What if Clay, Ruben, or Kim were to be part of AI3.. do you think they wouldve made it as far as they did last season? Would Ruben still be the Idol? Would there be a Clay vs. JPL rivalry between fans like NSYNC and BSB fans were? LOl. What if Vanessa was on.. would she have been the first to go? When do you think last years Idols would have been kicked off this year? Last longer or gone quicker?

I think that if Ruben were to be in this years top 12 he would not be the Idol. I think people would choose George over him, and Ruben would make top 5 or 4. As for Clay, I think he'd make it pretty much as far as he did. I think there'd be some tension between the Claymates and Pensalesmen LOl, both trying to see who would last the longest since Ive been reading on random Idol sites how a lot of people feel that JPL is this seasons 'Clay'.. so I think a lil rivalry would be going on. As for Kim, I think she wouldve gotten booted off towards the beginning. My memory from last years early top 12 is kinda foggy, but if I remember correctly, she was in the bottom 3 a lot. Then again, Camile has been in the bottom 3 both times now.. who knows, maybe she'll be like Kim L. this year and make it far. Hmm.. Vanessa, I think she wouldve lasted a week or 2 longer since Leah was far worse.

heres how i see it

vanessa- amy is basically this years vanessa, but 10x better.. i dont think she wouldve made the top 12 =/

charles- i dont think he wouldve made it this year. hes very bland, and this years group is very unbland

julia- since theres a lot of girl power, i dont think she couldve made it

the rest are iffy-- corey, rickey, kim c.. i think they wouldve made the top 12. corey and rickey woudlnt have made it too far though. not sure about kim c.. she had this stage presence that couldve brought her far this year.. and carmen.. not sure.. shes iffy too.

i dont know about josh either-- it wouldve been between josh and matt.. hmm. josh has a better voice, matt has a better personality

i think kimberely locke wouldve gone far i guess... not sure though. im pretty sure Clay wouldve won, and Ruben wouldve been eliminated halfway, because George Huff would steal a lot of his fans.

i also think there would be tension between the JPL and Clay fans :lol:

Originally posted by [.AIkenCompany3.]
heres how i see it

vanessa- amy is basically this years vanessa, but 10x better.. i dont think she wouldve made the top 12 =/

charles- i dont think he wouldve made it this year. hes very bland, and this years group is very unbland

julia- since theres a lot of girl power, i dont think she couldve made it

the rest are iffy-- corey, rickey, kim c.. i think they wouldve made the top 12. corey and rickey woudlnt have made it too far though. not sure about kim c.. she had this stage presence that couldve brought her far this year.. and carmen.. not sure.. shes iffy too.

i dont know about josh either-- it wouldve been between josh and matt.. hmm. josh has a better voice, matt has a better personality

i think kimberely locke wouldve gone far i guess... not sure though. im pretty sure Clay wouldve won, and Ruben wouldve been eliminated halfway, because George Huff would steal a lot of his fans.

i also think there would be tension between the JPL and Clay fans :lol:
o0o I agree on the Matt/Josh thing.. but I think Josh wouldve pulled out further though because of him being in the Marines (that the one??) and people were patriotic. Im not dissing Josh or anything, but I think due to the fact he was in the service was why he made it as far as he did.

Originally posted by ¤MsConanOBrien¤
o0o I agree on the Matt/Josh thing.. but I think Josh wouldve pulled out further though because of him being in the Marines (that the one??) and people were patriotic. Im not dissing Josh or anything, but I think due to the fact he was in the service was why he made it as far as he did. Yeah, in Simons book, he even admitted that if he wasnt a marine, then he wouldnt have made it far

Originally posted by [.AIkenCompany3.]
Yeah, in Simons book, he even admitted that if he wasnt a marine, then he wouldnt have made it far
Ahh I want to get that book.