AI7 - Top 8 Girls spoiler/discussion thread

[EmoJoe]

for tonight's show :)

hopefully TMZ leaks the song choices again!

[Cactus Jack]

for tonight's show :)

hopefully TMZ leaks the song choices again!
Ditto, only last night I wanted the Joe-leaked/posted ones not the TMZ leaked ones .

[EmoJoe]

lol, i didnt leak them :lol:...

and yeah, those would've been better song choices then the ones we got last night. -_-

[Cactus Jack]

lol, i didnt leak them :lol:...

and yeah, those would've been better song choices then the ones we got last night. -_-
Yup LOL

[EmoJoe]

last-minute spoilers for the girls


Amanda Overmyer -- Joan Jet "Hate Myself For Loving You"
Syesha Mercado -- Whitney Houston "Saving All My Love For You"
Kristy Lee Cook -- Journey "Faithfully"
Asia'h Epperson -- Whitney Houston "I Wanna Dance With Somebody"
Kady Malloy -- Queen "Who Wants To Live Forever"
Carly Smithson -- Cyndi Lauper "I Drove All Night"
Brooke White -- Pat Benatar "Love Is A Battlefield"
Ramiele Malubay -- Phil Collins "Against All Odds"

apparantly in this order...
1) Asia'h
2) Kady
3) Amanda
4) Ramiele
5) Kristy
6) Brooke
7) Carly
8) Syesha
Syesha, As'iah, and...surprise...KADY apparently sounded the best in rehersal. the Kady thing is sort of iffy though.

[Cactus Jack]

last-minute spoilers for the girls


Syesha, As'iah, and...surprise...KADY apparently sounded the best in rehersal. the Kady thing is sort of iffy though.
Souds great and no We Built This city YAY!

Is this from IDF? Was last night's too?

[Cactus Jack]

last-minute spoilers for the girls


Syesha, As'iah, and...surprise...KADY apparently sounded the best in rehersal. the Kady thing is sort of iffy though.
Yeah it does, sounds like someone knew Kady and she forced them to write that or she would kill them

[EmoJoe]

As'iah - pretty decent. better then last week. songs like this fit her MUCH better. the vocal's a little shaky but overall it's good.

[EmoJoe]

Kady - Kat sang this in S5 and i loved it. and erm...Kady. well, lol um she definitely did not nail it. it sounds...very off-key at times. it's her best yet cause there are some times when she sounds really nice but it's still sub-par. i think she's gone tomorrow.

[Krisalicious]

As'iah - Pretty good... better than last week

Kady - WTF!! I hated this. She was pitchy to the maximum and ew wtf ugh bad!

[EmoJoe]

Amanda - this was actually a NORMAL performance, thank God. i didnt think it was GREAT but it was much better then last week. i still dont care for her that much but she was good. i think she's got a spot in the top 12.

[Krisalicious]

Amanda - Good...my favorite performance of hers so far

[Krisalicious]

Carly - AMAZING. STFU Simon *SLAP* I loved it.

[EmoJoe]

Carly - probably her best performance yet. i still wouldn't say that it's her "moment" but it's definitely her best so far, and probably the best of the night so far.

is Paula going to give EVERYONE a standing o?! LOL.

[Krisalicious]

Kristy: -__________- I don't know... meh. I don't think she should make top 12.

[EmoJoe]

Kristy - i never cared for her all that much, but i thought she did pretty nicely with this. she seems to be steadily improving. it wasn't AWESOME but it was pretty good, actually. i have to agree with Simon though that i can't see her getting all that far if she does make top 12.

[EmoJoe]

Kristy: -__________- I don't know... meh. I don't think she should make top 12.
i kind of agree...there are better girls from this bunch. she did well but i wouldn't want her to make it over anyone really good.

[Cactus Jack]

Everyopne's been good, Kady was better this week but I dont think she should be in the 12

[Krisalicious]

Ramiele: MEH I HATE THAT SONG -.- she did OKAY with it, but she can do sooooooooo much better. She is my favorite girl and I just want her to do amazing songs.

[Cactus Jack]

i kind of agree...there are better girls from this bunch. she did well but i wouldn't want her to make it over anyone really good.
Ditto

[Cactus Jack]

Ramiele: MEH I HATE THAT SONG -.- she did OKAY with it, but she can do sooooooooo much better. She is my favorite girl and I just want her to do amazing songs.
LOL ditto there, whenever someone does that song it's bad except for Scott, but thats not saying much either

[EmoJoe]

Ramiele - ehh...much better then last week but I HATE HATE HATE HATE this song. WHY WOULD SHE CHOSE IT. it was pretty good i guess. i find it odd that Simon called it old-fashioned but loved her first performance which was just as old-fashioned. but...erm yeah. not Ramiele's best but decent. she needs to choose better songs.

[Cactus Jack]

Ramiele - ehh...much better then last week but I HATE HATE HATE HATE this song. WHY WOULD SHE CHOSE IT. it was pretty good i guess. i find it odd that Simon called it old-fashioned but loved her first performance which was just as old-fashioned. but...erm yeah. not Ramiele's best but decent. she needs to choose better songs.
Yeah, she coulda picked a better song

[EmoJoe]

Brooke - this is...interesting. an acoustic version of this song seems so... weird. i really like her though just because she's so unique. kinda like the female Jason for me. i don't what the judges will think but i REALLY liked this.

[Krisalicious]

Brooke - I really liked it. I think the song would have sounded really awkward if she didn't do an acoustic version, like Simon said. It's a kind of like....disco-ish type song and that is so NOT Brooke, but this was.

[Cactus Jack]

Brooke was awesome, and great job at an acoustic version of a a hard rock/discoesque song

[EmoJoe]

Syesha - a little shouty at the big notes...she did a good job with it though. much better then last week.

[Krisalicious]

Syesha - Pretty good, but like Simon said, predictable. She's really not that exciting to me.

My rankings:

1. CARLYYYYYYY
2. Brooke
3. Amanda
4. Ramiele
5. As'iah
6. Syesha

GAP





7. Kristy

EXTRA LARGE GAP















8. Kady


So basically Kady DEFINITELY needs to go. Kristy too. I think everyone else deserves a spot in the top 12.

[Cactus Jack]

Syesha was great!

[EmoJoe]

all in all, i actually liked everyone tonight. MUCH better then last week.

1. Brooke
2. Carly
3. Syesha
4. Ramiele
5. Kristy
6, Amanda
7. As'iah
8. Kady

the only one who didnt do well was Kady, so she's a goner. i pick Kady to go home, and...i dont know who else. Kristy maybe? i thought she did pretty well though. i'll pick As'iah for now.

[*InThisMoment*]

Asia'h Epperson - Pretty good. Still sings like she has a mental disablity.
Kady Malloy - I kind of liked this. Some pitch problems but overall not BAD.
Amanda Overmyer - Not my thing, but I kind of like her because she's different.
Carly Smithson- I liked this better than her other performances so far. She looked decent tonight.
Kristy Lee Cook - As a general rule I'm definitely not a fan of her but this performance was kinda nice. I liked it.
Ramiele Maluboy - Wow, no other Idol contestant has ever performed this song before! Exciting choice. :) :) :) I'm so over this girl, because she brings nothing new. But she's friends with my Princess Danny so I'll let this pass. :thumbsup:
Brooke White - Very nice. Something different with a familiar song.
Syesha Mercado - Liked this quite a bit. Love that song.

[EmoJoe]

wow Lynn you're like Paula tonight. loved everyone. did they put something in your cup?!

[*InThisMoment*]

wow Lynn you're like Paula tonight. loved everyone. did they put something in your cup?!
:lookaroun Kristy was my favorite. Tonight was VERY strange.

[EmoJoe]

:lookaroun Kristy was my favorite. Tonight was VERY strange.
ummm i think Nigel's putting the vodka in your cup again, Lynn. :) have a nice hangover tomorrow.

[EmoJoe]

oh speaking of overdone Idol songs, i say we make a bet as to how and by who I Have Nothing will be done this season.

i say Ramielle, top 10 week.

[Stormtracker TF]

oh speaking of overdone Idol songs, i say we make a bet as to how and by who I Have Nothing will be done this season.

i say Ramielle, top 10 week.
Chikezie will after he makes the Top 12, and he'll be eliminated on Top 11 week after singing it.

[*InThisMoment*]

ummm i think Nigel's putting the vodka in your cup again, Lynn. :) have a nice hangover tomorrow.
I took a sip from Pauler's cup. SO WHAT.

[Cactus Jack]

Chikezie will after he makes the Top 12, and he'll be eliminated on Top 11 week after singing it.
LOL yeah


I say Syesha, top 11 week

[Karen*]

I have a feeling someone's gonna get robbed tomorrow. That's how it usually is before they pick the top 12. Someone sucky always sneaks their way in there. :lol:

I just hope Carly, Ramiele, Syesha, and Brooke all stay. :( :mrtarver:

[Karen*]

Oh, and ideally Kady and Kristy should be eliminated. I still think Amanda could be gone despite all the pimping with tonight's performance. But I'm pretty sure Carly and Brooke are the only locks. Everyone else is pretty much in danger.

[EmoJoe]

i think either As'iah or Syesha is a goner. i just don't know which one. i'm leaning towards As'iah.

[Cactus Jack]

i think either As'iah or Syesha is a goner. i just don't know which one. i'm leaning towards As'iah.
As a shocker elimination?

[EmoJoe]

Chikezie will after he makes the Top 12, and he'll be eliminated on Top 11 week after singing it.
lmao...oh no. Chikezie singing that song...MY EARS. horror:

[EmoJoe]

As a shocker elimination?
yeah, lol. it's top 16 week, we have to have a semi-shocker!

[Cactus Jack]

yeah, lol. it's top 16 week, we have to have a semi-shocker!
Sure do!