me
Fantasia Barrino- Knock On Wood I realy like ISS too!

I like about every Carmen Rasmusen performance :lol: Even though Simon was never crazy about her and either am I.

Originally posted by David
Ruben Studdard- If Ever Your In My Arms Again I forgot that one! And Im Still Standing is my faaaaaaavorite Diana song. :heart:

I Have Nothing- Leah LaBelle
Mandy- John Stevens:seeya:

Hi everyone this is my first post here.

My favorite American Idol moments so far have been:

Ruben Studdard--Superstar
Clay Aiken--Any performance that he did. I have almost worn out his CD I love it so much.
LaToya London--Don't Rain on my Parade
Kimberley Locke--Somewhere over the Rainbow and New York State of Mind


Least favs:

I am sorry to their fans, but anything by Julia DeMato and Carmen Rasmussen.

Songs by People I'm not a fan of

Carmen - Can't Hurry Love

Diana - Don't Cry Outloud

Jasmine - Mr Melody

LaToya - Don't rain on My Parade


^best of the worst in my opinion (and Diana and LaToya are good singers, just don't like thier styles, although Diana is growing on me):o

- sigh - Most of LaToya's performances...to be more specific, Don't Rain on my Parade, Ain't Goin Down til the Sun Comes Up, and All By Myself. Though for some reason, I can't stand her, as you all probably know by now...

Camile Velasco- Goodbye Yellow Brick Road (Simon sent her the death wish on this one and...I can't see why! It was good!)
Justin Guarini- Before Your Love (-.-)
Jennifer Hudson- Heatwave, I Have Nothing, Weekend in New England
Jasmine Trias- Mr. Melody
John Stevens- My Girl (I know...I know...:blush:..)
Josh Gracin- Ain't Goin Down til the Sun Comes Up
Nikki McKibbin- Ben
RJ Helton- Under the Boardwalk
Fantasia Barrino- Always On My Mind, Knock on Wood, Fool in Love