Theres a thread for AI3 Top 10, but what about including seasons 1 & 2 in the mix? Hmm.. my top 10 of ALL AI:

(Yes, most of them will be mostly Clay, but hey, Im trying!:o :lol: )

1. Solitaire - Clay (Neil Sedaka night & AI3)
2. Grease - Clay
3. Mack The Knife - Clay
4. Bridge Over Troubled Water - Clay
5. Aint No Stopping Us Now - Clay & Ruben
6. Little Less Coversation - JPL
7. Band Of Gold - Kim Locke
8. Minnie The Moocher - Tamyra
9. Think - Diana DeGarmo
10. BeeGees Medley - AI2

My favorite of all time would have to be " Little Less Coversation" - Jon Peter Lewis. He was so adorable when he sang that song. :biglove:

1. Clay- Bridge Over Troubled Water
2. Kelly Clarkson- I Surrender
3. Kelly Clarkson- Stuff Like That There
4. Jasmine Trias- Insepereable
5. Clay- Solitaire
6. Kim Caldwell- Come To My Window
7. AI2- For The Longest Time
8. AI2- Neil Sedaka Medley
9. Clay- Mack the Knife
10. Kelly Clarkson- Without You
--- more...
11. Kelly Clarkson- A Moment Like This
12. Clay- Somewhere Out There
13. Kim Locke- Where the Boys Are
14. Kelly Clarkson- You're All I Need
15. Clay- To Love Somebody

1. Clay Aiken- "Bridge Over Troubled Water"
2. Ruben Studdard- "Imagine"
3. Kelly Clarkson- "Natural Woman"
4. Kelly Clarkson- "A Moment Like This"
5. AI2 top...11? I'm not sure how many there were but yea anyway... "Footloose"
6. Kelly, Justin, Nikki- "Love Will Keep us Together"
7. JPL- A Little Less Conversation
8. Tamyra Gray- A House is Not a Home
9. Josh Gracin- To Love Somebody
10. Carmen Rasmusen- You Can't Hurry Love

I can't number them.. that's too tough. However, these my favorites:

Season One

"Without You" - Kelly
"Think Twice" - Kelly
"Don't Play that Song" - Kelly
"Ain't No Sunshine" - Christina
"A House is Not a Home" - Tamyra

Season Two

"Bridge over Trouble Water" - Clay
"New York State of Mind" - Kim L.
"Inseparable" - Kim L.
"Band of Gold" - Kim L.
"Don't Let the Sun Go Down on Me" - Clay
"To Love Somebody" - Clay
"I Have Nothing" - Trenyce
"Love Will Lead You Back" - Carmen
"Turn the Beat Around" - Carmen
60's Medley - Top 5
"All Night Long" - Top 8 ( Remember the Clay/Carmen scene?!? )

Season Three

"I Have Nothing" - Leah (Although she was AWFUL after that)
"I Will Survive" - Suzy ( I <3 You Suzy )
"Inseparable" - Jasmine
"With A Broken Wing" - Diana

I DL'd a bunch of AI songs lastnite, and have a new list. :blush:

1. Solitaire - Clay (both)
2. Grease - Clay
3. Mack The Knife - Clay
4. Band Of Gold - K.Lo
5. Little Less Conversation - JPL
6. Stuff Like That There - Kelly Clarkson
7. Think - Diana DeGarmo
8. Aint No Stopping Us Now - Clay/Ruben
9. BeeGee's Medley - Top 4 AI2
10. Minnie The Moocher - Tamyra Gray

Its hard to put them all in a certain order though after the top 5.




Originally posted by Idol Fanatic
"All Night Long" - Top 8 ( Remember the Clay/Carmen scene?!? ) Yes, yes I do.:mad:

Ok here are mine


1. A LIttle Less Coversation - Jon Peter Lewis
2. KIng of the Road - JOn Stevens
3. Drift Away - JPL
4. Tiny Dancer - JPL
5. She Believes in Me - JPL
6. BeeGees Medley from AI2 ( its on one of the CDs I mad atcually LOL )
7. 60s Medley AI2
8. Top 12 - Soul Medley
9. Hard to Handle - Matt
10 Grease - Clay

Too mnay more to name LOL

Originally posted by ¤MsConanOBrien¤
I DL'd a bunch of AI songs lastnite, and have a new list. :blush:

1. Solitaire - Clay (both)
He did two Solitares? Ive only heard the one he sang when he appeard on AI3 a few weeks ago

I can't number them. And I only know Kelly Clarkson songs from other seasons.

So I'd have to say my number one is-

Amy Adams - Sin Wagon

Oh, come on, if you weren't expecting that...

Originally posted by "Weird" Jack Wilso-vic
He did two Solitares? Ive only heard the one he sang when he appeard on AI3 a few weeks ago
Yup! He did Solitaire last April when Neil Sedeka was guest host. It was Neil Sedeka and 60s night. He also sang Build Me Up Buttercup that night. His AI3 version was better because he had the glory note and his voice was all raspy ( :eyes: ), but AI2 will always be my favorite.

Originally posted by ?MsConanOBrien?
Yup! He did Solitaire last April when Neil Sedeka was guest host. It was Neil Sedeka and 60s night. He also sang Build Me Up Buttercup that night. His AI3 version was better because he had the glory note and his voice was all raspy ( :eyes: ), but AI2 will always be my favorite. Ah cool!

Originally posted by "Weird" Jack Wilso-vic
Ok here are mine


1. A LIttle Less Coversation - Jon Peter Lewis
2. KIng of the Road - JOn Stevens
3. Drift Away - JPL
4. Tiny Dancer - JPL
5. She Believes in Me - JPL
6. BeeGees Medley from AI2 ( its on one of the CDs I mad atcually LOL )
7. 60s Medley AI2
8. Top 12 - Soul Medley
9. Hard to Handle - Matt
10 Grease - Clay

Too mnay more to name LOL Add George Huff- Aint Too Proud to Beg to my list :D

Originally posted by -*Leah*-
My favorite of all time would have to be " Little Less Coversation" - Jon Peter Lewis. He was so adorable when he sang that song. :biglove:

Too bad I couldn't hear him sing that...I only heard him sing a few times.
Do you have any video clips of him?

Well now that AI3 is over, I thought of this thread for some reason -.- and I wanted to bump it up. Anyway...so here are my favorite performances of all time.

1. Kelly Clarkson- Natural Woman/Diana DeGarmo- Don't Cry Out Loud
2. Diana DeGarmo- Someone to Watch Over Me
3. Diana DeGarmo- Do You Love Me
4. Clay Aiken- Bridge Over Troubled Water
5. JPL- Jailhouse Rock
6. Jasmine Trias- I'll Never Love this Way Again
7. Kelly Clarkson- Stuff Like That There
8. Clay Aiken- Mack the Knife
9. Ruben Studdard- Signed, Sealed, Delivered
10. Kim Caldwell- Shoop Shoop Song
11. JPL- A Little Less Conversation
12. Kimberley Locke- My Heart Will Go On
13. Amy Adams- Sin Wagon
14. Trenyce- I'm Every Woman
15. Fantasia Barrino- Fool in Love
16. George Huff- Take Me to the Pilot
17. Kelly Clarkson and Justin Guarini- It Takes Two
18. Jasmine Trias- Inseparable
19. Diana DeGarmo- No More Tears
20. John Stevens- King of the Road

there are a lot more but I'll stop there

*screams* I can never make up my mind. Ok seriously, after #2, theyre not really in an order. I try, but then I think of another song and.. *screams*

1. Solitaire
2. Bridge Over Troubled Water
3. Im Still Standing
4. Think
5. Turn The Beat Around
6.

Ok thats it. Im just going to do my top 5 fav. songs in order for my 3 favorite contestants. Trying to put them all together just gives me a headache, seriously.

CLAY
1. Solitaire
2. Bridge Over Troubled Water
3. Grease
4. Mack The Knife
5. Dont Let The Sun Go Down On Me

DIANA
1. Im Still Standing
2. Think
3. Turn The Beat Around
4. No More Tears
5. Dont Cry Outloud

JPL
1. Little Less Conversation
2. Jailhouse Rock
3. Drift Away
4. Rocket Man
5. She Believes In Me

Ok.. now this is what Im gonna do. Im gonna make a top 10 NOT including Clay, Diana, or JPL.

1. Stuff Like That There - Kelly Clarkson
2. Ill Never Love This Way Again - Jasmine Trias
3. Take Me To The Pilot - George Huff
4. I Surrender - Kelly
5. You Keep Me Hanging On - Leah LaBelle
6. Band Of Gold - Kim Locke
7. Crocodile Rock - John Stevens
8. Amy Adams - Sin Wagon
9. Its Raining Men - Kelly
10. Still Rock & Roll To Me - Kim Caldwell

Ok, and now for my top 10 MEDLEYS.

1. BeeGees Medley AI2
2. Top 5 AI2
3. Aint No Stoppin' Us Now AI2
4. Burt Bacharach Medley AI1
5. Soul Medley AI3
6. Elton John Medley AI3
7. Top 3 Medley AI2
8. Guest Judge Medley AI2
9. Guest Judge Medley AI3
10. Paula Abdul Medley AI1

Now I have a headache.

*SCREAMS* I forgot Clay and the tio 4 singing Fantasy!

Here's some of my fav. Diana performances!:
1-Turn the Beat Around
2-Think
3-No More Tears
4-My Heart Will Go On ( I love any Celine Dion song she sings! b/c I love Celine Dion!!)

My only performance I liked of Fantasia is Signed , Sealed , Delivered. That was the only one I enjoy watching.

Now, I didn't watch AI during Season 1, so none of my favorites come from there...just so ya know.

1. Clay - Unchained Melody
2. Clay - Solitaire (the second time)
3. Fantasia - I Believe (all 17 times)
4. Fantasia - Summertime (the first time)
5. Diana - Think
6. Fantasia - Fool in Love
7. La Toya - Ain't Goin' Down (Till the Sun Comes Up)
8. Diana - Don't Cry Out Loud
9. George - Take Me to the Pilot
10. Clay - Build Me Up, Buttercup

My favorite Jasmine Trias songs that she sang where "Inseprable" and "Don't let the sun go down on me". But really, she did super on all of them except she didn't do very good on "Breathe"

Originally posted by FullHouseFan8795
My favorite Jasmine Trias songs that she sang where "Inseprable" and "Don't let the sun go down on me". But really, she did super on all of them except she didn't do very good on "Breathe"

Yeah, that one was pretty bad. :o

Originally posted by FullHouseFan8795
My favorite Jasmine Trias songs that she sang where "Inseprable" and "Don't let the sun go down on me". But really, she did super on all of them except she didn't do very good on "Breathe" i love her Inseperable perofmrnace. And yeah, i didnt like Breathe.

hmmmmmm my top 10 of ALL TIME

this is HARD
1. Kelly Clarkson- I Surrender
This performance was just spectacular to me. Along with the fact that it's a great song... she sang it with power, she looked like a millionaire in that jewelry and the dress, and she was sick. All that combined created that stunning performance.
2. Clay Aiken- Solitaire
Great song, just a really captivating moving performance.
3. Jasmine Trias- Inseparable
At the time, Jasmine was my fave along with Diana, however I wasnt TOO enthusiastic about anyone just yet, as we only saw them perform once so far. But after that performance, i was literally like wow. it was awesome
4. Diana DeGarmo- Don't Cry Out Loud
This was the perfect song for her, and she did it extremely well. Damn technical crap screwed it up in the finale, but it still remains my favorite.
5. Kelly Clarkson- Stuff Like That There
What is there NOT to like about this?
6. Clay Aiken- Bridge Over Troubled Water
See number 5.
7. Kimberly Caldwell- Nowhere To Run
This made me an official Caldwell fan. I just thought that it was great even though its technically nowhere near the top 10 performances vocally.
8. Kelly Clarkson- Without You
ooooooo just an awesome performance
9. Jasmine Trias- I'll Never Love This Way Again
Loved this one too :) I was worried about her up in this point
10. Diana DeGarmo- This Is It/Enough Is Enough
2 phenomenal perofrmances.