AI5: Final 3 Performances - official spoiler/discussion thread

[Karen*]

For tonight. :D

David, can you please sticky?

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

So excited. If Elliott doesnt go last Ima be pissed. He hasnt had the pimp spot since top 10. How many times have Kat and Taylor had it?! Ugh.

[Karen*]

So excited. If Elliott doesnt go last Ima be pissed. He hasnt had the pimp spot since top 10. How many times have Kat and Taylor had it?! Ugh.
Crystal, he's not going last tonight. :crying: According to spoilers on IDF, the performance order is Elliott, Kat, and Taylor.

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

Crystal, he's not going last tonight. :crying: According to spoilers on IDF, the performance order is Elliott, Kat, and Taylor.
Yeah I heard Taylor is going last too. Whateverrrr.

[Karen*]

Yeah I heard Taylor is going last too. Whateverrrr.
Uggghhh, I'm pissed though! He should've gotten the pimp spot LAST week, but they gave it to Kat instead (Maybe that's why she stayed instead of Chris? I don't know.)! So he pretty much got robbed of it again this week. pissed:

[Cactus Jack]

Uggghhh, I'm pissed though! He should've gotten the pimp spot LAST week, but they gave it to Kat instead (Maybe that's why she stayed instead of Chris? I don't know.)! So he pretty much got robbed of it again this week. pissed:
Yeah :(

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

Uggghhh, I'm pissed though! He should've gotten the pimp spot LAST week, but they gave it to Kat instead (Maybe that's why she stayed instead of Chris? I don't know.)! So he pretty much got robbed of it again this week. pissed:
I agree. Last week was his week, so he totally deserved it. Not that mattered much since he was top 2 :D. Im really nervous for him tomorrow though. I was feeling pretty confident last week, but now thats TONIGHT Im totally freaking out.

[EmoJoe]

Crystal, he's not going last tonight. :crying: According to spoilers on IDF, the performance order is Elliott, Kat, and Taylor.
uh oh....:eek:

Season 1- Nikki went first, she was out
Season 2- Kim L went first, she was out
Season 3- Jasmine went first, she was out
Season 4- Vonzell went first, she was out

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

uh oh....:eek:

Season 1- Nikki went first, she was out
Season 2- Kim L went first, she was out
Season 3- Jasmine went first, she was out
Season 4- Vonzell went first, she was out
Theyve also all been GIRLS, so hopefully itll stay that way.

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

Plus, K.Lo didnt stand a change against the Claymates and all those for Ruuuuuuuben. As for Jasmine, she had the whole friggan state of Hawaii for her, but a lot of people were pissed at her for lasting longer than La Toya. Who knows.

[Karen*]

Plus, K.Lo didnt stand a change against the Claymates and all those for Ruuuuuuuben. As for Jasmine, she had the whole friggan state of Hawaii for her, but a lot of people were pissed at her for lasting longer than La Toya. Who knows.
Yeah, Kat sure is suffering a lot of backlash for outlasting Chris.

[Cactus Jack]

Yeah, Kat sure is suffering a lot of backlash for outlasting Chris.
Yeah

[EmoJoe]

Yeah, Kat sure is suffering a lot of backlash for outlasting Chris.
:nod: it's like jasmine/latoya all over again...

[EmoJoe]

eliott kinda sucked at his first song o_O the judges liked it, besides simon, who said he needs to loosen up.

[Cactus Jack]

Elliott was Ok

I wonder why Clive isnt judging this year he always does

I wanna know what hios choice for Chris was gonna be

[Krisalicious]

Elliott was good.
Katharine gave me a headache.

[EmoJoe]

katharine didn't really do good, but it's all clive's fault.

HOW THE FREAKING HECK DOES RANDY BLAME HER FOR SONG CHOICE? good god.

[EmoJoe]

Taylor = some Bruce Springsteen song

i don't think he's doing that good of a job.

[EmoJoe]

paula needs to lay off of the alchohal -_-

and taylor's vocal really wasn't that good for his 1st song.

[Cactus Jack]

Kat was ok so was Taylor

[EmoJoe]

eliott's second choice was kinda bad

[EmoJoe]

katharine starts off a'capella :eek:

[Krisalicious]

I didn't like Elliott's 2nd song.
Katharine's actually doing great with Somewhere Over the Rainbow!

[Krisalicious]

Alright, Katharine's getting into the finals. After Simon's comment.. yeah. Definitely

[EmoJoe]

i dont think katharine gave the best performance of the season. but it was one of them.

BUT...i think she's a lock for the finale :woohoo:

[David]

Elliott's first one was pretty good. It's a bit of a safe song to be singing for the Final 3 round, but it was still good.

Katharine's first song wasn't great, but I do have to blame it on the song. It was a horrible horrible horrible song choice. Really. That was probably the LAST song I would have given to her. It's almost as if he meant that for Elliott but somehow it was given to Katharine.

Taylor's first one was probably the best in the first round.

---

Elliott's second song, was a good vocal, but it was just too generic and safe lyrically and vocally. Considering that nobody expected him to be in the top 3 in the beginning, I expected him to really take advantage of this round and do what he did last week.

Katharine's second song was beautiful, exquisite, amazing. FINALLY. :lol: I'm so glad she got the praise she deserved.

Taylor's second song was another good one. Probably my favorite performance from him.

[80sTrivia]

Katharine's performance of "Over the Rainbow" was simply amazing, as was Taylor's performance of "You Are So Beautiful"... :)

[Cactus Jack]

Elliott's second was ok

Katahrine=AWESOME AWESOME AWESOME

Taylor- Awesome

Elliott's thrid- Prettu good
Kat-AWESOME

[Cactus Jack]

Now THAT's what I call Taylor that was AWESOME

[G-Force Glockstar]

First Round:

Elliott: 9/10
Katharine: 10/10
Taylor: 9/10

Second Round:

Elliott: 9/10
Katharine: 8.5/10
Taylor: 9/10

Third Round:

Elliott: 9.5/10
Katharine: 8.5/10
Taylor: 9.5/10



EVERYONE, VOTE FOR KATHARINE!!!! SHE NEEDS TO WIN THIS--IF NOT WIN, THE RUNNER UP!!!!!

[EmoJoe]

First Round:

Elliott: 9/10
Katharine: 10/10
Taylor: 9/10

Second Round:

Elliott: 9/10
Katharine: 8.5/10
Taylor: 9/10

Third Round:

Elliott: 9.5/10
Katharine: 8.5/10
Taylor: 9.5/10



EVERYONE, VOTE FOR KATHARINE!!!! SHE NEEDS TO WIN THIS--IF NOT WIN, THE RUNNER UP!!!!!
:eek: whoa, you thought katharine's first was better then her second?

anyway...tonight sucked for me, but i enjoyed katharine and, admittetly, taylor. i hope kat makes final 2. i just couldn't help thinking "what if chris was there?" and ugh it's just so different when you don't have a favorite. it was the worst night of the season for me. for obvious reasons. i thought it was over chris being out but tonight made me sad again :(

[Cactus Jack]

:eek: whoa, you thought katharine's first was better then her second?

anyway...tonight sucked for me, but i enjoyed katharine and, admittetly, taylor. i hope kat makes final 2. i just couldn't help thinking "what if chris was there?" and ugh it's just so different when you don't have a favorite. it was the worst night of the season for me. for obvious reasons. i thought it was over chris being out but tonight made me sad again :(
Ditto :(

[G-Force Glockstar]

Geez, I only got in once for Katharine so far....

[G-Force Glockstar]

WTF!! What does it mean when you call in but you hear nothing, no busy signal OR a voice?? :confused:

[Cactus Jack]

Busy Signal

[David]

I haven't gotten in once for Katharine or Elliott yet.

I think it's goodbye to Elliott tonight. :( I would love at Kat-Elliott finale, but obviously Taylor's gonna land in there.

[Cactus Jack]

I haven't gotten in once for Katharine or Elliott yet.

I think it's goodbye to Elliott tonight. :( I would love at Kat-Elliott finale, but obviously Taylor's gonna land in there.
I got in 3 times for Kat

[EmoJoe]

WTF!! What does it mean when you call in but you hear nothing, no busy signal OR a voice?? :confused:
i don't know, that happened to me a lot this season with chris. sometimes i got "please enter the area code" too. just vote again :lol:

[Karen*]

I haven't gotten in once for Katharine or Elliott yet.

I think it's goodbye to Elliott tonight. :( I would love at Kat-Elliott finale, but obviously Taylor's gonna land in there.

Noooooo. Elliott NEEDS to be in the finale. If Chris can't be in it, then he should be in it. :crying:

[Zebra 3]

As for Jasmine, she had the whole friggan state of Hawaii for her, but a lot of people were pissed at her for lasting longer than La Toya.LaToya London was robbed!

[missjohnR]

I think Taylor did great! Katherine Nailed the second song. I only got in 31 votes for TWO hours for Taylor.

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

Im pretty sure Elliott is going home tomorrow night, so next week Ill be voting for Taylor all the way! If Katharine won itd be a joke to all the other past winners. She has been so inconsistent in the past, where as Kelly, Carrie, etc. always did well with maybe one or 2 off nights. I think Elliott had crappy song choices, though Open Arms was awesome. I think Kat needs to keep her mouth shut when the judges critique her, because she just sounds like a whiner. The judges are hard on everyone. Rainbow I actually enjoyed from her, which is a first.

[Karen*]

It was a rather lackluster night without Chris, that's all I can say. ohno:

[80sTrivia]

I really believe Elliot might be the one going home tonight, but I'm almost afraid to take a guess...

[missjohnR]

me too. I think it will come down to Katherine and Elliott on who will go home. They are so close on dialidol site. I can't believe that site was right last week.

BUT I did however watched my local news last night here in Virginia. Randy was on there saying that Elliott will be leaving tonight. But we shall see tonight if he's right.

[G-Force Glockstar]

omg I'm sooooooo happy!!! Well, if Dial Idol is right, I am!! :D


I only got in 3 times though for Katharine last night......

[EmoJoe]

just to let everyone know- tonight's results are one hour.

and also, there's no bottom 2 tonight. they just pull down the person eliminated. it was REALLY nerve-racking for me last year.

[G-Force Glockstar]

just to let everyone know- tonight's results are one hour.

and also, there's no bottom 2 tonight. they just pull down the person eliminated. it was REALLY nerve-racking for me last year.

Thanks for the info! :D

Didn't they have a bottom 2 for the top 3 last year? :confused:

[EmoJoe]

^no...they've never had a bottom 2 for the top 3.

[G-Force Glockstar]

^no...they've never had a bottom 2 for the top 3.

Oh....nvm, my bad