Top 2 to sing TWO songs they've already done, and winners single

[EmoJoe]

http://idolforums.com/index.php?showtopic=430029&st=0&gopid=9417873&#entry9417873

i want it to go like this:

Taylor:
"A Crazy Little Thing Called Love"
"In the Ghetto"

Katharine:
"Somewhere Over the Rainbow"
"Who Wants to Live Forever/Come Rain or Come Shine"

it'll probably go:

Taylor:
"In the Ghetto"
"Try a Little Tenderness"

Katharine:
"Somewhere Over the Rainbow"
"Someone to Watch Over Me/Come Rain or Come Shine"

[Karen*]

I don't want Katharine to sing Somewhere Over the Rainbow...I don't wanna hear the same song being sung two weeks in a row. :barf:

I think Taylor and Kat should pick from the following songs:

TAYLOR
- You Send Me
- In the Ghetto
- Crazy Little Thing Called Love

KATHARINE
- Someone to Watch Over Me
- Come Rain or Come Shine
- Since I Fell for You

BTW, this is a good idea for the finale...gives both of them a fair advantage. :)

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

I heard that they had the option of 2 singing 2 past songs OR singing 1 past song plus a different one of their choice. Evidently Kat chose the 'safe' route and is singing 2 old songs, and Taylor is singing 1 old 1 new.