Thoughts on tonight's results show (spoilers possible)

[David]

Well well. Fantasia and Diana got through.

Im pretty pleased, them 2 are two talented girls. I really wanted Katie Webber to get through though. Being unbiased, i thought she had one of the top 2 performances last night.

Anyways... what are your thoughts? I just have one thought right now.. and that is that there is something that bugs me about Fantasia.. I just dont know what though, however i really really like her at the same time. Odd. :lol:

So far, my vote goes to Matthew Rodgers (that Rose Bowl guy) for next round. Hopefully he'll please us. I really really dont want the brothers to get through :lol:

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

Im glad Diana made it! She was my fav! Fantasia just... bugs me. I really dont know whats so great about her. Oh well.

[david&maddie4ever]

I don't know what the judges saw in Fantasia that I didn't see...she's not my favorite. Her voice is annoying. There's no doubt she can sing and perform, but she bugs me. :o

I was really, really, really hoping for Katie and Matt, but I was almost positive that Katie would be in! :eek: I was so disappointed. Diana's really good, though. I guess she deserves it.

~Lauren

:sheep

[David]

Originally posted by ¤MsConanOBrien¤
Im glad Diana made it! She was my fav! Fantasia just... bugs me. I really dont know whats so great about her. Oh well. Yup. I liked Diana ever since her audition in Hawaii (i think thats where she auditioned... am i correct?)

[-*Leah*-]

I really like Fantasia, and I like the way the vote turned out.:)

[ChristyHeadIsSexy]

I was hoping that Diana would get the most amount of votes and that Katie would get the second highest and Fantasia third. Even though Fantasia's a good singer, I was surprised with how much the judge's praised her because I just didn't think it was that good. Her performance was alright with me.

[Krisalicious]

I like Fantasia a lot. I don't even really know why...I mean..I'm not sure which judge it was, probably Simon, but whoever said she sounds like Macy Gray was right. And I can't STAND Macy Gray. I dunno...I guess Fantasia just has a more pleasing voice than Macy lol. I don't like Diana that much though..and I have no idea why..she has a nice voice but I dunno. I guess I would have liked it more if Katie got in instead of Diana.

[Krisalicious]

oh yeah, and is it just me or was Diana the one that called Simon gay?? I really think it was her...but I'm not sure :lol: someone help me out here.

[LucyCompanyPhan]

I don't like Fantasia. She sounds way too much like Macy Gray for me. My friend does the FUNNIEST impression of her. hhahaha its great. But I was sure Fantasia would make it. I hope she doesn't win, I just don't picture her winning. Anyway I was hoping Katie Webber would've made it but oh well. When it was between Matt and Diana I was hoping it was Matt because I wanted to hear him sing again but after watching Diana sing she really did deserve it because she has a great voice. I like her. Anyway...can't wait for next week.

[Brian]

Originally posted by Krisalicious
oh yeah, and is it just me or was Diana the one that called Simon gay?? I really think it was her...but I'm not sure :lol: someone help me out here.


It wasn't her. That was Kira.

[Vegas Girl]

Krisalicious, my son and I are cracking up over your avatar. :lol:
We thought that contestant was so funny!