That's right, another "whosyerfavorite" thread.

Ok, I'm being lazy, but I already said my feelings before and here they are:


Sorry, MASH was better with Trapper.

BJ stories got so steeped in sentimental gush that you wondered if this was a sitcom at times.

And as far as a complementing Hawkeye, Trapper was better, as BJ seemed to make Hawkeye a more sentimental sap and the humor and antics lighter and fluffier.

With Trapper, Hawkeye had to keep himself in check at times because the two of them were both over the top. They talked each other through the madness with quick and biting banter that seemed more fresh and funny than anything Hawkeye and BJ ever did.

BJ's moustache really annoyed me.

I think that Trapper was kinda cute and I think BJ was kinda sweet.

Originally posted by hawaii five-o
BJ's moustache really annoyed me. BJ in general annoyed me.

Trapper was more fun.

Originally posted by bandito
BJ in general annoyed me.

Especially his moustache.

My favorite seasons were the first three, so I don't have to tell you who I picked.

That having been said, I think it was very astute of the show to have replacement characters that weren't the same as their predecessors.

I think it would be a tie