Ahh...Are you f-cking kidding me?! Oh my god...this is ridiculous. She didn't deserve to go...AT ALL. AT ALL. Argh......just.....wow. :livid:

Heh this is gonna piss off those that haven't seen it yet :lol:

Nope, she didn't.

I EFFING HATE CAMILE VALASCO AND JOHN STEVENS

I have not stopped crying since they said she was bottom 3.

Originally posted by I am Him
Heh this is gonna piss off those that haven't seen it yet :lol:

Oops......:blush:

IT'S SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO UNFAIR THAT AMY GOT KICKED OFF!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
SHE WAS REALLY GOOD!!

Originally posted by -*Forever*-
I EFFING HATE CAMILE VALASCO AND JOHN STEVENS

I have not stopped crying since they said she was bottom 3.

I wanted to cry too.

HOW MANY TIMES TO I HAVE TO REMIND MYSELF--"Katie don't go to this message board during Idol season! You live in the west coast!" It's only 6 here.

Well, I must say, it's a huge shock to find out that Amy was booted. Who would have guessed that one?! Camille can't sing her way out of a paper bag. Carmen was better than her, and she was quite terrible!

I suppose this is no longer a singing competition. Its a beauty pagent.

Originally posted by I am Him
Heh this is gonna piss off those that haven't seen it yet :lol:

:lol: YUP!

Originally posted by I am Him
Heh this is gonna piss off those that haven't seen it yet :lol: i edited the title just for the west coasters :D

Originally posted by [.AIkenCompany3.]
i edited the title just for the west coasters :D

Oh..you're my hero. :D

John so deserved to go and he knew it. Amy getting the boot was a shock.:eek:

Originally posted by Krisalicious
Ahh...Are you f-cking kidding me?! Oh my god...this is ridiculous. She didn't deserve to go...AT ALL. AT ALL. Argh......just.....wow. :livid: VERRRRRRRY ridiculous.

Out of the bottom 3.. Jennifer deserved to go.
Out of everyone.. John or Camile deserved to go, and they didnt even land in the bottom 3!!
What was LaToya doing there!?!
I expected Amy to go farther than that.. America messed up. Gosh, the one week i vote for Amy, she gets booted. I gave her some votes :) I guess they didnt pay off :(

Originally posted by Krisalicious
Oh..you're my hero. :D No problem ;)

Originally posted by Cashodeen
HOW MANY TIMES TO I HAVE TO REMIND MYSELF--"Katie don't go to this message board during Idol season! You live in the west coast!" It's only 6 here.

Well, I must say, it's a huge shock to find out that Amy was booted. Who would have guessed that one?! Camille can't sing her way out of a paper bag. Carmen was better than her, and she was quite terrible!

I'M SORRY!

Woah. I wasnt *too* surprised to see Amy & Jen in there because theyve been in the bottom 3 before, but Amy did really well lastnite. When it was down to John Stevens and La Toya I pretty much knew it was gonna be John, but when Ryan said La Toya I was shocked.. even John you could tell was really surprised- he looked like he felt bad because he knew he wasnt that great lastnite. Im thankful though that both Jo(h)ns are safe because I love JPL, and I really want to see John do big band next week- I feel he will do the best. And WTF is up with Camile not being in bottom 3?! You could tell on her face that she knew she shouldve been down there- she was mopy the whole episode. Camile deserves to go and its really unfair that others better than her are leaving before her.

Originally posted by ¤MsConanOBrien¤
Woah. I wasnt *too* surprised to see Amy & Jen in there because theyve been in the bottom 3 before, but Amy did really well lastnite. When it was down to John Stevens and La Toya I pretty much knew it was gonna be John, but when Ryan said La Toya I was shocked.. even John you could tell was really surprised- he looked like he felt bad because he knew he wasnt that great lastnite. Im thankful though that both Jo(h)ns are safe because I love JPL, and I really want to see John do big band next week- I feel he will do the best. And WTF is up with Camile not being in bottom 3?! You could tell on her face that she knew she shouldve been down there- she was mopy the whole episode. Camile deserves to go and its really unfair that others better than her are leaving before her. I know, Camile is just so awkward being in the top 9. It has to be her or Jennifer next week.

Originally posted by Krisalicious

I'M SORRY!

Oh don't appoligize! I've done this before. Once even on purpose. :lol:

Originally posted by I am Him
I suppose this is no longer a singing competition. Its a beauty pagent. I wouldnt call it that, because Amy is really pretty too-- and she has the voice to go with it. She wasnt my #1 fav., but she was starting to grow on me, and shes had better performances than others.

Camille sucks, JPL sucks, and John Stevens sucks. They all deserved to be in the bottom three and any one of them could have/should have went. Get real people! All three of them are way over their heads. :mad:

Originally posted by Idol Fanatic
Camille sucks, JPL sucks, and John Stevens sucks. They all deserved to be in the bottom three and any one of them could have/should have went. Get real people! All three of them are way over their heads. :mad: Even though i like JPL, i did feel that those 3 had the weakest performances.. and none of them were in the bottom 3!!!!

This voting has got to get its way back up.. the past 2 weeks we've seen LaToya AND Diana in the bottom 3!!

Originally posted by ¤MsConanOBrien¤
I wouldnt call it that, because Amy is really pretty too-- and she has the voice to go with it. She wasnt my #1 fav., but she was starting to grow on me, and shes had better performances than others.

yeah but you have to admit she was the least attractive of the top 10 females. Especially when compared to Diana, Jasmine and Camile.

Originally posted by [.AIkenCompany3.]
I know, Camile is just so awkward being in the top 9. It has to be her or Jennifer next week. Yah.. I mean, Im all for Camile having fans and stuff.. but who wouldve thought she had such a fanbase?!?! Her voice aint that great, and yah.. shes pretty.. but Diana and Amy are prettier AND have the voice to go. I.... for some reason like Camile, but I want her to go- she doesnt deserve it. Shes too nervous and her voice aint that strong. She looks like she doesnt want to be there. Jennifer Hudson bugs the hell out of me.. her attitude drives me crazy. She acts all sassy and stuff.. gaarrh!

Originally posted by I am Him
yeah but you have to admit she was the least attractive of the top 10 females. Especially when compared to Diana, Jasmine and Camile. No. I find her to be prettier than Jennifer and Fantasia. I think Diana is prettier though, yes-- but that doesnt altar my voting.

Originally posted by [.AIkenCompany3.]
Even though i like JPL, i did feel that those 3 had the weakest performances.. and none of them were in the bottom 3!!!!

This voting has got to get its way back up.. the past 2 weeks we've seen LaToya AND Diana in the bottom 3!!
:nod:

Yess.. whats up with America?! I dont think they listen when Ryan says- even if they did a great job.. vote anyways!!! Dont assume theyre safe!!

Originally posted by ¤MsConanOBrien¤
Yah.. I mean, Im all for Camile having fans and stuff.. but who wouldve thought she had such a fanbase?!?! Her voice aint that great, and yah.. shes pretty.. but Diana and Amy are prettier AND have the voice to go. I.... for some reason like Camile, but I want her to go- she doesnt deserve it. Shes too nervous and her voice aint that strong. She looks like she doesnt want to be there. Jennifer Hudson bugs the hell out of me.. her attitude drives me crazy. She acts all sassy and stuff.. gaarrh! i know.. even Simon predicted on Extra that she would leave. But argh she wasnt even close!!!

And Jennifer!!!!! Aahhhhh bottom 2 already twice! I thought she was gonna leave when the whole bottom 3 was revealed. i dont like Jennifer much.. but ah im still mad that Amy left :(

Since we're talking about looks here, not voice...

I think Diana looked awful tonight!

Originally posted by ¤MsConanOBrien¤
:nod:

Yess.. whats up with America?! I dont think they listen when Ryan says- even if they did a great job.. vote anyways!!! Dont assume theyre safe!! i know! Thats a HUGE thing with this show.. never assume safety, because the people that did poorly will have everyone voting for them, which messes up the people that did well. Thats why LaToya was in the bottom.. and why Tamyra left in season 1. and why Ruben landed in the bottom 2 that one week.

Originally posted by I am Him
yeah but you have to admit she was the least attractive of the top 10 females. Especially when compared to Diana, Jasmine and Camile. No, i think that goes to Jennifer. Amy is attractive in her own way :)

Originally posted by Vegas Girl
Since we're talking about looks here, not voice...

I think Diana looked awful tonight!

Well she wears awful clothes, and she could stand to loose a few pounds, but her face is still pretty.

But Diana was in the bottom 3 last week, so go figure.

That... Was really weird. I thought Jennifer would be the one to go, not Amy. Also, I thought John Stevens would be in the bottom 3. I'm glad he wasn't tho, I like him.

Originally posted by [.AIkenCompany3.]
No, i think that goes to Jennifer.

I agree Jennifer isn't that attractive, but notice Jennifer was in the bottom 2 this week, and in the bottom 3 in week one.

Originally posted by *MacGyver Gurl*
That... Was really weird. I thought Jennifer would be the one to go, not Amy. Also, I thought John Stevens would be in the bottom 3. I'm glad he wasn't tho, I like him. I thought Jennifer would leave too. I began growing on to her during the wildcard round, but after she straightened her hair, something about her makes me want her to leave =/

Originally posted by [.AIkenCompany3.]
I thought Jennifer would leave too. I began growing on to her during the wildcard round, but after she straightened her hair, something about her makes me want her to leave =/ Maybe it's her disturbing facial expressions she makes when she sings. :grr: :lol: They're kinda creepy. :o

Originally posted by Vegas Girl
Since we're talking about looks here, not voice...

I think Diana looked awful tonight!

WHY!?!?!? Coming from a 17 year old, she looked hot. I don't understand catty girls though, so,.....

Originally posted by Idol Fanatic
WHY!?!?!? Coming from a 17 year old, she looked hot. I don't understand catty girls though, so,..... I think Diana is the prettiest of them all and dont think she needs to lose any weight.

Originally posted by [.AIkenCompany3.]
i know! Thats a HUGE thing with this show.. never assume safety, because the people that did poorly will have everyone voting for them, which messes up the people that did well. Thats why LaToya was in the bottom.. and why Tamyra left in season 1. and why Ruben landed in the bottom 2 that one week.
Yuuup. Well, I slightly disagree with the Ruben one -.- I remember reading in a mag. last year about how they think that the producers or whatever put Ruben in on purpose for shock and to get him more votes. I kinda agree.. but who knows?

Originally posted by ¤MsConanOBrien¤
I think Diana is the prettiest of them all and dont think she needs to lose any weight. Yeah, she's great the way she is now

Originally posted by ¤MsConanOBrien¤
Yuuup. Well, I slightly disagree with the Ruben one -.- I remember reading in a mag. last year about how they think that the producers or whatever put Ruben in on purpose for shock and to get him more votes. I kinda agree.. but who knows? when ruben was in the bottom 2.. i actually wasnt too shocked.. because he gave the same old performances that week.. while Clay and Kim L were stepping it up.. and while Josh did bad.. so people were gonna vote for Clay, Kim, and Josh, screwing Ruben.

but actually i actually do remember reading that. i think that it wouldnt be surprising if the producers put him there to give him more votes the following week, because it was obvious from week 1 that they were pushing for him to win

Why was Camile not in the bottom three!!? That amazes me, because for the past couple of weeks she has done TERRIBLE!!l:o And poor Amy, she definatley didn't deserve to go. I was expecting it to be Camile, Jennifer, and John Stevens in the bottom three. Then John to go back, and for it to be against Jennifer and Camile. Boy was I wrong. I don't know anyone that likes Camile, and I can't for the life of me figure out where these votes are coming from. Ahh, well, shows just how wrong America can be. I don't think the Jay thing hurt Amy last night, and its not like she had a weak performance or anything, she was amazing last night. Ohh well, guess it'll teach people to vote even when they think their favorites will be safe. I know I will be voting more for JPL and Fantasia a lot more next week then I did last night.

Originally posted by -*Leah*-
Why was Camile not in the bottom three!!? That amazes me, because for the past couple of weeks she has done TERRIBLE!!l:o And poor Amy, she definatley didn't deserve to go. I was expecting it to be Camile, Jennifer, and John Stevens in the bottom three. Then John to go back, and for it to be against Jennifer and Camile. Boy was I wrong. I don't know anyone that likes Camile, and I can't for the life of me figure out where these votes are coming from. Ahh, well, shows just how wrong America can be. I don't think the Jay thing hurt Amy last night, and its not like she had a weak performance or anything, she was amazing last night. Ohh well, guess it'll teach people to vote even when they think their favorites will be safe. I know I will be voting more for JPL and Fantasia a lot more next week then I did last night. I actually like Camile alot. :lol:

Amy is a good singer, she's done well with all of her performances, at least that I've seen. IMO Jennifer should have went home, actually Camille and George should have rounded out that bottom three. BUT that's just my opinion, I don't mean to offend anyone's favs.

Originally posted by -*Leah*-
Why was Camile not in the bottom three!!? That amazes me, because for the past couple of weeks she has done TERRIBLE!!l:o And poor Amy, she definatley didn't deserve to go. I was expecting it to be Camile, Jennifer, and John Stevens in the bottom three. Then John to go back, and for it to be against Jennifer and Camile. Boy was I wrong. I don't know anyone that likes Camile, and I can't for the life of me figure out where these votes are coming from. Ahh, well, shows just how wrong America can be. I don't think the Jay thing hurt Amy last night, and its not like she had a weak performance or anything, she was amazing last night. Ohh well, guess it'll teach people to vote even when they think their favorites will be safe. I know I will be voting more for JPL and Fantasia a lot more next week then I did last night. I thought those 3 would be in the bottom 3 as well

Originally posted by [.AIkenCompany3.]
when ruben was in the bottom 2.. i actually wasnt too shocked.. because he gave the same old performances that week.. while Clay and Kim L were stepping it up.. and while Josh did bad.. so people were gonna vote for Clay, Kim, and Josh, screwing Ruben.

but actually i actually do remember reading that. i think that it wouldnt be surprising if the producers put him there to give him more votes the following week, because it was obvious from week 1 that they were pushing for him to win Yup. :nod:

Yah.. thats the only thing that gets to me.. that they pushed for him to win from the beginning. I mean, yah, he was good, but c'mon there were better! Just because he had that soul soothing voice doesnt mean its the best. Oh well.. I knew down the line Claymates would prove their point and we did, and we still are. So far he has the #1 single of 2004, selling over 100,000 in its first week. For comparison, Madonna only sold about 4,500.

Originally posted by ¤MsConanOBrien¤
Yup. :nod:

Yah.. thats the only thing that gets to me.. that they pushed for him to win from the beginning. I mean, yah, he was good, but c'mon there were better! Just because he had that soul soothing voice doesnt mean its the best. Oh well.. I knew down the line Claymates would prove their point and we did, and we still are. So far he has the #1 single of 2004, selling over 100,000 in its first week. For comparison, Madonna only sold about 4,500. Wow, go him! :D

Oh you know what? George reminds me of Ruben this year.. but i like George better.. cuz he's more exciting to watch. :)

Oh my gosh....Camille deserves to leave so badly. She's terrible. Nothing about her performances are good. I mean, some people had week performances last nite, but her's have been weak every time. I really really hope she gets the boot next week. She's causing good singers to be kicked out.

Originally posted by *MacGyver Gurl*
I actually like Camile alot. :lol: She used to be alright, but she has started to act nervous during every performance, and the past couple of weeks I could barely hear her singing, because she sounds like a little kid, trying to not let anyone hear her, I mean c'mon!


But, Lynn, we all have our opinions, and I am sure you respect mine, as I respect yours!:D ( and you proved my opinion wrong, I now know someone who likes her;))

Originally posted by [.AIkenCompany3.]
Wow, go him! :D

Oh you know what? George reminds me of Ruben this year.. but i like George better.. cuz he's more exciting to watch. :) :cheer:

yah, I agree.. only difference is Im a fan of George. I wasnt before, but hes cool now.

Originally posted by I am Him
yeah but you have to admit she was the least attractive of the top 10 females. Especially when compared to Diana, Jasmine and Camile.

No. Fantasia is HIDEOUS, as are Jennifer and Camile. Jasmine and Diana are ADORABLE, but not beautiful... very pretty. LaToya is pretty in her own way.

But Amy was just.... gorgeous. She's my equivalent to everyone else's JPL.

Originally posted by -*Forever*-
No. Fantasia is HIDEOUS, as are Jennifer and Camile. Jasmine and Diana are ADORABLE, but not beautiful... very pretty. LaToya is pretty in her own way.

But Amy was just.... gorgeous. She's my equivalent to everyone else's JPL. I'm sorry she got voted out. She was definatly not my choice, but there's nothing I can do about it now. Lets just hope that, like Amy said, we'll see more of her.

Oh gawd, this is rigged. Camile wasn't even in the bottom 3.
What was Latoya doing in the bottom 3? When it was down to Jennifer and Amy, I thought it was Jennifer going home. I bet she goes next week. I Just cant believe that Amy is gone before camile. What a joke.

I don't understand where camile is getting all her votes either. There's someone in Hawaii who has special equipment who can cast like thousands of votes in a matter of minutes. :rolleyes:

Originally posted by *MacGyver Gurl*
I actually like Camile alot. :lol:

ditto. Camile's voice isn't bad, she just needs to get over her nerves which I see happening.

I hate John Stevens!! He turns every song into a Frank Sinatra song and I hate it!! :mad: He knows he should have gone home last night!!

I love Diana, Fantashia and La Toya!!!!

Originally posted by -*Forever*-
No. Fantasia is HIDEOUS, as are Jennifer and Camile. Jasmine and Diana are ADORABLE, but not beautiful... very pretty. LaToya is pretty in her own way.

But Amy was just.... gorgeous. She's my equivalent to everyone else's JPL. Some country record labels should really be asking her for a deal. She was amazing on that song. I really wouldn't be surprised if she did become a country singer.

Originally posted by ¤MsConanOBrien¤
Yuuup. Well, I slightly disagree with the Ruben one -.- I remember reading in a mag. last year about how they think that the producers or whatever put Ruben in on purpose for shock and to get him more votes. I kinda agree.. but who knows? I am starting to think that a lot of this show is rigged. Like La Toya, she had probably had enough votes, but like they did with Ruben put her in the bottom three so she would get even more votes. Maybe I think this way beacause I am a Clayniac, but Clay did have more fans and I think the final show of AI2 was rigged. I don't know though.

Originally posted by ¤MsConanOBrien¤
:cheer:

yah, I agree.. only difference is Im a fan of George. I wasnt before, but hes cool now. Yea, George is awesome :D If you remember.. he was actually originally cut in the last day of the Pasadena auditions, and he's now in the top 9!

Originally posted by ~Tropical Punch 19~
I am starting to think that a lot of this show is rigged. Like La Toya, she had probably had enough votes, but like they did with Ruben put her in the bottom three so she would get even more votes. Maybe I think this way beacause I am a Clayniac, but Clay did have more fans and I think the final show of AI2 was rigged. I don't know though. I couldnt agree with you more. My theory is, last year Ruben was #1 for a while.. but then Clay caught up.. so to get Ruben more votes, they placed him in the bottom 3 to scare his fans.

Originally posted by ~*Hannah_Lee*~
Some country record labels should really be asking her for a deal. She was amazing on that song. I really wouldn't be surprised if she did become a country singer. OMG..:rofl: your avatar!! I melted when he did that look.

Originally posted by ¤MsConanOBrien¤
I couldnt agree with you more. My theory is, last year Ruben was #1 for a while.. but then Clay caught up.. so to get Ruben more votes, they placed him in the bottom 3 to scare his fans.

No I think Clay was #1 for the longest time but as the contestants got fewer...people who liked the contestants that got booted off turned to Ruben because it was either him, Kim, or Clay.

Originally posted by ¤MsConanOBrien¤
OMG..:rofl: your avatar!! I melted when he did that look. Thanks! :D I changed my avator, but don't worry, next Tuesday that face will be back in my avator. I had to take a few days to pay remembrence to my rock icon.