Ok, we all have our favorite American Idols, and then theres out guilty pleasures. You know, that one song you cant get enough of- no matter how bad it is. Whether its A.) by someone you love to hate B.) Your least favorite-- and your favorites competition or C.) They just plain suck, you still love that one song by them- and sometimes hate to admit it. So, what are they?

My guilty pleasures:

Ruben Studdard - Flying Without Wings :eek:
Justin Guarini - Pretty Young Thing (PYT)
Kimberly Caldwell - Still Rock & Roll To Me
Fantasia Barrino - Knock On Wood/Way You Look Tonight
La Toya London - Aint Nobody/Dont Rain On My Parade
Leah LaBelle - You Keep Me Hanging On
Josh Gracin - Piano Man/His solo in the top 5 60s medley lol.. Young Girl?
Carmen Rasmussen - Turn The Beat Around

I don't know why, but I thought of this post today. I could have sworn I replied to this? I guess not -.- anyways.. yeah.. bump...

Mine:
LaToya London - Don't Rain on My Parade
Fantasia Barrino - Knock on Wood
John Stevens - Crocodile Rock -_______-
John Stevens - Mandy
Janay Castine - Hit Em Up Style (*shrug* I thought it was entertaining :lol:)
Jennifer Hudson - Heatwave
Anthony Fedorov - Poison Ivy

Umm.. and probably my worst guilty pleasure ever.

















I can't believe I'm admitting this.

















Oh god.















*cough*


















Scott Savol - On Broadway :eek:

I could've sworn I responded to this as well.. but I'll answer anyway.

My guilty pleasures:
Mikalah Gordon - Love Will Lead You Back and Young Hearts Run Free
Carrie Underwood - When Will I Be Loved
Scott Savol - She's Gone
Jasmine Trias - All of her Final 3 Night performances
Diana DeGarmo - Aint No Mountain High Enough
Anthony Fedorov - Climb Ev`ry Mountain :eek:

Charles Grigsby - You Can't Win
Scott Savol - Against All Odds

hahaha lovin' this thread

Jared Yates - How Could I
Carmen Rasmusen - And So It Goes
Diana DeGarmo - Because You Loved Me
David Brown - All Is Fair in Love
Leah LaBelle - I Have Nothing
Jessica Sierra - Against All Odds
Carrie Underwood - Because You Loved Me

those are the ones off the top of my head

Carrie Underwood-Love is a Battlefield

omg i cant believe im saying this but Climb Ev'ry Mountain and I Surrender by Anthony Federov.. :eek: :eek: whats with me? haha, maybe its the mono...

You B's!!! Yall 'thought' you replied to this before :snob:
:p

Alone - Carrie Underwood
Bohemian Rhapsody - Constantine Maroulis
Never Can Say Goodbye - David Brown
How Could I - Jared Yates
Total Eclipse Of The Heart - Jessica Sierra
MacArthur Park - Carrie Underwood
Shes Gone - Scott Savol
Against All Odds - Scott Savol
On Broadway - Scott Savol
Crocodile Rock - John Stevens
Mr. Melody - Jasmine Trias -.-
September - Anwar Robinson
Janay Castine - Hit Em Up Style
Janay Castine - Dreaming Of You -.-
Scott Savol - Everlasting Love
Travis Tucker - Every Little Step
Joe Murena - Lets Stay Together
Constantine Maroulis - Hard To Handle

Scott Savol- Against All Odds (uggh it was good, even i admit it)
Mikalah Gordon- God Bless This Child
Mikalah Gordon- Son of a Preacherman
Jessica Sierra - Against All Odds
Diana DeGarmo- My Heart Will Go On :p

ill think of more later ;)

*super sigh* I CAN get enough of it, but I do occasionally listen to it. And this is the only one that I would consider a guilty pleasure.

*BIG HUGE SIGH*








*cries*











Can't believe I'm saying this.

















****tard - How Am I Supposed to Live Without You

Also probably every performance by Scott Savol except for Dance With My Father...total YUCK!! puke:

Also:

Constantine Maroluis- How You Remind Me (I liked it :p )

Also:

Constantine Maroluis- How You Remind Me (I liked it :p )
Oh I liked that one too! It actually made me like the song.

I'm bumping this up because this could be very entertaining :lol:

The ones I previously mentioned are still true today -____- just wanted to throw out there...
Bathwater by Sanjaya

:lol: I don't know what it is...it's like, in theory I know it absolutely sucks but come on, the ponyhawk, his facial expressions... pure entertainment!

new additions to mine:

Kellie Pickler - Unchained Melody. yes i KNOW she was totally off vocally but i liked it for some reason.

Kristy Lee Cook - Faithfully. i really liked this...LOL

Kevin Covais - When I Fall in Love...actually pretty much anything he did, lol.

Mandisa - Any Man of Mine. even though it kinda sucked really bad i liked it for some reason cause i thought the song was funny.

Jordin Sparks - Livin' on a Prayer. it was AWFUL yet i like watching it, i dont even know why...LOL.

Mikalah Gordon - Love Will Lead You Back. i dunno...it was just NICE.

...yeah. *hides*

I just thought of some more...

Fat Bottomed Girls by Bucky Covington - Okay, I HATE him, but I'm not gonna lie, I love this performance :lol: it's like, the perfect song choice for his voice.
Tell Him by Haley Scarnato
We Will Rock You by Ace Young - It is absolutely AWFUL, especially because it's not a challenging song at all...but I don't know... something about it entertains me :lol:
Crazy Little Thing Called Love by Fantasia - I can't stand her, but I looove this.

Jordin Sparks - Livin' On A Prayer

Ok, this one....














probably my least favorite singer on AI (Danny Noriega comes in a close second).....











its....











Sanjaya! lol when he did You Really Got Me