Rank the Top 8

[EmoJoe]

YOU.KNOW.THE.DRILL.


1. David Archuleta (he will have to like, kill a pig live on the stage to fall from #1 on my rankings because he is just awesome. TEAM ARCHULETA FOR IDOL '08!)


*gap*


2. Brooke (she's been disappointing these past few weeks, but i still love her and her unique, mellow sound)
3. Michael (really stepped up his game these past few weeks)
4. Carly (seems like a nice person, great voice, and has given a lot of good performances)
5. Kristy (yeah i like her...i think she's been improving lately and she has a nice voice and a good personality)
6. David C (hes good, but i dont really care for him ALL that much, just cause i dunno...i dont care for his style. but i wont deny his talent)
7. Jason (i think his routine is kind of getting old, but i dig his unique style still).


8. Syesha (good voice, but she seems like she's acting to me when she's singing and i dunno...in a season with a lot of unique voices and talent, she's...the opposite of unique).


the only one i dont really care for is Syesha, but i dont think she's that bad either. and i enjoy her performances. so yeah, once again...i think this is turning out to be a really good season.

[Krisalicious]

YOU.KNOW.THE.DRILL.


1. David Archuleta (he will have to like, kill a pig live on the stage to fall from #1 on my rankings because he is just awesome. TEAM ARCHULETA FOR IDOL '08!)




That's not even that unusual. You eat pork, right? :p

ANYWAYZ.

1. David A.
2. Carly
3. David C.
4. Michael
5. Jason
6. Brooke
7. Syesha
8. Kristy

[*InThisMoment*]

1. David Archuleta. <3
2. Doesn't matter
3. Doesn't matter
4. Doesn't matter
5. Doesn't matter
6. Doesn't matter
7. Doesn't matter
8. Doesn't matter

If I feel like making a more extensive report at a later time, I will. :)

[*InThisMoment*]

That's not even that unusual. You eat pork, right? :p
Yeah, man, he was just tryna make dinner. :grady:

[Buffyboy323]

LOVE:
1. David Archuleta - NEED I SAY MORE?
2. Brooke White - She's probably my new #3 favorite Idol contestant ever (after Carrie and Arch, of course.)

LIKE:
3. Jason Castro - Still a favorite, but he's been sucking lately. Sorry for that one SO fan who considered him her "peace of ass." ;)
4. Carly Smithson - She REALLY needs to start picking better songs. It's gotten to a point where I'm caring less and less about her....

5. Syesha Mercado - For the first time ever - PAULA WAS RIGHT! Syesha just might be this seasons' "Dark Horse." Personally, I think she's the most underrated contestant on the show right now.
6. Michael Johns - He's good. I don't think he'll win it though.

8. Kristy Lee Cook - I enjoyed her last week, but I still am not too fond of her. She's gone next week, I think.

Ugh...
9. David Cook - I'd rather not comment.

[*InThisMoment*]

3. Jason Castro - Still a favorite, but he's been sucking lately. Sorry for that one SO fan who considered him her "peace of ass." ;)

LMAO who was that? :lookaroun

Actually.. I think he's been nothing but a suckfest from top 12 on, but he's still fyne as hell. :grady: But even that can't make me care if he goes home next week. :o

[Impressions]

OK, I tried to be realistic as possible.

1. David A.
2. David C.
3. Michael
4. Carly
5. Syesha
6. Brooke

GAP

7. Jason
8. Kristy Lee

[Karen*]

1. David Cook
2. Michael Johns
3. Carly Smithson
4. David Archuleta
5. Syesha Mercado
6. Jason Castro
7. Brooke White
8. Kristy Lee Cook

[howierules86]

1. David Archuleta
2. Kristy Lee Cook (still love her)
3. Michael Johns
4. Carly Smithson
5. Syesha Mercado
6. Jason Castro
7. David Cook
8. Brooke White

Since Ramiele Malubay (my #4 seed) just HAD to get eliminated last night, everyone ranked below her has simply moved up a notch.

[Cactus Jack]

LOVE:
1. David Archuleta - NEED I SAY MORE?
2. Brooke White - She's probably my new #3 favorite Idol contestant ever (after Carrie and Arch, of course.)

LIKE:
3. Jason Castro - Still a favorite, but he's been sucking lately. Sorry for that one SO fan who considered him her "peace of ass." ;)
4. Carly Smithson - She REALLY needs to start picking better songs. It's gotten to a point where I'm caring less and less about her....

5. Syesha Mercado - For the first time ever - PAULA WAS RIGHT! Syesha just might be this seasons' "Dark Horse." Personally, I think she's the most underrated contestant on the show right now.
6. Michael Johns - He's good. I don't think he'll win it though.

8. Kristy Lee Cook - I enjoyed her last week, but I still am not too fond of her. She's gone next week, I think.

Ugh...
9. David Cook - I'd rather not comment.
Check your PMs

[I Love Lamp]

1-3. David C., Carly, and Brooke (in no particular order)
4. Michael Johns
5. Syesha
6. David A.
7. Kristy
8. Jason

[Buffyboy323]

LMAO who was that? :lookaroun

Actually.. I think he's been nothing but a suckfest from top 12 on, but he's still fyne as hell. :grady: But even that can't make me care if he goes home next week. :o
Haha! I wonder WHO! "Piece of ass." LOL.... That's hilarious.

Out of all of his top 12 performances so far, I liked his "Hallelujah" performance best. That's about it though. I really do like him, so I hope he improves in the coming weeks.

[Buffyboy323]

Check your PMs
:idea:

Alrighty...

[*InThisMoment*]

Haha! I wonder WHO! "Piece of ass." LOL.... That's hilarious.

Out of all of his top 12 performances so far, I liked his "Hallelujah" performance best. That's about it though. I really do like him, so I hope he improves in the coming weeks.
Hehe. http://i175.photobucket.com/albums/w159/DorkyW00tage31/Random/teehee.gif

I really enjoyed that, as well. To be honest, I liked all of his performances in the top 24 and on, up until top 12. I just feel like he's become boring and predictable. :/

[Cactus Jack]

Hehe. http://i175.photobucket.com/albums/w159/DorkyW00tage31/Random/teehee.gif

I really enjoyed that, as well. To be honest, I liked all of his performances in the top 24 and on, up until top 12. I just feel like he's become boring and predictable. :/
Yeah ditto, I think he;s been taking something before every show, and I dont mean steroids

[Chocoholic]

1. David Cook
2. Michael Johns

3-8. the rest of the group

[EmoJoe]

Hehe. http://i175.photobucket.com/albums/w159/DorkyW00tage31/Random/teehee.gif

I really enjoyed that, as well. To be honest, I liked all of his performances in the top 24 and on, up until top 12. I just feel like he's become boring and predictable. :/
i agree. i think his time is coming.

[Cactus Jack]

i agree. i think his time is coming.
Maybe next week or the week after that , he could make top 6

[Buffyboy323]

Yeah ditto, I think he;s been taking something before every show, and I dont mean steroids
He was probably smoking something.... :whistle:

[Buffyboy323]

Maybe next week or the week after that , he could make top 6
I'm thinking he'll make the top 5. Kristy Lee and Syesha will probably go before him.

[Cactus Jack]

I'm thinking he'll make the top 5. Kristy Lee and Syesha will probably go before him.
Yeah probably

Actualyl I predict the top 5 being David A, Carly, Brooke, David C. and Michael ( in that order too, with David A winning)

[Cactus Jack]

He was probably smoking something.... :whistle:
LOL on The Soup the guy said he looked stoned when talking to Ryan last week :rotflmao:

[Buffyboy323]

LOL on The Soup the guy said he looked stoned when talking to Ryan last week :rotflmao:
:rofl:

Joel McHale kicks ass!

[Cactus Jack]

:rofl:

Joel McHale kicks ass!
LOL sure does!