AI7 - Top 11 Performance Night: The Beatles, Part II (spoiler/discussion thread)

[EmoJoe]

WOOO.

D'Arch better redeem himself this week!1

[EmoJoe]

Amanda - Back in the USSR

Doing okay, but not her best. Her usual thing but she sounds kinda off-key at times. Okay I guess.

Randy: Perfect song, but a little pitchy. I give it a 7 out of 10.
Paula: The timing and pitch were a little off, but it was authentic.
Simon: It was predictable, and a bit of a mess in parts. You need to do something different, or you're going to get boring.

[Krisalicious]

Amanda - I didn't like it -______- I do agree, she is getting sorta boring doing the same old thing each week.

[EmoJoe]

btw David A is singing the long and winding road :happyface i hope he does ok!

[EmoJoe]

Kristy - Hide Your Love Away

Uhh much better then last week. Sounds kinda pitchy at times. Very pitchy actually. Not that good really...it's ok, but nothing GREAT.

Randy: One of my favorite Beatles songs, but it was a boring and safe arrangement.
Paula: It was safe, and just "good".
Simon: You're not a good performer. It's like musical wallpaper - you notice it, but you don't remember it. The last two seconds were okay.

Meh, 6/10. It was alright. Not great.

[Krisalicious]

Kristy - -________________- Please let this girl go home this week?!

[EmoJoe]

David Arch - "The Long and Winding Road"

needless to say it's MUCH better then last week. LOL at the audience screaming at like every little thing it does. i REALLY enjoyed this. not as good as Imagine but much better then the last two weeks.

Randy: David Archuleta is back! These are the type of songs you should be singing. You could've done a little more with it, but you did a very nice job.
Paula: Your voice has such a purity that makes it exciting...or something.
Simon: Last week was a mess, but this week, you were amazing. You really sold the song.

YESSS :woohoo: HE REBOUNDED!

[Krisalicious]

David - HASDPJSDPFOKDFSKZKDFOZIJDSLkjdsfkjlfkjvxdshas AMAZING. Thank God, after last week's disaster :lol:

[EmoJoe]

OK IM TIRED OF DOING THE FRIGGEN JUDGES COMMENTS.

Michael - it was okay. still nothing great from him. im getting bored of him.

[Krisalicious]

Michael - Not so good and he hit a REALLY bad note at the beginning :lol: but .. meh. I'm starting to lose interest in him.

[Krisalicious]

OK IM TIRED OF DOING THE FRIGGEN JUDGES COMMENTS.

Michael - it was okay. still nothing great from him. im getting bored of him.

BLAH I FEEL THE SAME WAY!

It's like, every week I hope he does something amazing because he has such a GREAT great great voice, but he never does. Geez. He needs another performance like Bohemian Rhapsody, because I think that was his only phenomenal performance this season.

[Cactus Jack]

Amanda- Pretty good

Kristy- Not too great, but better

D'Archie Letta-AWESOME!!!

Michael-Not his best, but awesome song choice

[Krisalicious]

Brooke - Bad -.- she should have sang HEY JUDE, damn it, lol

[EmoJoe]

Brooke - meh, not her best, but last week was good enough to last her like 3 more weeks. lol.

[EmoJoe]

BLAH I FEEL THE SAME WAY!

It's like, every week I hope he does something amazing because he has such a GREAT great great voice, but he never does. Geez. He needs another performance like Bohemian Rhapsody, because I think that was his only phenomenal performance this season.
yeah i agree...he did AWESOME in Hollywood but since then hes been going downhill every week.

this night SUCKS so far, aside from David. that'll teach them not to repeat themes hopefully.

[TVFactFan]

Why did it look like Brooke was about to cry after being crticized? I was glad she held it in because she would have looked kind of weird

[Cactus Jack]

Brooke - Bad -.- she should have sang HEY JUDE, damn it, lol
:nod:


Brooke was not the greatest here;s her song

Here come the airline tickets do do do do

[Krisalicious]

David C - LOVED him! Whatever to Simon lol it was a great performance!

[EmoJoe]

David C - decent, not the best, but not bad...again though, he did so well last week that he's probably safe for like the next 4 weeks, at least. lol.

[Krisalicious]

BLACKBIRD. Ahh. THAT's what Brooke should have sang. Random... but mmm.. we'll see how Carly does with it.

[Krisalicious]

Carly - I thought it was really good, but I think she could have chosen a better song.

[EmoJoe]

Carly - starts off meh but gets REALLY good at the end...i liked it. i dunno what Simon's problem was.

[Cactus Jack]

David C- Awesome

Carly-Coulda chosen a better song , but was really good

[Krisalicious]

Jason - Pretty good, but not the greatest

[EmoJoe]

Jason - i thought it was ok, not THAT bad, but not that good either.

i agree with Simon, doing Beatles night again = big mistake.

[Cactus Jack]

Jason- Good but not his best

[Cactus Jack]

"I wanna touch everybody tonight"

Thats what SHE said
:lol: ;)

[Krisalicious]

Syesha - Good but she just doesn't really interest me

[EmoJoe]

Syesha - really liked this...huge improvement over last week.

i have a feeling shes gonna be like Amy Adams & Jessica Sierra though - boring top 12 performance, great top 11 performance, then an okay top 10 performance, and then she'll be eliminated.

[Cactus Jack]

Syesha-awesome

[Krisalicious]

So, Ramiele is last? Hmmm does this mean she'll finally pick a song that is NOT boring and do amazing? :lol:

[Cactus Jack]

So, Ramiele is last? Hmmm does this mean she'll finally pick a song that is NOT boring and do amazing? :lol:
Maybe!

[Krisalicious]

Chikezie - I'm gonna regret I ever said this, but... I LOVED HIM!!!!

[EmoJoe]

Chikezie - this...was ODD. o_O wtf. i liked last week better...it was good but kinda...weird. lol.

[Cactus Jack]

Chikeze was.................INTERESTING

[Krisalicious]

Ramiele - Pretty good but she can do better than this, once again.

[Cactus Jack]

Ramiele- A lot better than last week

[EmoJoe]

Ramiele - i thought she was good, i dunno why the judges didnt. and Paula's critism was retarded...last week you tell her to stop singing slow songs, so she does an upbeat song and then you tell her to sing slow songs. uh.

[Krisalicious]

RANKINGS:

1. David A.
2. David C.
3. Carly
4. Chikezie
5. Syesha
6. Jason
7. Michael
8. Ramiele
9. Brooke
10. Amanda
11. KRISTY. GO HOME PLS.

Bottom 3 Predictions:
Kristy
Syesha
Chikezie

I only say this because I feel like everyone else has a really strong fan base, lol. So we'll see.

[EmoJoe]

rankings.


1. David Arch - 9.5/10
GAP
GAP
GAP
GAP
2. Syesha - 9/10
3. Carly - 8.5/10
4. Ramiele - 8/10
5. David C - 7.5/10
6. Chikezie - 7/10
7. Brooke - 6.5/10
8. Jason C - 6/10
9. Amanda - 6/10
10. Michael - 5.5/10
11. Kristy - 5.5/10

no one tonight was really AWFUL but everyone besides David, Syesha, and maybe Carly was pretty meh.

im gonna say...Michael, Kristy, and Amanda for the bottom 3, with either Kristy or Amanda going home and Michael safe first.

[howierules86]

Did anyone do any voting last night? Here's who I voted for:

Kristy Lee Cook (x16)
Ramiele Malubay (x8)
Amanda Overmyer (x6)
Carly Smithson (x2)

How about you?

[EmoJoe]

i voted for Archuleta a few times. cause he rules.

Lynn voted for him 100 times, first time she's ever voted for an Idol contestant. im sure shed want you to know :)

[Cactus Jack]

i voted for Archuleta a few times. cause he rules.

Lynn voted for him 100 times, first time she's ever voted for an Idol contestant. im sure shed want you to know :)
Wow awesome, why was it her first time?

[Krisalicious]

omg wtf Carly in the bottom three?! I am scared.