Who do you like better? I think Ashlee has a much better voice. Jessica has a more raspy sweet voice, while Ashlee has a more strong sounding, prettier voice.

p.s. my mother said that i can come to anywhere but chit chat main and random boards

I don't care for either of them, but if I had to pick voice wise, definitely Jessica. Jessica has a much strongver voice, especially on her first album.

Ashlee. Her songs are better than Jessica, honestly. Jessica just kills ballads. She may not be that great of a singer, but she has that raspy voice that fits well for the sound shes going for.

Tim wants me to tell all of you how much he loves Ashlee and that you should all go buy her album on July 20th.

Originally posted by TradingMooses
Tim wants me to tell all of you how much he loves Ashlee and that you should all go buy her album on July 20th. Amy is a dirty pirate whore. SHE LIES

I don't like either Jessica or Ashlee, but Ashlee gets the edge because she doesn't seem so self-righteous, and she's nowhere as ditzy either.

neither- in my opnion both cant sing and are annoying- thats just my opinion

Jessica has a good voice and she's amusing with the buffalo wings and chicken of the sea. reminds me of myself. the number of commercials she's in annoys me though. i've just heard ashlee's song "pieces of me" and i kind of like it. she has a decent voice unless it's edited and she got a record deal just because her sister has one. that's just how the music industry works these days.

talentwise i would say Jessica ( though i can't stand the way she tosses her head around and trying to throw her voice) she has a good voice and she also got her fame by herself. Asshlee kind of annoys me the way she says suddenly became "punk" i listened to "pieces of me" and it is a good song, but punk? please it is not even close. and it sounds like her voice got major editing done to it. it kind of sounds like a computer.

Originally posted by skyhigh25789
Asshlee kind of annoys me the way she says suddenly became "punk" i listened to "pieces of me" and it is a good song, but punk? please it is not even close.
how did i know someone was gonna bring that up.

wearing a shirt with the word 'punk' on it is not the same thing as saying "i am such a totally hardcore punk and all my songs are agressive punk core."

I haven't heard Ashlee sing but I like Jessica's music.

I can't stand Ashlee at all her voice sucks and her acting sucks I can't wait until she's gone from 7th Heaven.

Ashlee never said she was making punk music. She said she was going for pop-rock and nothing like her sisters music.

and if people think Jessica has a good voice you must be tone deaf. I can't even listen to her screaming.

Originally posted by Nirvana
Ashlee never said she was making punk music. She said she was going for pop-rock and nothing like her sisters music.

and if people think Jessica has a good voice you must be tone deaf. I can't even listen to her screaming.

I disagree Jessica has a beautiful voice but she overdoes it when she sings live. Her first single "I Wanna Love You Forever" is very beautiful

Originally posted by MandieR1980
I disagree Jessica has a beautiful voice but she overdoes it when she sings live. Her first single "I Wanna Love You Forever" is very beautiful I think she always overdoes it. She screams her lungs off in Take My Breath Away and Angels. It doesn't sound good. She just tries to hard. With You wasn't as bad, though.

I hate Jessica's voice. It's so irritating. I agree...she screams when she sings.

Neither.

ASHLEE. I don't care if she's not some amazing vocalist.. I like her lyrics and voice (even if it is edited some).

There are too many amazing vocalists nowadays anyways.

I <3 Pieces of Me.

OOOOHHHHHHH SEEMS LIKE I CAN FINALLY REST MY HEAD ON SOMETHIN' REAL.. I LIKE THE WAY THAT FEELS. OOOOOOOHHHHHHHHHHHH IT'S AS IF YOU KNOW ME BETTER THAN I EVER KNEW MYSELF. I LOVE HOW YOU CAN TELL.. ALL THE PIECES... PIECES... PIECES OF MEEEEE.

Oh and Jess looks like she's having orgasms when she performs live.

edited

Originally posted by safety pin
how did i know someone was gonna bring that up.

wearing a shirt with the word 'punk' on it is not the same thing as saying "i am such a totally hardcore punk and all my songs are agressive punk core."


no she didnt say that. but in this interview she said that she sang punk http://www.thewb.com/Faces/ArtOfBeing/0,11158,101562,00.html

but still her songs are better than her sisters.

Originally posted by Idol Fanatic
Oh and Jess looks like she's having orgasms when she performs live.


i know :lol: i think she is trying to throw her voice around. but she just ends up looking stupid.

I don't care for Jessica too much, but I like her song "With You".

I voted neither.

Give me Lisa Simpson over Jessica and Ashlee anyday :)

Today on the radio before playing "Pieces of Me" which I really like, they said "Next up is Jessica's sister, with Pieces of Me". Why do they recognize her as "Jessica's sister"? Well it makes sense they are sisters, but hasn't Ashlee been around long enough to have her own identity?

Originally posted by BeaverFan5
Today on the radio before playing "Pieces of Me" which I really like, they said "Next up is Jessica's sister, with Pieces of Me". Why do they recognize her as "Jessica's sister"? Well it makes sense they are sisters, but hasn't Ashlee been around long enough to have her own identity?

i know i feel for her because she is trying to break away from that image and be her own person.

plus in my opinion, she is a better singer than Jessica.

Originally posted by BeaverFan5
Well it makes sense they are sisters, but hasn't Ashlee been around long enough to have her own identity?

not really, outside of 7th Heaven fans, nobody really heard of Ashlee until the past month or two.

my mom said that she only has recorded one song, "Pieces of Me". is that all she has recorded?

and I found online a download for it if anyone likes it. It's on her website

Originally posted by BuffySlayer79
Give me Lisa Simpson over Jessica and Ashlee anyday :)

:lol:

Originally posted by BuffySlayer79
Give me Lisa Simpson over Jessica and Ashlee anyday :)
:lol: :rock:

Originally posted by BeaverFan5
my mom said that she only has recorded one song, "Pieces of Me". is that all she has recorded?

and I found online a download for it if anyone likes it. It's on her website

Her album comes out next Tuesday. She's recorded more than one song, there is 12 on the album, including the (s)hit single Pieces of Me. I will be meeting her on the 20th. Envy me. You can listen to the whole album at mtv.com 's the leak. I like La La the best. She's dirty I like it "you make me wanna la la on the kitchen on the floor i'll be a french maid..i like it better when it hurts". AWESOME

Where will you be meeting her?

Originally posted by BeaverFan5
Where will you be meeting her? Virgin Megastore in Times Square in the city.

NYC, sorry only a long island'er knows what "the city" is:rolleyes:

I lyk them both alot, but i would pick Ashlee over Jessica!! :D

i dont like either of them!

Originally posted by Nirvana
NYC, sorry only a long island'er knows what "the city" is:rolleyes: Excuse me, but "the city" is Chicago. :p

Originally posted by Nirvana
NYC, sorry only a long island'er knows what "the city" is:rolleyes:

lol, as do fans of Sex And The City

I pick Jessica, but both are pretty terrible singers. Their songs and videos (well, Jessica's many and Ashlee's one so far) are extremely annoying. Ugh, when Ashlee stands there at the mic "belting it out," I want to slap her. I'm not seeing ANY talent from her. They both are shouters, not real singers. Granted, Jessica's worse at the shouting. At least her stupidity on Newlyweds was entertaining.

Originally posted by Nirvana
NYC, sorry only a long island'er knows what "the city" is:rolleyes:

You did mention Time Square, so even those who don't watch Sex and the City, should know what city you meant. ;)

Originally posted by Cashodeen
You did mention Time Square, so even those who don't watch Sex and the City, should know what city you meant. ;)

unless they're as dense as 4 bricks

I don't think I've ever heard Ashlee sing. Jessica isn't bad though....she does too many ballads though

http://www.ashleesimpsonmusic.com/

on this site you can listen to "Pieces of Me". Go to downloads on the menu and download it. Just wanted to post this for the fans of that song.:)

Album is going to debut at #1 with an expected 300K. I went to her singing tonight but there were too many people there so they only let in a few hundred.

Originally posted by Nirvana
Album is going to debut at #1 with an expected 300K. I went to her singing tonight but there were too many people there so they only let in a few hundred.

Ahem, I thought you were gonna be one of the few...? :(

Originally posted by Cashodeen
Ahem, I thought you were gonna be one of the few...? :( yeah well don't piss off your connection the night before you're supposed to go.:rolleyes:

Is the album actually any good?... I bet it sounds like Avril left-overs.

Ugh...neither one.

Originally posted by Nirvana
yeah well don't piss off your connection the night before you're supposed to go.:rolleyes:

That royally sucks, Tim. I'm sorry. :(

apparently Avril is fan of hers (just so y'all know I'm referring to Jessica not Ashlee, sorry)

Originally posted by SBTB Geek
Is the album actually any good?... I bet it sounds like Avril left-overs.

It's awesome.

Originally posted by Superstar
Probably, apparently Avril is fan of hers only not. becuase she never said that.

You think I'm talking about Ashlee right? I edited my post above, I thought y'all were talkin about Jessica. Sorry.

But Avril did say she was a fan of Jessica

Originally posted by Superstar
You think I'm talking about Ashlee right? I edited my post above, I thought y'all were talkin about Jessica. Sorry.

But Avril did say she was a fan of Jessica sHE SAID SHE WAS PRETTY YEAH.SHE DOESN'T LOVE HER THOUGH.

AND I THOUGHT YOU DIDNT LIKE HER? OH PLZ,.... GET A LIFE

Hey Kristina, do you have any ideas for my Avril fan club? I need some ideas for some special tribute to Avril from her fans here. She really deserves one:D

Originally posted by Kristina
sHE SAID SHE WAS PRETTY YEAH.SHE DOESN'T LOVE HER THOUGH.

AND I THOUGHT YOU DIDNT LIKE HER? OH PLZ,.... GET A LIFE

I don't like her, am I not allowed talk about some1 I don't like? Why do u think I should get a life?

On my local radio station they are doing an Ashlee Simpson giveaway. When you hear "Pieces of Me", the first 10 to call in get her first album free!:D

party: yay!

Two girls, a bottle of wine, and no seatbelts.

Amazingly, no one of consequence was harmed.

I'm probably going to get to meet Ashlee tomorrow. :D

Originally posted by AllIWantIsYourClutch
I'm probably going to get to meet Ashlee tomorrow. :D *coughhacksneeze*

Was she nice?

Originally posted by Superstar
Was she nice? Yep. She said she liked my shirt. :D

BTW I like your avatar