Who win an Ultimate American Idol?

[Cactus Jack]

I was just thinking this, let's say they had a thing with all 6 winners so far, and they snag and everyone voted on theultimate winner, who would win?

[Cactus Jack]

id say it would be between Kelly, Carrie and Jordin, with Kelly or Carrie winning

[Krisalicious]

Kelly... definitely. The only other person who comes close to her is Carrie. All the rest stand no chance :D

[EmoJoe]

Kelly was the most consistent performer on AI ever, so...her.

i think Carrie has a stronger voice though so she might win too.

i'd say it would rank:

6) Taylor
5) Ruben
4) Fantasia
3) Jordin
2) Carrie
1) Kelly

with 1-2 possibly being switched.

[PlayOn]

CARRIE! Check out the siggy. :D

[BarneyFife]

Carrie Underwood, with Kelly Clarkson a close 2nd.

[HuntingtonM15]

With the way their careers are currently going...Carrie would win hands down. The girl cannot be stopped.

[I Love Lamp]

I would rank:

1. Kelly
2. Carrie
3. Jordin
4. Ruben
5. Taylor
6. Fantasia

Although Kelly and Carrie are the only two that I actually really liked, and only Kelly is the one that I REALLY liked.

[I Love John Ritter]

I like Taylor the best, but I think Carrie would probably win.