Who are your top 3 favorite contestants on AI3? Mine are (in no order) John Stevens, Amy Adams, and Jon Peter Lewis.

I like

Diana DeGarmo

Fantasia Barrino

George Huff

In order:

1. Jon Peter Lewis
2. Matt Rogers
3. Diana DeGarmo

Matt Rogers
Jon Peter Lewis
George Huff

Hmm, I'm not exactly good with names yet, but I think I like LaToya, and definitely George. I'll have to watch next week and get squared away who else is good.

I must say I don't care for that John! I like to watch him--it's like the train wreck effect. But he couldn't possibilty be the next American Idol! Yikes. (But I know he already has some loyal fans--he just may devistate me.)

Diana, Amy, Jasmine.

1) Jon Peter Lewis
2) Diana DeGarmo
3) Amy Adams

Amy
Jasmine
George

1. Leah LaBelle
2. John Stephens
3. Jon Peter Lewis (The Pen Salesman)

1. Camile Velasco
2. Leah LeBelle
3. Amy Adams

Originally posted by ChristyHeadIsSexy
Who are your top 3 favorite contestants on AI3? Mine are (in no order) John Stevens, Amy Adams, and Jon Peter Lewis.
Those are my favorites too, also in no order.

None of them so far, AI2 was much better.

Originally poste by SBTB Geek

None of them so far, AI2 was much better.

So true. This years been a disappointment so far.

Originally posted by SBTB Geek
None of them so far, AI2 was much better.


Even though I really like AI3, I think that nothing can compare to AI2. AI2 is the season of AI by which all others are judged.

Originally posted by Cashodeen
So true. This years been a disappointment so far. im actually very pleased with this season so far. I hope the rest of the season continues to unfold well.

but anyways.. my top 3:

1-2 (tie) Jasmine Trias and Diana DeGarmo
3. Either George or Jon Peter Lewis

Originally posted by SBTB Geek
None of them so far, AI2 was much better.
Aint it the truth. Although, for AI2, I only liked about 3. Clay, Kim C, Rickey, and yah.. thats about it. The rest bugged me. :lol:

Amy Adams
Fantasia Burrino
George Huff

I think I might like Diana too... I only heard a tiny clip of her singing and that was good. But I'm Amy Adams all the way!!!

hi im new to this board but i think that George is one of my favorites cause he seems like a nice, outgoing guy

Originally posted by -*Leah*-
1) Jon Peter Lewis
2) Diana DeGarmo
3) Amy Adams

Same here! I think I like Amy better than Diana though, but I am not sure.

Diana is now one of my favorites after tonights performance. I think that she did the best.

Originally posted by -*Forever*-
Amy Adams
Fantasia Burrino
George Huff

I think I might like Diana too... I only heard a tiny clip of her singing and that was good. But I'm Amy Adams all the way!!!

I'm changing mine. My top 3 are -

Amy Adams
Diana Degarmo
Matt Rogers

1. Diana :biglove:








2. La Toya

3. George (maybe Jasmine...she was really good)

Originally posted by -*Forever*-
I'm changing mine. My top 3 are -

Amy Adams
Diana Degarmo
Matt Rogers im changing mine too.

1/2. TIE Jasmine Trias and Diana DeGarmo
3/4/5. TIE Fantasia, LaToya, and George :lol:

right now mine are:

jon peter lewis
diana degarmo
george huff

I'm not trying to put down Matt, but why would anybody like him?

Originally posted by ChristyHeadIsSexy
I'm not trying to put down Matt, but why would anybody like him?


I like him but I think others in the Top 12 have better voices. I think he's cool, though. I think he has some potential.

Jon Peter Lewis
John Stevens
Matt Rogers

Originally posted by Brian
I like him but I think others in the Top 12 have better voices. I think he's cool, though. I think he has some potential. I agree. He's decent, he's fun to watch, but there are better.

My 3 favorites are:

1. Jon Peter Lewis (I'm a penpal)

2. Diana

3. Jasmine

I think a cute, energetic, fun, confident, and unique male singer should win this year because we got cheated last year!

Although I like Diana and Jasmine, been there, done that!

Currently:
1. John Stevens
2. (tie) Diana DeGarmo & Jon Peter Lewis
3. George Huff.

new rankings:

diana
jasmine
amy