AI7 - Top 12 Performance Night: The Beatles (spoiler/discussion thread)

[EmoJoe]

YES. top 12 is finally here. :woohoo:

it's 2 hours tomorrow!

[Karen*]

Holla holla.

Can't wait. :D :heart:

[Cactus Jack]

Bump

[Cactus Jack]

Song spoilers
http://photos.tmz.com/galleries/idol_top_twelve_perform


Great choices, even though I wanted to see David C or Michael to do Helter Skelter, and David Arch to do Let It Be, Hey Jude, Something or Yesterday

[Cactus Jack]

I think the SET is the next American Idol....and David Archuleta

[EmoJoe]

wow, HUGE stage :eek:

[EmoJoe]

Syesha - not bad. not the most exciting performance, but it's okay overall.

[EmoJoe]

Chikezie - i...actually really liked this. it was a little ODD, but i loved how it was actually EXCITING, unlike his other performances. he might have made me not hate him tonight!

[Cactus Jack]

Chikezie - i...actually really liked this. it was a little ODD, but i loved how it was actually EXCITING, unlike his other performances. he might have made me not hate him tonight!
Ditto!

[EmoJoe]

Ramiele - ugh, that's three mediocre performances in a row for her. what's happening? not her best.

[Cactus Jack]

Syesha - not bad. not the most exciting performance, but it's okay overall.
Yeah


Ramiele was alright

[EmoJoe]

Jason - not his best...and not nearly as good as last week. overall it's good, but not great.

[Cactus Jack]

Jason- not the best but still pretty good

[EmoJoe]

Carly - EXCELLENT. one of my favorite performances of this season so far. just an awesome performance on the whole.

[Cactus Jack]

Carly=AWESOME!

[Cactus Jack]

David was awesome too

[EmoJoe]

David C - i don't think he can win like Simon said, but this was really good, probably his best yet.

[Cactus Jack]

David C - i don't think he can win like Simon said, but this was really good, probably his best yet.
Yeah, we all know who the winner will and should be :D

[EmoJoe]

Brooke - not quite as good as last week, but still really good.

[Cactus Jack]

Brooke- she was great,not like last week though

[EmoJoe]

David H - not good. way too manic. he could be in trouble tomorrow.

[Cactus Jack]

David H - not good. way too manic. he could be in trouble tomorrow.
Sure could be, but knowing his scandal, people might let him through till he strips..

[EmoJoe]

Amanda - good. not as good as last week, and i still don't care for her style, but it was good.

[*InThisMoment*]

EXCUSE ME WHO ARE THESE PPL I WANT TO SEE DAVID ARCHULETA


The no caps rule can diaf. <3

[Cactus Jack]

Amanda- good, but not as great as last week

[EmoJoe]

Michael - meh, not his best. it was ok, but nothing special.

[Cactus Jack]

EXCUSE ME WHO ARE THESE PPL I WANT TO SEE DAVID ARCHULETA


The no caps rule can diaf. <3
They are:
Jason Castro, Brooke White, Ramiele Mulcabay, Carly Smithson, MIchael Johns, Amanda Overmyer, Chikeze, David Hernandez, David Cook, Syehsa Mercado and Kristy Lee Cook

[Cactus Jack]

Michael - meh, not his best. it was ok, but nothing special.
Yeah wasnt as awesome as expected

[EmoJoe]

Kristy - erm...this is kinda like...o_O...with how country it is. i think she kinda overdid it lol. it's cool how she added her own spit to it but it was kinda over-the-top country. just a little TWANG would've been fine. it wasn't a great vocal either. this...wasn't good.

[Cactus Jack]

Kristy- yer goin tomorrow, that wasnt good at all

[*InThisMoment*]

Kristy.. what the hell, girlfriend?

OMG DAVID I'M NERVOUS

[*InThisMoment*]

They are:
Jason Castro, Brooke White, Ramiele Mulcabay, Carly Smithson, MIchael Johns, Amanda Overmyer, Chikeze, David Hernandez, David Cook, Syehsa Mercado and Kristy Lee Cook
thx u 4 telling me :wave:

[Cactus Jack]

thx u 4 telling me :wave:
LOL youre welcome

[Cactus Jack]

David-coulda been better but I still liked it

[EmoJoe]

David A - ack...i didnt like this *_* im pissed though, cause they told him to do an upbeat song when he really probably shouldve done a ballad this week.

[Cactus Jack]

David A - ack...i didnt like this *_* im pissed though, cause they told him to do an upbeat song when he really probably shouldve done a ballad this week.
Yeah ditto

[*InThisMoment*]

OMG I wanna hug David. :( I knew the second he was talking about how nervous he was it was gonna be a losing battle. O.O

I love youu babyboo. <3 DIAF anyone who says anything remotely negative about my babyboo. :)

[Cactus Jack]

OMG I wanna hug David. :( I knew the second he was talking about how nervous he was it was gonna be a losing battle. O.O

I love youu babyboo. <3 DIAF anyone who says anything remotely negative about my babyboo. :)
I wont, tonight wanst his best...actually it wasm y least fav from him almost

[EmoJoe]

I wont, tonight wanst his best...actually it wasm y least fav from him almost
it was easily his worst :lol:

anyway... my bottom 3 prediction is:

Syesha (safe first - she went first, and was just okay).
Kristy (awful, but she has the sympathy vote, so she's not going home).
David H (eliminated - he was pretty bad, went in the middle of the show, and was forgettable. he's a goner).

Ramiele could sneak in there too.

[Cactus Jack]

it was easily his worst :lol:

anyway... my bottom 3 prediction is:

Syesha (safe first - she went first, and was just okay).
Kristy (awful, but she has the sympathy vote, so she's not going home).
David H (eliminated - he was pretty bad, went in the middle of the show, and was forgettable. he's a goner).

Ramiele could sneak in there too.
Ditto

[PlayOn]

I missed David A's performance because my aunt JUST HAD to watch the last few minutes of The Biggest Loser. lol. Just kidding. I was engrossed by it to, I must say.
Anyway, was David A really that bad?
I called him and didn't get a busy signal. Mainly when I call his line is busy.

[Krisalicious]

Damn I haven't seen the episode yet because I just got back from vacation tonight -________- I'm relying on youtube or somewhere on the internet to let me watch it! Haha ahhh reading this thread has made me soooo curious. From what you all say it seems like David H. or Kristy is gone tomorrow, neither of which I'd really mind.

BUT I WANNA SEE MY DAVID ARCH!! *dies because she hasn't seen tonight's ep*

[Krisalicious]

Alright I just watched David Archuleta's performance tonight and WTF it almost made me cry how bad it was...because he is not that bad! Poor kid. Ahhhh. Well whatever I'm sure he'll be amazing again soon!

[Karen*]

David Cook is totes my fave right now. :eek: :woohoo: :biglove:

[Karen*]

Oh gosh, I hope David Hernandez isn't the one leaving tomorrow. >.< :crying: :mrtarver: He needs to make the tour. :p I think he'll be in the bottom though. I hope Kristy leaves, but we all know the pretty girls with the mediocre voices tend to sneak their way in somehow. Haley Scarnato, anyone?!

[howierules86]

I wonder why only the Top 10 are able to go on the AI tour and not the Top 12. What's the point of doing a Top 12 if they're not going to allow #11 & #12 to go on the tour?

[Cactus Jack]

Oh gosh, I hope David Hernandez isn't the one leaving tomorrow. >.< :crying: :mrtarver: He needs to make the tour. :p I
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

[EmoJoe]

I wonder why only the Top 10 are able to go on the AI tour and not the Top 12. What's the point of doing a Top 12 if they're not going to allow #11 & #12 to go on the tour?
there's a RUMOR that they're doing a wildcard round this year on Idol Gives Back where they'll bring back the 12th & 11th placers as well as 4 other semi-finalists that didn't make the top 12, and then they'll perform and people will vote for their favorite and the two with the highest number of votes will go on tour with the top 10. PRETTY KEWL.

[EmoJoe]

Alright I just watched David Archuleta's performance tonight and WTF it almost made me cry how bad it was...because he is not that bad! Poor kid. Ahhhh. Well whatever I'm sure he'll be amazing again soon!
i know, it made me feel so bad :( i guess the pressure of being "the one to beat" combined with having the pimp spot made him crack. he was really good in rehersals apparently.

[EmoJoe]

OK ANYWAY...these are my final rankings of the performances:

1. Carly - 9.5/10
2. Brooke - 9.5/10
3. David C - 9/10
4. Chikezie - 8.5/10
5. Amanda - 8/10
6. Syesha - 8/10
7. Michael - 7/10
8. Jason - 6.5/10
9. David A - 5.5/10 (sorry David...but you were BAD :( )
10. Ramiele - 5.5/10
11. David H - 5/10
12. Kristy - 4.5/10

i don't think Kristy is going home, though. i think it's either going to be Syesha or David H.

[Cactus Jack]

there's a RUMOR that they're doing a wildcard round this year on Idol Gives Back where they'll bring back the 12th & 11th placers as well as 4 other semi-finalists that didn't make the top 12, and then they'll perform and people will vote for their favorite and the two with the highest number of votes will go on tour with the top 10. PRETTY KEWL.
thats AWESOME! Hope they dont bring back Colton, Luke, Garrett or Kady

[Brent88]

Best: Carly, Brooke, Chikezie(really shocked me), David C

Worst: KRISTY!!!!!!!, David H, Syesha(primarily for being forgettable), Ramiele, David A ohno:

[JT]

David A's performance was horrible. Really painful to watch.

The best three were David C, Carly, and Amanda. The others were dull, weird, or just baaaaad. I do admit that Kristy's was delightfully campy, however.

[EmoJoe]

http://www.etonline.com/news/2008/03/59501/index.html possibly the reason David did so bad last night?

i dont mean to make "excuses" for him or anything but it seemed odd to be he just randomly collapsed like that...