Which American Idol judge do you like the best, and why?

Randy because he's the most honest. Simon does not give real advice, just criticism. He also plays favorites waaaay too much. And Paula is a bafoon.

Simon - He tells the honest truth even though it could be a little harsh.

Simon, of course! I used to love Paula, but meh.. she bugs me. I :heart: Randy now though.

Simon.

Its not that I agree with him, its just that he is the most entertaining. Without Simon, you don't have a show.