Who was everyones favorites?

Mine are in order:

1. JPL..love the dancing!
2. Matt
3. Diana
4. Jasmine

Leah.. was BAD

I think Diana did the best. I also liked JPL, John Stevens, Jasmine, and Latoya. I hope that Leah is voted off. I think Camille will be in the bottom 3.

1. Jon Peter Lewis

2. Jasmine

3. Diana

I actually think they all did good except for Leah (never liked her) and Camille.

Everyone was WONDERFUL.

My top 3 (can I have 4? :D) were

1. Amy Adams
2. Diana Degarmo
3. Jasmine Trias
4. Matt Rogers

WOOOO!!!! GO YOU GUYS YOU RULE!!!!

Originally posted by ¤MsConanOBrien¤
Leah.. was BAD

Yeah. Sadly, I also find her the hottest. Why is the hot one always the worst singer? She also said "Why don't you baby?" It's"Why don't you babe?". Don't get me wrong, I'd still.... well, you know.

Anyway....

1. Diana
2. Fantasia (She's Ghetto Fabulous!)
3. Matt

Our This Week: Amy Adams

I was never a fan of George, but after tonite I like him. I think his song choice was really good for his voice and he did a great job. I still cant stand Fantasia, but I will say she can sing better than a few others in the top 12 - even though her voice still bugs the hell outta me.

Hey! Anyone see Kim C. in the audience tonite? :D

Gaaaah I am so excited for tomorrow nite!

1. Jon Peter Lewis :D
2. Jasmine Trias
3. Amy Adams
4. Fantasia Barrino
5. Diana DeGarmo
6. George Huff


Leah was awful tonight. I agree with Simon, she should just pack her bags because I think she's going home.

Originally posted by ¤MsConanOBrien¤
I was never a fan of George, but after tonite I like him. I think his song choice was really good for his voice and he did a great job. I still cant stand Fantasia, but I will say she can sing better than a few others in the top 12 - even though her voice still bugs the hell outta me.

Hey! Anyone see Kim C. in the audience tonite? :D

Gaaaah I am so excited for tomorrow nite!

This is so random and I'm sure if it even belongs here, but since you're talking about Kim and Clay, then I'll ask.

What season did they all sing Love Will Keep Us Together in? Cos I really like this song... :D

Originally posted by -*Forever*-
This is so random and I'm sure if it even belongs here, but since you're talking about Kim and Clay, then I'll ask.

What season did they all sing Love Will Keep Us Together in? Cos I really like this song... :D

Season 1

Originally posted by Krisalicious
Season 1

Okay, I thought that was Kelly Clarkson, thanks :D

Originally posted by Krisalicious
Season 1 Yup :nod: The top 3- Nikki, Justin, and Kelly

Originally posted by ¤MsConanOBrien¤
I was never a fan of George, but after tonite I like him. I think his song choice was really good for his voice and he did a great job. I still cant stand Fantasia, but I will say she can sing better than a few others in the top 12 - even though her voice still bugs the hell outta me.

Hey! Anyone see Kim C. in the audience tonite? :D

Gaaaah I am so excited for tomorrow nite! aah Kim was in the audience?? Kims awesome!!

anyways.. my rankings

1. JASMINE TRIAS -- i absolutely LOVED her performance!
2. Diana DeGarmo
3. George Huff

also, i couldnt really stand fantasia when i first saw her but now i like her shes pretty cool!

also i think it will be between Camille and Leah to go home.. neither of them seem like they wanna be there. either that or they're nervous

1) Jon Peter Lewis - he's adorable :biglove:

2) Fantasia - love her voice

3) Diana - all around good job

*hated Leah LaBelle and Camille...they did awful.:o

Originally posted by ¤MsConanOBrien¤
I was never a fan of George, but after tonite I like him. I think his song choice was really good for his voice and he did a great job. I still cant stand Fantasia, but I will say she can sing better than a few others in the top 12 - even though her voice still bugs the hell outta me.

I think you and me have similar tastes, this season Crystal. :lol: I think the same thing about George and Fantasia.

My favorites tonite:
1.) Jon Peter Lewis
2.) John Stevens
3.) Diana Degarmo/Jasmine Trias

My Rankings

1. Jasmine
2. Diana
3. Fantasia
4. George
5. Latoya
6. Jon Peter Lewis
7. Matt Rogers
8. Jennifer
9. Amy Adams
10. John Stevens
11. Camile
12. Leah

JPL, George, Jasmine, Diana, Matt and John S. gave their best performances thus far.

Predictions: The bottom three will be Camile, Leah and Amy. Leah will get her torch extinguished and be the first one voted off the island.

not in any particular order...

1. Diana DeGarmo
2. LaToya London
3. Jasmine Trias

My opinion...

Fantasia has a very good voice, but her smile/mouth annoys me!

I think Leah looks very snotty and is the weakest link. Paula shouldn't have voted her in just to spite Simon.

I don't think John Stevens will be successful with the different genres of music always sounding like Frank Sinatra. However,
he's just a kid, and I think Randy was a little tough on him.

I don't think Jon Peter Lewis has a great voice (good, but not great). However, he does have a cute smile and I'm liking him
more. He looks like a fun guy...odd that Simon said he had the personality of a mouse.

Usually they give people makeovers...surprised they didn't tone
down Amy Adams' hair.

The first time George Huff competed, I didn't like his voice and thought he sounded raspy. He sounds better every week, and I like his smile.

Jasmine is really cute and has a great voice.

so many good performances last night

for me, i liked:

1- jon peter lewis
2- diana degarmo
3- george huff

jasmine and fantasia did great too; a lot of them did but those 3 were my favorites

My favorite...BY FAR...was Diana. She was absolutely unbelievable. :rock: My dad said that performance was the best he's ever seen on AI, and even though we're Claymates around these parts, I just might have to agree. This is a 16-year-old kid we're dealing with here! She is a performer, and she craps on everybody else there. :nod: Perfect job.

My pick for second is La Toya. She was really, really good and she's just got so much class. She's got a great style and I think she'll be around for a long time.

I can't really rate the rest, because I was just so shocked at how good everybody was. I thought this Top 12 would be terrible, but every one of 'em was fantastic...'cept Leah. :o

Anyway, my predictions for the Top 3 this season (in no order...I'm not sure yet):

Diana
La Toya
George

:biglove:

My favorite...BY FAR...was Diana. She was absolutely unbelievable. My dad said that performance was the best he's ever seen on AI, and even though we're Claymates around these parts, I just might have to agree. This is a 16-year-old kid we're dealing with here! She is a performer, and she craps on everybody else there. Perfect job. Her and Jasmine are my top 2!! Shes AMAZING! I loved her last night! She can SAaaNG

My pick for second is La Toya. She was really, really good and she's just got so much class. She's got a great style and I think she'll be around for a long time. I like LaToya too. She's great :)


I can't really rate the rest, because I was just so shocked at how good everybody was. I thought this Top 12 would be terrible, but every one of 'em was fantastic...'cept Leah. Yup, this is my favorite top 12!! :woohoo: Cant wait for the results show tonight (with Clay!)

Originally posted by Sitcomwriter

2. Fantasia (She's Ghetto Fabulous!)
Sitcomwriter shut up. Anyway, Fantasia is one of my favorites I like her voice and her personality, and I really like John Paul, Im undecided about John Stevens...oh, and I also liked Matt THIS week.

I liked Diana. I think she'll be around for awhile but will probably get unfairly kicked off by this season's Josh Gracin (JPL). This JPL support is nauseating. :vomit: