The first chick was good

The second guy John didn't sing all that well.

The 3rd contestant Heather wasn't that great.

How come George took the place of another contestant? Does anyone know the story behind that?

One of the semifinalists was kicked off after a DUI. I think his name was Donnie Williams.

Originally posted by Brian
One of the semifinalists was kicked off after a DUI. I think his name was Donnie Williams. Oh, ok, thanks.

1866IDOLS05!!

Jasmine all the way!

And George 06, if you please :)

I originally liked Heather, but she seemed TOTALLY different today

Originally posted by I am Him
The second guy John didn't sing all that well. I know! Him and Lisa were bad

Eh..the only one I really liked tonight was Jasmine.

John Stevens baby

I loved George the best. I think he is going to be in the top 3 because I have only gotten in one vote in like 15 tries. But that's good because the more busy signals, the better. :D

Originally posted by LucyCompanyPhan
John Stevens baby
John Stevens is cool. I like him. :)

predictions

Jasmine and George advance. (though I personally liked Suzy over George)

John Stevens sneaks into the wild card based on Simon's comments on his unique voice.

I think this was another mediocre bunch, who received some harsh criticisms from the judges last night. George was off tune and just did not have a good voice. I think the first girl
and the Hawaaiian girl were the best.

Originally posted by Vegas Girl
I think the first girl
and the Hawaaiian girl were the best.

Well I would say the first girl Susan was the best of that group.

Originally posted by *MacGyver Gurl*
John Stevens is cool. I like him. :)


yes. hes my favorite. me and my friend voted like 75 times. He better win. Any guy who can sing like that is great. We need something different, not to meantion we only have one guy so far in the top 6. We need a cutie.

i love that song too in your siggy.

I think Simon was right with his comment on John Stevens. He does have a unique voice. And I think he has potential. I just like him. I think he should advance.
George sounded alittle too raspy, I think he's got a cold or something.
Jasmine was real good, I hope she makes it through.
Jasmine and John. Those are my two picks.

I don't like John Stevens.

He's not that good of a singer, and he doesn't have the ability to win.

Furthurmore, he isn't going to be able to sing that 40s jazz crap in the finals, and he doesn't have the ability to sing anything else.

Originally posted by I am Him
I don't like John Stevens.

He's not that good of a singer, and he doesn't have the ability to win.

Furthurmore, he isn't going to be able to sing that 40s jazz crap in the finals, and he doesn't have the ability to sing anything else. i actually am neutral about john stevens. I thought his audition was good, but tonight he was just plain boring to me (sorry, you all :().. but ill be okay if he goes through, however i like 3 people better: Heather, George and Jasmine :woohoo:

George sounded like he had a frog in his throat.

Well John and Jasmine made it.

I still don't think John has the ability to win unless teenage girl just vote for him because they like the way he looks.

Im surprised Jon got the most votes (28%!!) :eek:. But Im happy. :D He looks like Conans younger brother.

Which John are you talking about? Are you talking about John Preator or John Stevens?

John Stevens. I'm very surprised that he made it.

I'm not too surprised, then. I am bummed that George apparently didn't make it. He was my favorite last night.

Originally posted by Brian
I'm not too surprised, then. I am bummed that George apparently didn't make it. He was my favorite last night. well good news, he gets called back for the wild card show :)

Originally posted by ¤MsConanOBrien¤
Im surprised Jon got the most votes (28%!!) :eek:. But Im happy. :D He looks like Conans younger brother.
I said from day one that he looked like Conan!! :lol:

I'm so happy for John. I love his voice and uniqueness and lets give him the benefit of the doubt before we go thinking he can't sing anything else but old jazz music. We know hes good at that but I wanna see what else he can do. I'm sure he can pull something off with practice.

I didn't expect George to make it. I know hes only 23 but he just seems so old and I thought he sounded like he had a frog in his throat too. but im willing to give him another chance. I think we have the best female singers but I'm looking forward to some male singers. Jon Peter Lewis and Matthew Metzgers is coming back. I wanna see at least another guy make it. Hopefully 2

I am happy with tonights results, and with the people picked for the Wild Card show. I hope John Peter Lewis gets through to the top 12.:D *crosses fingers*

Originally posted by ~*Hannah_Lee*~
I said from day one that he looked like Conan!! :lol: :lol: Yes! I see him and I just crack up.

Originally posted by ¤MsConanOBrien¤
Im surprised Jon got the most votes (28%!!) :eek:. But Im happy. :D He looks like Conans younger brother.

OMG he does look like conans younger brother :lol:
Yeah, I was expecting Jasmine to get the most votes by far. And John and George be close in their votes. But John had the most votes, I wasn't expecting that. :)

Originally posted by Burley_Furley
OMG he does look like conans younger brother :lol:
Yeah, I was expecting Jasmine to get the most votes by far. And John and George be close in their votes. But John had the most votes, I wasn't expecting that. :) me too.

Jasmine and Diana are my favorites this year!!

Go Katie Webber for Wildcard!! and Jon Peter Lewis and Eric Yoder and Elizabeth :woohoo:

Lisa Leuschner better make it to the top 12 this time! I personally think she deserves it most out of all the wild card contestants.

I'm voting for Eric Yoder, George Huff, Jon Peter Lewis, and Katie Webber. I'm surprised that Marque Lynche was chosen for the Wild Card. I thought he was OK that night but not the best out of the Wild Card contestants.

I didn't know this until a few days ago but Webber is from the same town that one of my sisters currently resides in, Santa Cruz. But that would be no reason to vote for her. I think she has a great voice and should have gone to the top 3 in Week 1. It is no surprise to me, then, that she has been given a second chance.

Originally posted by Brian
I'm surprised that Marque Lynche was chosen for the Wild Card. I thought he was OK that night but not the best out of the Wild Card contestants.

I thought he was great... I still know him as Tate though. If anybody didn't know, Marque used to be on the Mickey Mouse Club with Justin, JC, Britney, Christina, and Keri...

I hope he does a good job and makes it through to the next round!

I also remember watching Marque Lynche aon the Mickey Mouse Club also. I am voting for him. My favorite person coming back to the wild card is Jon Peter Lewis. To get some guys in the top 12 I am voting for Jon, Marque, Matthew, and George. If anyone noticed that every year there is always the same amount of guys and girls. They would need 4 guys from the wild card to make it even this year.



GO JON, MARQUE, MATTHEW, AND, GEORGE.

GOOD LUCK!

Originally posted by Brian
I'm voting for Eric Yoder, George Huff, Jon Peter Lewis, and Katie Webber. I'm surprised that Marque Lynche was chosen for the Wild Card. I thought he was OK that night but not the best out of the Wild Card contestants.

I didn't know this until a few days ago but Webber is from the same town that one of my sisters currently resides in, Santa Cruz. But that would be no reason to vote for her. I think she has a great voice and should have gone to the top 3 in Week 1. It is no surprise to me, then, that she has been given a second chance. i like the 4 people you're voting for!! Eric, George, Jon, and Katie!! But im also rooting for E. LeTendre

Originally posted by Nikkiz
I also remember watching Marque Lynche aon the Mickey Mouse Club also. I am voting for him. My favorite person coming back to the wild card is Jon Peter Lewis. To get some guys in the top 12 I am voting for Jon, Marque, Matthew, and George. If anyone noticed that every year there is always the same amount of guys and girls. They would need 4 guys from the wild card to make it even this year.



GO JON, MARQUE, MATTHEW, AND, GEORGE.

GOOD LUCK! JW, what year was Marque, Britney, and Justin in the MMC?

I don't think I'm gonna vote but if i did it would probably be for Jon Peter Lewis. Maybe Matthew, but most likely Jon Peter Lewis because my friend really likes him.

Marque who went by Tate then, Britney and Justin were on the MMc in Seasons 6 &7. J.C. Chasez was on for seasons 4, 5, 6, and7. I have all of seasons 4, 5, 6, and 7 so even though Marque didn't make it I can still watch him on my tapes of him. I still liked him even though he was cut before he could even sing that night.