Who do u prefer?

I prefer Paige

I like Paige a little better too.:lol:

I think Paige is more fun than Prue

same here, I think Paige makes the show a whole lot funnier. Prue was much more serious....

I liked seeing Piper and Phoebe getting to know their half-sister and teaching her spells and things like that

the first Paige season was my favorite of the entire series, but I like 1-3 much more than seasons 5 and 6

4 was my least fave because it was all about Phoebe and Cole when it should have been about Paige getting used to magic

Originally posted by Superstar
4 was my least fave because it was all about Phoebe and Cole when it should have been about Paige getting used to magic

Phoebe and Cole was why I loved season 4, lol

4 was my least fave because it was all about Phoebe and Cole when it should have been about Paige getting used to magic



I've been watching season four on TNT and most of the episodes are about Paige. She had an evil past life, turning into a vampire, the creepy house she tried to warn her sisters of, using the book for personal gain, dealing with her adoptive parents deaths, and trying to warn Phoebe about Cole. There's more I just can't think of at the moment.

Prue is way better than Paige. I don't know if Rose gets better later on in the series, but she couldn't act at all in season four.

I've been watching season four on TNT and most of the episodes are about Paige. She had an evil past life, turning into a vampire, the creepy house she tried to warn her sisters of, using the book for personal gain, dealing with her adoptive parents deaths, and trying to warn Phoebe about Cole. There's more I just can't think of at the moment.

Prue is way better than Paige. I don't know if Rose gets better later on in the series, but she couldn't act at all in season four.
Good points actually, I hadn't thought of those.

Prue is a good character too, but I just think Rose brings something unique to the show

Good points actually, I hadn't thought of those.

Prue is a good character too, but I just think Rose brings something unique to the show



I thought of a couple of more episodes about her. She caused her and Phoebe to switch bodies, she did that spell on her friend after telling him she was a witch, and I'm not sure what she was but she had that powerball inside her and went to kill Cole. Season four is about her too, not just Phoebe and Cole's relationship.

I don't think Rose brought anything to the show in season four. Maybe in the last three seasons, but season four she is just annoying.

I thought of a couple of more episodes about her. She caused her and Phoebe to switch bodies, she did that spell on her friend after telling him she was a witch, and I'm not sure what she was but she had that powerball inside her and went to kill Cole. Season four is about her too, not just Phoebe and Cole's relationship.

I don't think Rose brought anything to the show in season four. Maybe in the last three seasons, but season four she is just annoying.
I do admit in season 4 she was annoying but now she is my fave character next to Piper

Paige by far. Prue is a boring IMO and is a little snobby.

I like Prue better, but maybe mostly because I liked the theme of the show better when Shannen was on the show. Nowadays the show is a little too light and fluffy. But like one of my Shannen-loving friends said, she'd love a Prue/Piper/Paige combination of the show (she hates Phoebe)

I like Prue better, but maybe mostly because I liked the theme of the show better when Shannen was on the show. Nowadays the show is a little too light and fluffy. But like one of my Shannen-loving friends said, she'd love a Prue/Piper/Paige combination of the show (she hates Phoebe)



I would have liked a Prue/Piper/Phoebe combination for all 7 years and counting. They have the best chemistry.

I would have liked a Prue/Piper/Phoebe combination for all 7 years and counting. They have the best chemistry.

me too, but Alyssa and Shannen just couldn't get along

I prefer Prue over Paige. At least when Prue was part of the cast, the storylines weren't so wild and unrealistic. I've watched a couple of episodes with Paige, but when I watch the first three seasons, the storylines were more believable. Plus, the characters were more themselves, they still are in someways. I know with time comes change, but the type of changes they've made and have become is too much. Too much to the point where everything seems almost unrealistic. The only character that hasn't really changed and became somewhat annoying is Piper, she still believes in the family unit, I've always liked that about her. I know it's been years already, but I just can't seem to adjust to Paige being in the family and not Prue. Paige doesn't have the acting ability that Prue had. Even though Prue is gone, I wouldn't mind seeing Prue, Piper and Phoebe together again. I consider them the Charmed ones, that's just me though!!!

Paige is so much better than Prue :)

PRUE all the way!!!!........but I do like Paige. Let's vote for Pheobe to die!....I like her the least.

PAIGE for sure!!! Prue was wonderful of course, but I started liking the show a whole lot better once Paige came on. Rose McGowan is my favorite of the three girls and Paige is always saying and doing stuff that never fails to make me laugh a little. I think she's always got the best one liners and I just can't get enough of her! I only hope she will get a proper storyline for the rest of the season, I'd like to see a little more of the "superwitch" spirit she once had back in the 4th/5th season.

PRUE! It was never the same for me after she died

Prue was so much better than Paige. Prue actually had chemistry with Phoebe and Piper, and I loved the setup with the original Charmed Ones. Prue was perfect as the big sister. Piper was perfect as the middle sister. Phoebe was perfect and adorable as the baby sister. Paige never fit in, in my opinion, and she was not funny, just ditzy, flaky, insecure, confused, and a bit trampish.

is this a serious question? paige, of course! :lol:

I think Paige is more fun than Prue

The show was already fun. That's why it was a hit. Phoebe, Prue, and Piper were fun to watch as magical sisters.

same here, I think Paige makes the show a whole lot funnier. Prue was much more serious....

I never thought of Paige as funny, just shallow. Prue was a whole lot funnier, in my opinion.

Prue could be serious, but she could also be funny, lighthearted and playful, which was a great balance and combination.

I know it's been years already, but I just can't seem to adjust to Paige being in the family and not Prue. Paige doesn't have the acting ability that Prue had. Even though Prue is gone, I wouldn't mind seeing Prue, Piper and Phoebe together again. I consider them the Charmed ones, that's just me though!!!

I agree. It will always be Prue, Piper, and Phoebe for me whenever I think of the Charmed Ones. They were perfect as sisters. I actually like Paige, but I think of her as more of a friend or cousin, not a sister. :)