Rate the Idol Performance Above You

[David]

I know we had a thread like this last year, but I'm too lazy to find it, so let's start new.


Taylor Hicks - Just Once

[EmoJoe]

8/10

Katharine McPhee- Who Wants to Live Forever

[David]

9/10

Chris Daughtry - Innuendo

[EmoJoe]

9/10

Kellie Pickler- Fancy

[David]

9/10

Kevin Covais - Vincent

[EmoJoe]

7/10

Carrie Underwood- Making Love Out of Nothing At All (it can be other seasons right?)

[David]

^ Yep :)

10/10

Clay Aiken - Solitaire

[WendyMichelle20]

8/10

Paris Bennett - These Foolish Things

[David]

8.5/10

Bucky Covington - Wave on Wave

[I Love John Ritter]

8/10

Elliott Yamin - A Song for You

[Karen*]

10/10

Katharine McPhee - Come Rain or Come Shine

[David]

9.5/10

Ayla Brown - Unwritten

[EmoJoe]

8.5/10

Chris Daughtry- What a Wonderful World

[Cactus Jack]

9/10


Chris Daughtry-Renegade

[David]

8/10

Ace Young - We Will Rock You

[EmoJoe]

6/10

Kellie Pickler- Bohenium Rhapsody

[David]

9/10 since nobody expected her to pull it off as well as she did

Carrie Underwood - Hello, Young Lovers

[EmoJoe]

9.5/10 :D

Diana DeGarmo- My Heart Will Go On

[David]

7.5/10 (not one of her best)

Diana DeGarmo - Don't Cry Out Loud

[Cactus Jack]

9.5/10

Diana DeGarmo- No More Tears

[David]

10/10

George Huff - Against All Odds

[EmoJoe]

5/10 (that was my least favorite performance from him)

Bo Bice- I Don't Want to Be

[David]

8/10

Bo Bice - Long Long Road

[EmoJoe]

7/10...not his best

Katharine McPhee- Black Horse and the Cherry Tree (top 5 night)

[Karen*]

9.9/10

Chris Daughtry - I Walk the Line

[I Love John Ritter]

9/10

Anthony Fedorov - I Surrender

[Karen*]

9/10

Elliott Yamin - I Believe it to My Soul