Very similar to the "Which Do You Prefer" game over at Chit Chat Games. Just list 2 performances, and the next poster chooses which one he/she likes better and prefers listening to.

Example:
Post 1: Clay Aiken's "Grease" or Noel Roman "This I Promise You"

Post 2: Clay- Grease...
Elizabeth LeTendre "I Wanna Dance With Somebody" or Tiara Purifoy's "I Wanna Dance With Somebody"

Post 3: Choose 1, List 2

I'll start off:

LaToya London "All By Myself" or Fantasia Barrino "Something To Talk About"?

LaToya London "All By Myself"


Jon Stevens - Always A Woman To Me or George H - Always & Forever

Originally posted by ¤MsConanOBrien¤
LaToya London "All By Myself"


Jon Stevens - Always A Woman To Me or George H - Always & Forever George Huff- Always and Forever

Hmm.. Leah LaBelle- I Have Nothing or Elizabeth LeTendre- I Wanna Dance With Somebody

Elizabeth LeTendre- I Wanna Dance With Somebody



Noel Roman - This I Promise You or Jesus Roman - Back At One

Originally posted by ¤MsConanOBrien¤
Elizabeth LeTendre- I Wanna Dance With Somebody



Noel Roman - This I Promise You or Jesus Roman - Back At One ooo hard one :lol:

Noel- This I Promise You


Camille- One Last Cry or Jasmine Trias- Run To You

Jasmine Trias-Run To You

JPL-Tiny Dancer or Eric Yoder-In The Still Of The Night

Originally posted by ChristyHeadIsSexy
Jasmine Trias-Run To You

JPL-Tiny Dancer or Eric Yoder-In The Still Of The Night Eric Yoder- In The Still of the Night

Kimberley Locke- Heatwave or Top 12- Heatwave

Are you referring to a list or do you actually have everybody's name and what they sang memorized? I can't remember all that.

Top 12 Heatwave

Clay-Bridge Over Troubled Water or Keith-Like A Virgin

Clay- bridge


Elizabeth Letendre - I wanna dance with somebody

OR

Suzy Vulaca - Unbreak my Heart

Originally posted by Vegas Girl
Are you referring to a list or do you actually have everybody's name and what they sang memorized? I can't remember all that. i have everybodys name and song memorized :lol:

Originally posted by Idol Fanatic
Clay- bridge


Elizabeth Letendre - I wanna dance with somebody

OR

Suzy Vulaca - Unbreak my Heart Elizabeth LeTendre-IWDWS

Amy Adams (Power of Love) or Trenyce (Power of Love)

Amy

Clay or Josh-To Love Somebody

Originally posted by ChristyHeadIsSexy
Amy

Clay or Josh-To Love Somebody Clay

Ruben or Josh- Baby I Need Your Lovin

Ruben

Camille-One Last Cry or Jasmine-Run To You

Originally posted by ChristyHeadIsSexy
Ruben

Camille-One Last Cry or Jasmine-Run To You Jasmine- Run To You

Diana Degarmo-Ive Got the Music In Me
or
Fantasia Barrino-Something To Talk About

Originally posted by [.AIkenCompany3.]
Jasmine- Run To You

Diana Degarmo-Ive Got the Music In Me
or
Fantasia Barrino-Something To Talk About

Diana Degarmo

matthew metzger - wlaking in memphis

or

jennifer hudson - imagine

Originally posted by -blue jean baby-
matthew metzger - wlaking in memphis

or

jennifer hudson - imagine matt- walking in memphis (im not a big hudson fan)

heather piccinini- new attitude
or
tamyra gray- new attitude

Tamyra

Clay-This Is The Night or Ruben-Flying Without Wings

Originally posted by ChristyHeadIsSexy
Tamyra

Clay-This Is The Night or Ruben-Flying Without Wings clay- this is the night

justin guarini- lets stay together
or
trenyce- lets stay together

Trenyce

Justin or Leah LaBelle-Let's Stay Together

Leah LaBelle ( Myself and Leah------------->:love: )

Jon Peter Lewis- A Little Less Conversation ( :elvis: ) or Jonah Monanu- I Wish

jon peter lewis - a little less conversation {of course hehehe}

susan vuluca - i will survive

or

katie weber - so emotional

Originally posted by -blue jean baby-
jon peter lewis - a little less conversation {of course hehehe}

susan vuluca - i will survive

or

katie weber - so emotional katie webber

diana degarmo- ive got the msuic in me
or
matt metzger- walking in memphis

Diana

Fantasia-Let's Give them Something To Talk About or Matt Rodgers-What You Won't Do For Love

Originally posted by ChristyHeadIsSexy
Diana

Fantasia-Let's Give them Something To Talk About or Matt Rodgers-What You Won't Do For Love
Fantasia

Rickey Smith- Endless Love
or
Kimberly Caldwell- Everything I Do

Rickey

Kelly-A Moment Like This or Justin-A Moment Like This

Originally posted by ChristyHeadIsSexy
Rickey

Kelly-A Moment Like This or Justin-A Moment Like This Kelly, definately :)

Kelly- Raining Men
or
K. Locke- Raining Men

Kelly

Lisa "Big Mouth" Wilson- Come to my Window or Kim Caldwell- Come to my Window

hehehe.... ain't I a stinker?

Originally posted by Vegas Girl
Are you referring to a list or do you actually have everybody's name and what they sang memorized? I can't remember all that.

Love the show but also forgot some of the songs they sung myself though I do remember Clay's Bridge Over Troubled Water sung real well.

Originally posted by Sitcomwriter
Kelly

Lisa "Big Mouth" Wilson- Come to my Window or Kim Caldwell- Come to my Window

hehehe.... ain't I a stinker? :lol: Definitley Caldwell-Come To My Window

Camille Velasco- One Last Cry
or
Rickey Smith- One Last Cry

Kim C.

Kim C.- Anymore or Julia Demato-Breathe

Can we also do American Junior performances?

Originally posted by ChristyHeadIsSexy
Kim C.

Kim C.- Anymore or Julia Demato-Breathe

Can we also do American Junior performances? of course :)

Kim C- Anymore Definitely

Lucy Hale- Have You Ever or Katelyn Tarver- Have You Ever

Originally posted by [.AIkenCompany3.]
of course :)

Kim C- Anymore Definitely

Lucy Hale- Have You Ever or Katelyn Tarver- Have You Ever

toughie...but I'm gonna say Katelyn's.

Clay Aiken "Bridge Over Troubled Water" or Clay Aiken "This is the Night"

Originally posted by Krisalicious
toughie...but I'm gonna say Katelyn's.

Clay Aiken "Bridge Over Troubled Water" or Clay Aiken "This is the Night"
BOTW, def.

Hmm.. in keeping with the Clayness..

Solitaire (AI2) or To Love Somebody

Originally posted by ¤MsConanOBrien¤
BOTW, def.

Hmm.. in keeping with the Clayness..

Solitaire (AI2) or To Love Somebody

Solitaire!

Amy Adams - Power of Love or You Make Me Feel Brand New

Hey, what can I say, I'm Amy obsessed :D

Originally posted by -*Forever*-
Solitaire!

Amy Adams - Power of Love or You Make Me Feel Brand New

Hey, what can I say, I'm Amy obsessed :D Power of Love :)

Jon Peter Lewis- Drift Away or Jon Peter Lewis- Tiny Dancer

Drift Away!!!!!!


JPL - Little Less Conversation Clay - Grease

Originally posted by King Juke "N" Jive
Drift Away!!!!!!


JPL - Little Less Conversation Clay - Grease Clay- Grease

LaToya London- Aint Nobody OR Fantasia Barrino- Signed Sealed Delivered

Originally posted by King Juke "N" Jive
JPL - Little Less Conversation Clay - Grease
:faint: God, Id have to think about that for a loooong time. Little Less Convo was my fav. performance so far this season, and Im not the biggest song of the Grease theme... but the way Clay did it with the hip wiggles and the red leather jacket (which I, for one, LOVED) really makes up for it!:lol: But hmm.. Id have to go with JPL. omg:

Moving along..

LaToya London- Aint Nobody OR Fantasia Barrino- Signed Sealed Delivered
Latoya London.


Diana DeGarmo - Freedom OR Kim Locke - Band Of Gold

Originally posted by ¤MsConanOBrien¤
:faint: God, Id have to think about that for a loooong time. Little Less Convo was my fav. performance so far this season, and Im not the biggest song of the Grease theme... but the way Clay did it with the hip wiggles and the red leather jacket (which I, for one, LOVED) really makes up for it!:lol: But hmm.. Id have to go with JPL. omg:

Moving along..


Latoya London.


Diana DeGarmo - Freedom OR Kim Locke - Band Of Gold

Diana :D

Fantasia Barrino - Something to Talk About or LaToya London - All By Myself

Originally posted by -*Forever*-
Diana :D

Fantasia Barrino - Something to Talk About or LaToya London - All By Myself LaToya London- All By Myself

Diana- I've Got the Music In Me
or
Diana- Think

Think

Leah-Let's Stay Together or You Keep Me Hangin' On

Originally posted by ChristyHeadIsSexy
Think

Leah-Let's Stay Together or You Keep Me Hangin' On Lets Stay Together

Fantasia- Signed Sealed Delivered
or
Ruben- Signed Sealed Delivered

Ruben

John Stevens-Lately or She's Always A Woman

Originally posted by ChristyHeadIsSexy
Ruben

John Stevens-Lately or She's Always A Woman Always A Woman

Josh- Bad Blood
or
Ryan- You Really Got Me

Josh

Drift Away-JPL or Corey Clark

Originally posted by ChristyHeadIsSexy
Josh

Drift Away-JPL or Corey Clark Jon Peter Lewis

Kim C- Its Still Rock N Roll To Me or
American Juniors- Its Still Rock N Roll To Me

Originally posted by ChristyHeadIsSexy
Amy

Clay or Josh-To Love Somebody

Hey speaking of Josh, do you guys know about his new CD!!! I was a Josh fan, but he was always 2nd to Clay!!! Well josh's CD is pretty country, which is my personal favorite . Go to joshgracin.com to listen to "I Want To Live."

Originally posted by [.AIkenCompany3.]
Jon Peter Lewis

Kim C- Its Still Rock N Roll To Me or
American Juniors- Its Still Rock N Roll To Me

That's tough...Kim C.

Son of A Preacher Man-Julia DeMato or Camille Velasco

I dont really remember Juila, but I'll say her because Camille's was terrible.

Think- Diana DeGarmo
or
Inseperable- Jasmine Trias

Originally posted by rippedpants713
Hey speaking of Josh, do you guys know about his new CD!!! I was a Josh fan, but he was always 2nd to Clay!!! Well josh's CD is pretty country, which is my personal favorite . Go to joshgracin.com to listen to "I Want To Live." Yup! I heard about it :)

Originally posted by ~*Hannah_Lee*~
I dont really remember Juila, but I'll say her because Camille's was terrible.

Think- Diana DeGarmo
or
Inseperable- Jasmine Trias Jasmine Trias- Inseperable (although Diana's was my 2nd favorite of the night!)

George Huff- Dock of the Bay or George Huff- Lean on Me

Originally posted by [.AIkenCompany3.]
Jasmine Trias- Inseperable (although Diana's was my 2nd favorite of the night!)

George Huff- Dock of the Bay or George Huff- Lean on Me

Definately Lean On Me.

The group soul medley or the group performance of "Fame"

I love both, I don't think I could pick! Glad I don't have to! :p

Soul Medley

Matt-What You Won't Do For Love or Hard To Handle

Originally posted by ChristyHeadIsSexy
Soul Medley

Matt-What You Won't Do For Love or Hard To Handle Hard To Handle

Jasmine- Inseperable or Jasmine- Run To You

Inseperable

Latoya-Ain't Nobody or Ain't Goin' Down Til The Sun Comes Up

Originally posted by ChristyHeadIsSexy
Inseperable

Latoya-Ain't Nobody or Ain't Goin' Down Til The Sun Comes Up

Ain't goin' down til the sun comes up

Amy Adams - Sin Wagon or Diana DeGarmo - Broken Wing

Amy

Diana-I've Got The Music In Me or Think

Originally posted by ChristyHeadIsSexy
Amy

Diana-I've Got The Music In Me or Think

Think!!!

John Stevens - King of the Road or Jon Peter Lewis - She Believes in Me

Originally posted by -*Forever*-
Think!!!

John Stevens - King of the Road or Jon Peter Lewis - She Believes in Me

John Stevens- King of the Road...ahh...I STILL LOVE JPL THOUGH!!! erm

Jasmine Trias "Breathe" or Camile Velasco "Son of a Preacher Man" (I think thats what its called?)

Originally posted by Krisalicious
John Stevens- King of the Road...ahh...I STILL LOVE JPL THOUGH!!! erm

Jasmine Trias "Breathe" or Camile Velasco "Son of a Preacher Man" (I think thats what its called?)

Oh, god, this is tough. They were both horrible.

Camille's song sucked, Jasmine's vocals sucked.

I'd have to go with Camille.

Jasmine Trias - Inseperable or Fantasia Barrino - Signed, Sealed, Delivered

Originally posted by -*Forever*-
Oh, god, this is tough. They were both horrible.

Camille's song sucked, Jasmine's vocals sucked.

I'd have to go with Camille.

Jasmine Trias - Inseperable or Fantasia Barrino - Signed, Sealed, Delivered Jasmine- Inseperable

Matt- Amazed or John- King of the Road

Originally posted by -*Forever*-
Oh, god, this is tough. They were both horrible.

Camille's song sucked, Jasmine's vocals sucked.

I'd have to go with Camille.


Yeah, that was the point. :p

Originally posted by [.AIkenCompany3.]
Jasmine- Inseperable

Matt- Amazed or John- King of the Road

Again, JOHN!

JPL "Drift Away" or Matt "Hard to Handle"

Originally posted by Krisalicious
Yeah, that was the point. :p



Again, JOHN!

JPL "Drift Away" or Matt "Hard to Handle"

HARD TO HANDLE OMG

JPL A Little Less Conversation or JPL She Believes in Me

Originally posted by -*Forever*-
HARD TO HANDLE OMG

JPL A Little Less Conversation or JPL She Believes in Me JPL - LITTLE LESS CONVERSATION!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

JPL- Drift Away or John Stevens - King of the Road

JPL

Matt Amazed or George-I Can Love You Like This

Originally posted by ChristyHeadIsSexy
JPL

Matt Amazed or George-I Can Love You Like This

Matt....yes it was terrible...but George just gets on my nerves.

Diana "Think" or "With a Broken Wing"(or at least thats what I think its called)

Originally posted by ~*Hannah_Lee*~
Matt....yes it was terrible...but George just gets on my nerves.

Diana "Think" or "With a Broken Wing"(or at least thats what I think its called) hmmm both great-- but ill just go with "Think"

Jennifer Hudson- Baby I Love You or Amy Adams- You Make Me Feel Brand New

Jenn- Baby I Love Your



John Preator - Whatever he sang in the group 4 OR Lisa Wilson - Come to My Window

Originally posted by Idol Fanatic
Jenn- Baby I Love Your



John Preator - Whatever he sang in the group 4 OR Lisa Wilson - Come to My Window oooo both bad.. ill go with John

JPL- She Believes In Me or JPL- Tiny Dancer

Tiny Dancer

Jasmine-Run To You or Breathe

Originally posted by ChristyHeadIsSexy
Tiny Dancer

Jasmine-Run To You or Breathe

Run to You

Fantasia Barrino: Something to Talk About or Signed, Sealed, Delivered

Originally posted by Krisalicious
Run to You

Fantasia Barrino: Something to Talk About or Signed, Sealed, Delivered Signed Sealed Delivered

Top 12- Soul Medley or Top 11- Love Shack

Soul Medley

John-King of the Road or She's Always A Woman

Originally posted by ChristyHeadIsSexy
Soul Medley

John-King of the Road or She's Always A Woman King of the Road

Camile- Desperado or Matt- Amazed

Originally posted by [.AIkenCompany3.]
King of the Road

Camile- Desperado or Matt- Amazed bumpity bump.. Desperado

Diana- Do you Love Me or American Juniors- do you love me

American Juniors

Corey or JPL-This Old Heart Of Mine or

Originally posted by ChristyHeadIsSexy
American Juniors

Corey or JPL-This Old Heart Of Mine or Corey

John- My Girl or Camile- For Once in My Life

Originally posted by [.AIkenCompany3.]
Corey

John- My Girl or Camile- For Once in My Life
Camile -.-

AI2 top 4: Bee Gees Medley
AI top 6 was it?: 60s Medley

Originally posted by ¤MsConanOBrien¤
Camile -.-

AI2 top 4: Bee Gees Medley
AI top 6 was it?: 60s Medley i think it was the top 5.. but ill go with the 60s Medley

Christina Christian- Aint No Mountain High Enough or
AI3 Top 10 - Aint No Mountain...

Originally posted by [.AIkenCompany3.]
i think it was the top 5.. but ill go with the 60s Medley

Christina Christian- Aint No Mountain High Enough or
AI3 Top 10 - Aint No Mountain... ai3

john s- my girl
or
john s- crocodile rock

Originally posted by [.AIkenCompany3.]
ai3

john s- my girl
or
john s- crocodile rock

Crocodile Rock!

Camile: Goodbye Yellow Brick Road or Desparado

Originally posted by Krisalicious
Crocodile Rock!

Camile: Goodbye Yellow Brick Road or Desparado Desperado

Clay Aiken- Grease or Clay Aiken- To Love Somebody

Originally posted by [.AIkenCompany3.]
Desperado

Clay Aiken- Grease or Clay Aiken- To Love Somebody

i dont know i really didnt watch that much last season

Diana "A broken wing" or Camile "Desperado"

Originally posted by SBTBprincess715
i dont know i really didnt watch that much last season

Diana "A broken wing" or Camile "Desperado" Broken Wing

Amy- Dancing in the Streets or Amy- Power of Love

Originally posted by [.AIkenCompany3.]
Broken Wing

Amy- Dancing in the Streets or Amy- Power of Love

Power of Love

George Huff- Ain't Too Proud to Beg or Lean on Me

*bump* :D

um Aint Too Proud I guess

Sin Wagon- Amy or Carrie?

CARRE!!!!!!!!

Drift Away - JPL or Bo

Wow, old thread :)

Bo Bice


Umm Jasmine or Vonzell or Anwar - I'll Never Love This Way Again

Jasmine

Bo or Clay- Don't Let the Sun Go Down On Me

Bo, because I didn't see Clay's. :eek:

When You Tell Me That You Love Me-Top 12 or Vonzell?

Top 12 I guess

Bo- I Don't Want to be or Carrie- Alone

Top 12 I guess

Bo- I Don't Want to be or Carrie- Alone
Bo's I Don't Want to Be, but then again, I am prejudiced. :lol: Alone was definitely Carrie's best performance though.

Carrie's solo of Bless the Broken Road or with Rascal Flatts?

Oh man. Both were special in their own way... but I pick the solo, since that was more Carrie :lol:

Nadia - I'm the Only One or Jessica - On the Side of Angels

On the Side of Angels (This was actually one of my favorites from Jessica)

Anwar- What a Wonderful World or Bo Bice- Time in a Bottle

Anwar - What A Wonderful World

Carrie - Independence Day (Top 10 Round) or Carrie - Love Is A Battlefield

Independence Day I guess

Diana DeGarmo- One Voice or Diana DeGarmo- A Broken Wing

Diana - One Voice

Ummm... George - What A Wonderful World or Nikko - Can We Talk?

Nikko - Can We Talk

I Surrender- Anthony or Kelly?

Oh man. I loved both, but I'll go with Kelly.

Vonzell - Treat Me Nice or Vonzell - When You Tell Me That You Love Me

Tough one, but I'll go with When You Tell Me That You Love Me

Jessica- Shop Around or On the Side of Angels

Shop Around


Carrie- Alone or Love Is a Battlefield

Shop Around


Carrie- Alone or Love Is a Battlefield


Damn..that's a toughie. With 51% of my votes (I'm such a dork :grineyes: ) um....Love Is A Battlefield. Alone was great, I just started listening to it again, and I love it, but I just really really love rocker chick Carrie.


Carrie - Angels Brought Me Here or Inside Your Heaven

Angels Brought Me Here :)

Umm.

Janay - Hit Em Up Style or Leroy Wells' audition?

:rotflmao: Leroy Wells audition because it was more entertaining :lookaroun

Carrie Underwood- Trouble or Love is a Battlefield?

Trouble. :D

Constantine's Bohemian Rhapsody or Bo's In a Dream?

Ummm. Both were good, but I'll go with "In a Dream"

Bo - Satisfaction ... or ... Bo - Free Bird

SATISFACTION!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Carrie- Indepence Day or bo- I Dont Wanna Be

Independence Day

Kimberly Caldwell - Shoop Shoop Song or Carmen Rasmusen - Wild Angels

Going by media, I guess Kim C- Shoop Shoop Song

A Broken Wing- Diana or Jessica?

DIANA. diana > jessica.

amanda avila or joseph murena - how am i supposed to live without you?

Haha, Joseph because anyone is better than Amanda Avila. :p

Everlasting Love-Clay Aiken, Jasmine Trias, or Scott Savol?

Clay

Against All Odds- George or Scott?

Scott :eek:

mikalah or carmen - love will lead you back

^ Yeah George;s AAO was my least fav of his



Mikalah, cause hers is the only one of ive heard


Bo - Vehicle or Satisfaction?

Vehicle

Inside Your Heaven- Bo or Carrie?

Carrie

Celena Rae - When The Lights Go Down or Aloha - You Don't Know My Name

I guess When The Lights Go Down

Bo- Time in a Bottle or Vonzell- Best Of My Love

vonzell - best of my love

vonzell or trenyce or leah or jennifer - i have nothing

vonzell - best of my love

vonzell or trenyce or leah or jennifer - i have nothing
To tell the truth...I haven't heard any of them! :lol: But I'll go ahead and ask my next question...

Carrie-Sin Wagon or When God Fearin' Women Get the Blues?

Sin Wagon

Anthony- Everytime You Go Away or Constantine- I Can't Make You Love Me.

Anthony - Everytime You Go Away

Vonzell - Respect or Nadia - Try A Little Tenderness

Nadia- Try a Little Tenderness

Diana: Do You Love Me or A Broken Wing

Do You Love Me

Carrie - Piece of My Heart or Carrie - If You Don't Know Me By Now

Carrie's two worst performances :( Hmm I guess If You Don't Know Me By Now (I like the song better)

Jasmine: Inseperable or I'll Never Love This Way Again?

I like em both, but I guess...Inseparable.

Anthony-I Surrender or Everytime You Go Away?

I Surrender (but both are great)

Jennifer: Circle of Life or I Have Nothing?

Circle of Life (the birth of Whatevia)

Corey Clark - This Old Heart of Mine
or
the sound of nails scratching a chalkboard

:lol: This Old Heart of Mine, but it was a close one

Scott: The Impossible Dream or Dance With My Father?

dance with my father

carrie - could've been or jessica - against all odds

dance with my father

carrie - could've been or jessica - against all odds
^^interesting...a lot of people HATED Dance With My Father

Anyways...Jessica-Against All Odds

Constantine-I Think I Love You or How You Remind Me?

I Think I Love You

Against All Odds: Jessica or Scott?

Scott

Bo-Don't Let the Sun Go Down on Me or Stand by Me?

Don't Let the Sun Go Down On Me

Carrie: Sin Wagon or MacArthur Park?

Sin Wagon

Vonzell-Treat Me Nice or Don't Leave Me This Way?

Treat Me Nice

Vonzell- Best of My Love or Anthony- I Knew You Were Waiting

Vonzell - Best of My Love

Clay Aiken - Mack the Knife or Ruben Studdard - Imagine

Old thread Im bumping up




Have You Ever Really Loved a Woman
Chris or Matt?