AI5 Results: 4 turns into 3!!

[David]

Dun dun dun.

[EmoJoe]

*dies*

[EmoJoe]

Ryan: Someone will be leaving us tonight!

*shows katharine and eliott*

[Karen*]

I'm hella nervous. :(

[David]

I am extremely nervous -- just as nervous as I was for Carrie when everyone said she was leaving on final 4 night.

[James"Thunder"Early]

I'm expecting a shock

[Karen*]

I'm expecting a shock

I REALLY hope it's not Chris.

I've had a crappy day. :o If Chris gets voted off tonight, it'll be the worst thing that will happen to me. :crying:

[EmoJoe]

I am extremely nervous -- just as nervous as I was for Carrie when everyone said she was leaving on final 4 night.
me too :( and i had kinda a crappy day too :-/

[EmoJoe]

I REALLY hope it's not Chris.

I've had a crappy day. :o If Chris gets voted off tonight, it'll be the worst thing that will happen to me. :crying:
:nod: :(

:rotflmao: WTF the ford commercial with KERMIT THE FROG

[EmoJoe]

good group song so far!

[EmoJoe]

I am extremely nervous -- just as nervous as I was for Carrie when everyone said she was leaving on final 4 night.
ugh, me too :crying:

[James"Thunder"Early]

I REALLY hope it's not Chris.

I've had a crappy day. :o If Chris gets voted off tonight, it'll be the worst thing that will happen to me. :crying:When it gets down this low, not even the fan favorites are safe. He'll probably stay, though.

[EmoJoe]

*throws up*

[EmoJoe]

LOVED the group song!

[David]

Excellent group song :D :D LOVEDDDD IT!

But aaaaaah. 10 minutes until we find out who's out :(

[David]

This just proves how fantastic the final four this year is. There has been no year where every contestant in the top 4 actually had a shot at wining.

[EmoJoe]

AGHHH *sick to my stomach*

[EmoJoe]

ugh WTF it's obvious taylor isn't out now -_-

i'm SOOOOOO nervous.

[David]

WHAT?!?!

THAT IS NOT FAIR!

Taylor gets to sing again? On a RESULTS SHOW?

The person eliminated better get a goodbye song.

[EmoJoe]

POOOOOOP -_-

AFTER THE BREAK? *insert curses here*

[David]

Chris and Katharine are the bottom 2. I can tell.

[EmoJoe]

WHAT?!?!

THAT IS NOT FAIR!

Taylor gets to sing again? On a RESULTS SHOW?

The person eliminated better get a goodbye song.
I KNOW! WTF?!?

i'm too nervous for words :( ugh i just KNOW chris is out

[EmoJoe]

Chris and Katharine are the bottom 2. I can tell.
I KNOW! ugh my top 2 :(

[James"Thunder"Early]

I'm so anxious to hear the result, I'm on the west coast and I always like to find out before it comes on here.

[EmoJoe]

ACK :(

taylor and eliott are safe :(

CHRIS is out :crying:

[EmoJoe]

i hate this friggen show :cuss:

[James"Thunder"Early]

ACK :(

taylor and eliott are safe :(

CHRIS is out :crying:That is just not right

[theshark8777]

Soul Patrol!

[vienna waits]

omg... chris is out? that's nuts

[Krisalicious]

WHAT?!?!?!?!?

No, really.


WHAT?!?!?!?!?!?!??!!?!?

This is unreal.

[80sTrivia]

I can't believe Chris is gone!!! :( But, I know he'll have a major label record contract by tomorrow morning!!! Go, Chris!!! :clap

[EmoJoe]

i'm seriously done watching this show. it's obvious not about talent anymore.

[Brent88]

I am done with this show.

[KissMyGrits]

Me too!! I will never watch this show again!!!

[James"Thunder"Early]

Chris doesn't need Idol, he can sing and he'll get a contract in no time

[Krisalicious]

No offense, but I don't really think any of the others are deserving of the title of being the next AMERICAN IDOL. Each of them have had at least 3 bad performances throughout their run on the show. With Chris, I can only think of 1 or maybe 2 that were not up to his level.

[Cactus Jack]

:crying:NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO this cnat be!!!


Noooo, Ill watch the next twow eeks though, but still :( oh crap

COME OIN TELL ME THOSE WERE THE WRONG VOTES!!!!!!!!


Still he has a chance . :( Ill miss him though gahhhh NOOOO

[EmoJoe]

No offense, but I don't really think any of the others are deserving of the title of being the next AMERICAN IDOL. Each of them have had at least 3 bad performances throughout their run on the show. With Chris, I can only think of 1 or maybe 2 that were not up to his level.
honestly, whoever wins will be the worst selling idol. this is the worst top 3 ever

[Melonhead00]

I am done with this show.
Good!
I hope you join the Anti-American Idol Party

[Cactus Jack]

honestly, whoever wins will be the worst selling idol. this is the worst top 3 ever
With the exceptino of Katahrien ditto

[missjohnR]

:eek2: OMG, OMG! I CAN'T BELIEVE IT. I THOUGH KATHERINE WOULD LEAVE. SHE EVEN KNEW THAT SHE WOULD BEEN THE ONE GOING.

[James"Thunder"Early]

honestly, whoever wins will be the worst selling idol. this is the worst top 3 everI agree

[Brent88]

Good!
I hope you join the Anti-American Idol Party

:lol:

God my splitting headache I've had all day got worse.

Now I'm going to see which idiot wins the stupid money on Unan1mous. I hope it runs out. :p :rolleyes:

[EmoJoe]

With the exceptino of Katahrien ditto
yeah but i'm sure she'll be out next.

[Heart Shaped Box]

I cannot fricken believe this. I NEVER thought Chris would go home. He doesn't deserve to go home, he deserves to stay on the show and win it. He had the best performences last night, and I will never watch this show again. Obviously people are too stupid enough to know who has real talent.

[EmoJoe]

I cannot fricken believe this. I NEVER thought Chris would go home. He doesn't deserve to go home, he deserves to stay on the show and win it. He had the best performences last night, and I will never watch this show again. Obviously people are too stupid enough to know who has real talent.
:nod: you said it! this show has really gone to crap.

[Cactus Jack]

:nod: you said it! this show has really gone to crap.
Ditto!:D

Ill still watch though

[EmoJoe]

Ditto!:D

Ill still watch though
i don't know if i will. i might watch next year, but i won't watch the remaining weeks.

[Cactus Jack]

i don't know if i will. i might watch next year, but i won't watch the remaining weeks.
Youre right

Nwow Chris wont be on nay result shows next year UUUGGGGHHHH gosh :(:( PLEEEASEEE Ryan, did yoyu actually read it correctly?

[Cactus Jack]

Please Chris :( just.... come back next week anyways

[Krisalicious]

This season has had its sucky moments, but this was the worst. I mean I could tell this would be a horrible season after Bucky magically made top 12 while good talent like Ayla and Will was just wasted away.

[EmoJoe]

he BETTER get a record deal.

[EmoJoe]

This season has had its sucky moments, but this was the worst. I mean I could tell this would be a horrible season after Bucky magically made top 12 while good talent like Ayla and Will was just wasted away.
:nod:

[PrettyinPink55]

I am just BEYOND SHOCKED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

CHRIS!!!!!!!!!

I would've NEVER EVER EVER guessed he would go tonight!!!!!

He was supposed to be the next American Idol! :( :(

NOOOOO!!!!!

[EmoJoe]

he IS the winner in my eyes. :king:

seriously...i just don't see the remaining people as american idol worthy. they don't live up to the talent of past winners

[Cactus Jack]

he BETTER get a record deal.
Oh he will, trust me.

AI is the best that happened to him, now he'll be a winner in some sors

You know what? Just cancel it next week, Nigel

[Cactus Jack]

he IS the winner in my eyes. :king:

seriously...i just don't see the remaining people as american idol worthy. they don't live up to the talent of past winners
:nod: This is like when LaToya was voted off, but worse

[G-Force Glockstar]

WTF!!!!! Elliott should've gone before Kellie left.....and now he's still safe and THE BEST SINGER ON THE SHOW LEFT??!!!!

I'm BEYOND shocked!!!!



Chris was too good for AI anyway! He'll make a record deal, I PROMISE!

[Cactus Jack]

I am just BEYOND SHOCKED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

CHRIS!!!!!!!!!

I would've NEVER EVER EVER guessed he would go tonight!!!!!

He was supposed to be the next American Idol! :( :(

NOOOOO!!!!!
Ditto :(

I hope those results were misread , RYAN NEEDS GLASSES AND AMERICA NEEDS EARS AND FINGERS

[PrettyinPink55]

No, but the way he said it! "Chris Alot of ppl thought you could be our next American Idol, and then BAM You're going home tonight??" JUST NOT RIGHT!!!

[Cactus Jack]

No, but the way he said it! "Chris Alot of ppl thought you could be our next American Idol, and then BAM You're going home tonight??" JUST NOT RIGHT!!!
I know :(


But yeah he was too good for AI just watch this summer, a an album from him

[EmoJoe]

I know :(


But yeah he was too good for AI just watch this summer, a an album from him
he's under stupid AI's contract for a few months, sadly.

[Cactus Jack]

he's under stupid AI's contract for a few months, sadly.
Oh :( how many?

[PrettyinPink55]

I STILL can't believe it!!!
I think this has got to be one of the show's most shocking moments, right up there with Jennifer Hudson of season 3!!!!!!!!!!

[PrettyinPink55]

he's under stupid AI's contract for a few months, sadly.

:cuss: :cuss:

[EmoJoe]

Oh :( how many?
who knows? i think like 3 or something. they should show him some respect after throwing him off the show.

[eltonfan80]

who knows? i think like 3 or something. they should show him some respect after throwing him off the show.
I AGREE

[EmoJoe]

I STILL can't believe it!!!
I think this has got to be one of the show's most shocking moments, right up there with Jennifer Hudson of season 3!!!!!!!!!!
chris is by far the most robbed contestant ever on this show.

[Cactus Jack]

chris is by far the most robbed contestant ever on this show.
Yup

[David]

In a board full of Chris fans, it's pointless of me to even say how I feel about Katharine being safe, because looking at my avatar, it's obvious.

But I do admit that Katharine did deserve to go home, and that Chris deserved to make it farther than Taylor. On the night, the only one who did excellent on both songs was Elliott, and when the underdog does the strongest, it really can mess up everyone's predictions. But, Chris fans, this isn't the end of Chris. Think positively. Yes he didn't win, but that can be a good thing. Bo's album didn't work as well because of how the producers wanted to do it, so if Chris is able to do his own thing, it'll be better for his fans. It's better to have a real, authentic album versus a manufactured, cookie-cutter album, right? Sorry if this didn't help, but I know how you guys feel, and yes, a lot of times I knew inside that "my eliminated favorites" would have a hard time making it in the real world, but something inside is telling me that Chris will succeed.

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

WOW. Honestly, as much as I couldnt stand Chris, I reaaaaaaallly couldnt stand Katharine. I would choose Chris over Kat any day. With that said... YES YES YES YES YES!!!!!!!!!!!! If Katharine goes next week [pleasepleaseplease], then that means Taylor and Elliott will be in the finale. They are my two favorites and have been since the beginning, well, aside from Kevin :( lol. I have never had someone I love win [Kelly doesnt count], so to have both my favs. in the finals.. I would be ecstatic!

With that said, Kat needs to wipe that smug look off her face. She looked depressed the whole time. Given, she probably thought she was going home, but she couldve atleast faked it. Everyone else puts on a happy face.

[EmoJoe]

In a board full of Chris fans, it's pointless of me to even say how I feel about Katharine being safe, because looking at my avatar, it's obvious.

But I do admit that Katharine did deserve to go home, and that Chris deserved to make it farther than Taylor. On the night, the only one who did excellent on both songs was Elliott, and when the underdog does the strongest, it really can mess up everyone's predictions. But, Chris fans, this isn't the end of Chris. Think positively. Yes he didn't win, but that can be a good thing. Bo's album didn't work as well because of how the producers wanted to do it, so if Chris is able to do his own thing, it'll be better for his fans. It's better to have a real, authentic album versus a manufactured, cookie-cutter album, right? Sorry if this didn't help, but I know how you guys feel, and yes, a lot of times I knew inside that "my eliminated favorites" would have a hard time making it in the real world, but something inside is telling me that Chris will succeed.
:nod: :( i agree david. i hope katharine wins, she's my favorite now that chris is gone :)

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

LOL at people who are all 'worst top 3 ever', 'Im never watching this show again'. Honestly, if I said that everytime my favorites got kicked off, I wouldnt have made it through season 2. But, I keep coming back. And whos to say its the worst top 3 ever.. does Jasmine ring a bell? Nikki?! Diff'rent strokes for diff'rent folks. I havent been pleased with an Idol outcome since Kelly won and that was friggan 4 years ago! Last year was just a mess for me. Theres always next season...

Besides, IMO Chris would be better off with a band. Out of the top 3, I think Elliott and Katharine are the most marketable. I loves Taylor, but I have no idea wtf theyre going to do with him. But his fans are rabid and if they are anything like Claymates, he'll wind up being one of the most successful.

[eltonfan80]

i hope elliott wins

[eltonfan80]

i hope elliott wins i am so unhappy

[EmoJoe]

LOL at people who are all 'worst top 3 ever', 'Im never watching this show again'. Honestly, if I said that everytime my favorites got kicked off, I wouldnt have made it through season 2. But, I keep coming back. And whos to say its the worst top 3 ever.. does Jasmine ring a bell? Nikki?! Diff'rent strokes for diff'rent folks. I havent been pleased with an Idol outcome since Kelly won and that was friggan 4 years ago! Last year was just a mess for me. Theres always next season...

Besides, IMO Chris would be better off with a band. Out of the top 3, I think Elliott and Katharine are the most marketable. I loves Taylor, but I have no idea wtf theyre going to do with him. But his fans are rabid and if they are anything like Claymates, he'll wind up being one of the most successful.i liked jasmine :p

but anyway, i'll probably watch next season and i probably will watch the finale but ehh. i won't vote or anything.

[PrettyinPink55]

I think it's going to be Taylor :(

My choice for top two was Chris and Kat-- Chris being the winner.

If it can't be Chris, I choose Kat! :(

[EmoJoe]

my full support goes to katharine now.

[Brian Damage]

C'mon guys, you gots to get down with the Soul Patrol!!!

[Czas na Zywiec]

Damn, easily a shock. I'm rooting for Elliot (I usually always go for the underdog), but damn, I never expected this. It just goes to show you that no one is ever safe.

This show was really never about talent if you really think about it. I mean it is, but if you don't get enough votes, it doesn't matter how good you are. Look at Scott, can you honestly say he was better then all but 4 people last year? Or that Rueben is better than Clay. I'm not really a fan of either, but look where these two are today. On waaaay different paths and if someone tells you Clay lost to Rueben and you never saw the show, you probably wouldn't believe it.

The aftermath will realy show who is successful/marketable and who isn't. It'll probably take a while, but if someone is really talented, they'll make their way back up to the spotlight like Kelly/Clay.

[LuLu Rogers]

C'mon guys, you gots to get down with the Soul Patrol!!!

You got it baby! Taylor is the man!!:D I wanted Chris to win though, and Taylor to be 1st runner up. :( Chris was robbed! :mad:

I hope Taylor wins now!!

[Czas na Zywiec]

Oh, and Constantine anyone?

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

Damn, easily a shock. I'm rooting for Elliot (I usually always go for the underdog), but damn, I never expected this. It just goes to show you that no one is ever safe.

This show was really never about talent if you really think about it. I mean it is, but if you don't get enough votes, it doesn't matter how good you are. Look at Scott, can you honestly say he was better then all but 4 people last year? Or that Rueben is better than Clay. I'm not really a fan of either, but look where these two are today. On waaaay different paths and if someone tells you Clay lost to Rueben and you never saw the show, you probably wouldn't believe it.

The aftermath will realy show who is successful/marketable and who isn't. It'll probably take a while, but if someone is really talented, they'll make their way back up to the spotlight like Kelly/Clay.
:nod: When Clay lost I was devastated. I swore I would never vote anymore than 27 times for anyone else, since 27 was the amount of times I actually got through for Clay -.- lol. Of course I since gave that up, but when he lost I thought it was the end. Then a few days later I realized how popular he was. Look up any of my posts from AI2 - or Jeffs. Now that is some serious Idol bitching.

[Krisalicious]

Oh, and Constantine anyone?

Oh god, I don't know which was more depressing...Chris getting voted off tonight or last year when Scott was safe and Constantine was voted off :eek:

[Czas na Zywiec]

:nod: When Clay lost I was devastated. I swore I would never vote anymore than 27 times for anyone else, since 27 was the amount of times I actually got through for Clay -.- lol. Of course I since gave that up, but when he lost I thought it was the end. Then a few days later I realized how popular he was. Look up any of my posts from AI2 - or Jeffs. Now that is some serious Idol bitching.

I couldn't even talk to you for a couple days after the finale lol. You were an emotional trainwreck, holy ****.

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

I couldn't even talk to you for a couple days after the finale lol. You were an emotional trainwreck, holy ****.
LOlll yes, those were some pretty dark days! I remember goiing into work the next day feeling sick and I barely spoke to anyone.

[Karen*]

I can't believe this. I just can't ****ing believe this.

[Karen*]

Elliott is the only one who will get my votes now. I couldn't give two craps about Taylor or Kat. Sorry to offend fans of those two, but it's my honest opinion. Elliott or bust is my motto now.

[I Love John Ritter]

I'm sorry Chris fans :(

Aw, I didn't want him to leave tonight. He did so well last night, that wasn't fair. And the way that Ryan said he was out was really mean. He starts by saying a lot of people predicted him to win, and then all of a sudden says he's out. I know I predicted him to win ever since the top 24.

I am however, very happy that Elliott was safe!! I Love Clay Aiken, I love your avatar!!! Elliott and Taylor are who I've wanted for the final two ever since Mandisa left.

[PrettyinPink55]

I still can't believe it either, and it's been how long??

You can tell Chris was shocked himself! Even Katherine, Elliot, and Taylor! And the judges too! Did you see Paula crying???

And I agree, the way Ryan said he was elminated just wasn't right, and came as a total suprise!

Oh well, Chris is still my American Idol!

[EmoJoe]

C'mon guys, you gots to get down with the Soul Patrol!!!
taylor is my least favorite left :p

[Cactus Jack]

In a board full of Chris fans, it's pointless of me to even say how I feel about Katharine being safe, because looking at my avatar, it's obvious.

But I do admit that Katharine did deserve to go home, and that Chris deserved to make it farther than Taylor. On the night, the only one who did excellent on both songs was Elliott, and when the underdog does the strongest, it really can mess up everyone's predictions. But, Chris fans, this isn't the end of Chris. Think positively. Yes he didn't win, but that can be a good thing. Bo's album didn't work as well because of how the producers wanted to do it, so if Chris is able to do his own thing, it'll be better for his fans. It's better to have a real, authentic album versus a manufactured, cookie-cutter album, right? Sorry if this didn't help, but I know how you guys feel, and yes, a lot of times I knew inside that "my eliminated favorites" would have a hard time making it in the real world, but something inside is telling me that Chris will succeed. Yea!:D

I know, if Chris won, his ablum ould be probably produced by Clive Davis and we'd see pop songs where the ttile dont make sense


So, would rather here Chris sng songs where the title doesnt make sense? or an albu, with a band?


I say , album with a band :D

[Cactus Jack]

LOL at people who are all 'worst top 3 ever', 'Im never watching this show again'. Honestly, if I said that everytime my favorites got kicked off, I wouldnt have made it through season 2. But, I keep coming back. And whos to say its the worst top 3 ever.. does Jasmine ring a bell? Nikki?! Diff'rent strokes for diff'rent folks. I havent been pleased with an Idol outcome since Kelly won and that was friggan 4 years ago! Last year was just a mess for me. Theres always next season...

Besides, IMO Chris would be better off with a band. Out of the top 3, I think Elliott and Katharine are the most marketable. I loves Taylor, but I have no idea wtf theyre going to do with him. But his fans are rabid and if they are anything like Claymates, he'll wind up being one of the most successful.
I liked Jasmine too


But I disagree , I still think he coulda made oen more week, Chris of course.


He qwould be better off with a band though

[AllIWantIsYourClutch]

soul patrooooool.

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

I'm sorry Chris fans :(

Aw, I didn't want him to leave tonight. He did so well last night, that wasn't fair. And the way that Ryan said he was out was really mean. He starts by saying a lot of people predicted him to win, and then all of a sudden says he's out. I know I predicted him to win ever since the top 24.

I am however, very happy that Elliott was safe!! I Love Clay Aiken, I love your avatar!!! Elliott and Taylor are who I've wanted for the final two ever since Mandisa left.
Thanks! Well if things keep going as they appear, we will be happy happy in a couple weeks! :elvis: :dance:

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

I liked Jasmine too


But I disagree , I still think he coulda made oen more week, Chris of course.


He qwould be better off with a band though
I didnt mind Jasmine either, but she was one of the ones that started off really strong, then slowly dwindled down to the point of her being a joke.

[80sTrivia]

I'm actually afraid to root for any of the remaining contestants, as I feel they will be voted off the show... :(

[missjohnR]

Remember Chris doesn't need Idol because he will sell alot of Records. Even if he put one out tomorrow. But going back to the result show, I thought Ryan should of put it more gentle when he said Chris name. I didn't like the way he said it. "Chris is kick off the show America." I didn't like how he said that. He should said it like when Kellie lefted. "I'm sorry Chris, tonight's the end for you." Do you agree? I thought Ryan took his heart out and stump on it. It wasn't right.

[EmoJoe]

good news for chris fans...supposedly he's been asked to be the lead singer of a band!

[Cactus Jack]

good news for chris fans...supposedly he's been asked to be the lead singer of a band!
Fuel?

I knew hed be successful! He was to good for AI anyways

[EmoJoe]

Fuel?

I knew hed be successful! He was to good for AI anyways
yeah it's fuel! and his band was also offererd a deal. i hope he takes one of those two offers.

[Cactus Jack]

yeah it's fuel! and his band was also offererd a deal. i hope he takes one of those two offers.
Awesome, I hoe he takes one of them, which ever will be awesome

[G-Force Glockstar]

Remember Chris doesn't need Idol because he will sell alot of Records. Even if he put one out tomorrow. But going back to the result show, I thought Ryan should of put it more gentle when he said Chris name. I didn't like the way he said it. "Chris is kick off the show America." I didn't like how he said that. He should said it like when Kellie lefted. "I'm sorry Chris, tonight's the end for you." Do you agree? I thought Ryan took his heart out and stump on it. It wasn't right.

Yes, Ryan was rude to Chris :(

My mom was saying today how she thought Ryan did a bad job yesterday.....I mean, not only how he treated Chris, but he also let Taylor sing again ON A RESULTS SHOW! idk what was up with Ryan......

[G-Force Glockstar]

If Katharine goes, AI will be as boring as h***......I'm sorry, but that's just the plain truth.

First, Kellie leaves, then Chris........gosh, Elliott should've gone the week right after Bucky!!! :(

[G-Force Glockstar]

good news for chris fans...supposedly he's been asked to be the lead singer of a band!

party: YESSSSSSSSSS!!!!!

Ok, I have a stupid question.....where do I listen to the band?

[KissMyGrits]

The name of his band is Absent Element. They are awesome. You can go onto their web site and click on media and they have some songs you can listen to.

www.absentelement.com

[KissMyGrits]

I listened to an interview they did with Chris and he said that he thinks his fans forgot to vote for him!! I wish I could tell him is wasn't true!! We tried our hardest!! I nearly cried when I heard him say that!!

[G-Force Glockstar]

I listened to an interview they did with Chris and he said that he thinks his fans forgot to vote for him!! I wish I could tell him is wasn't true!! We tried our hardest!! I nearly cried when I heard him say that!!

Aww! :(

[EmoJoe]

I listened to an interview they did with Chris and he said that he thinks his fans forgot to vote for him!! I wish I could tell him is wasn't true!! We tried our hardest!! I nearly cried when I heard him say that!!
i voted a whole two hours for him :(

[EmoJoe]

The name of his band is Absent Element. They are awesome. You can go onto their web site and click on media and they have some songs you can listen to.

www.absentelement.com
:woohoo: it's awesome that they might get signed! chris is proving you don't need to win AI to have sucsess.

[EmoJoe]

If Katharine goes, AI will be as boring as h***......I'm sorry, but that's just the plain truth.

First, Kellie leaves, then Chris........gosh, Elliott should've gone the week right after Bucky!!! :(
i like eliott a lot, but he's overstayed his welcome. an eliott/taylor finale would be the absolute worst top 2 ever. it would be SO boring.

[LuLu Rogers]

I really think everyone is giving Taylor a bad rap here. Sorry, but I gotta support my boy. He's representin me and the rest of us here in Sweet Home Alabama! Go T! :woohoo: :cheer:

[KissMyGrits]

The only thing Taylor has going for him is that he dances goofy!! Once he comes out with a CD who is going to buy it? His major audience is in their 50's and 60's! He belongs in Vegas!! If I was to vote for anyone it would be Katharine!! But I am not voting and not watching anymore!! The whole system is a farce when I call to vote for Chris and get a recording of Kat's voice thanking me for voting for her!!

I truly believe that Taylor will be gone and so will Elliott!! Leaving Katharine standing alone. Sorry, she is just so much more marketable than either of the men this year. Not that I don't like Elliott, just from a business stand point there is probably no way he will be the next AI! The whole show is a farce and as far as I am concerned they can take it and shove it up their assets!!

[LuLu Rogers]

The only thing Taylor has going for him is that he dances goofy!! Once he comes out with a CD who is going to buy it? His major audience is in their 50's and 60's! He belongs in Vegas!! If I was to vote for anyone it would be Katharine!! But I am not voting and not watching anymore!! The whole system is a farce when I call to vote for Chris and get a recording of Kat's voice thanking me for voting for her!!

I truly believe that Taylor will be gone and so will Elliott!! Leaving Katharine standing alone. Sorry, she is just so much more marketable than either of the men this year. Not that I don't like Elliott, just from a business stand point there is probably no way he will be the next AI! The whole show is a farce and as far as I am concerned they can take it and shove it up their assets!!

Relax coach, after all, it is just a TV show. And I would be one of those people who would buy Taylor's CD. Just because Chris got voted off is no reason to hate the show, that's just acting like a spoiled little kid because your favorite didn't win. I wanted Chris to win, but I'm not torn up about it. It won't affect my life. :rolleyes:

[KissMyGrits]

Relax coach, after all, it is just a TV show. And I would be one of those people who would buy Taylor's CD. Just because Chris got voted off is no reason to hate the show, that's just acting like a spoiled little kid because your favorite didn't win. I wanted Chris to win, but I'm not torn up about it. It won't affect my life. :rolleyes:

First of all don't you DARE call me coach!! Second of all I am not letting it effect my life!!! Thirdly, don't accuse me of acting like a spoiled child!! It isn't effecting my life at all!! I am just stating that the best person they had on there lost and since he is gone I have no desire to watch the show anymore. Plain and simple. I was also stating an obvious fact that when I called Chris's # I got Kat's voice!! You know!! I think I will vote again!! This time for Kat to knock your precious Taylor off!! Get a life!!

Chris will be more popular than any of the other three remaining idols. He has already been offered a lead singing position with the group Fuel. He doesn't need to win this glorified popularity contest.

[EmoJoe]

The only thing Taylor has going for him is that he dances goofy!! Once he comes out with a CD who is going to buy it? His major audience is in their 50's and 60's! He belongs in Vegas!! If I was to vote for anyone it would be Katharine!! But I am not voting and not watching anymore!! The whole system is a farce when I call to vote for Chris and get a recording of Kat's voice thanking me for voting for her!!

I truly believe that Taylor will be gone and so will Elliott!! Leaving Katharine standing alone. Sorry, she is just so much more marketable than either of the men this year. Not that I don't like Elliott, just from a business stand point there is probably no way he will be the next AI! The whole show is a farce and as far as I am concerned they can take it and shove it up their assets!!
i dont like taylor, but i seriously can't see anyone but him winning this now that chris is gone. eliott just doesn't have what it takes and AI won't allow kat to win because they're pulling for a guy this year. i don't think he'll do well though.

i may throw in a vote or two for katharine next week but i wont be voting crazy like i did for chris. if katharine isn't in the finale, then i'll only watch the finale results to see the top 12 re-united again and to see past idols perform, because a taylor/eliott finale would be a snooze-fest.

[EmoJoe]

Chris will be more popular than any of the other three remaining idols. He has already been offered a lead singing position with the group Fuel. He doesn't need to win this glorified popularity contest.
i agree :nod:

[LuLu Rogers]

First of all don't you DARE call me coach!! Second of all I am not letting it effect my life!!! Thirdly, don't accuse me of acting like a spoiled child!! It isn't effecting my life at all!! I am just stating that the best person they had on there lost and since he is gone I have no desire to watch the show anymore. Plain and simple. I was also stating an obvious fact that when I called Chris's # I got Kat's voice!! You know!! I think I will vote again!! This time for Kat to knock your precious Taylor off!! Get a life!!

Chris will be more popular than any of the other three remaining idols. He has already been offered a lead singing position with the group Fuel. He doesn't need to win this glorified popularity contest.

I really don't care if Taylor wins or loses. And saying that Chris was the best is again, YOUR opinion. I really think that this years American Idol as a whole sucks, so I really don't care who wins. I haven't even watched the show in over 3 weeks. My mom has been watching and filling me in. And don't you DARE tell me to get a life! I am not the one who's upset over some random guy getting voted off a reality TV show, geez! Grow Up!

[KissMyGrits]

I really don't care if Taylor wins or loses. And saying that Chris was the best is again, YOUR opinion. I really think that this years American Idol as a whole sucks, so I really don't care who wins. I haven't even watched the show in over 3 weeks. My mom has been watching and filling me in. And don't you DARE tell me to get a life! I am not the one who's upset over some random guy getting voted off a reality TV show, geez! Grow Up!

Again, I am upset and have every right to be, but I don't let it control my life. I went to work as usual and I had lunch with my friends like usual. I am just saying that I will never watch it again and that is my right.

BTW, alot of people here also thought Chris was the best too!! Or didn't you bother to read the other posts before you added your two cents?

No one or nothing will control my life and I am proud to say that Chris is my American Idol. Don't like my posts then don't read them. I am entitled to my opinion just like you are. I guess we will have to agree to disagree on this one, but please don't down Chris and then I won't have to get down on Taylor. Cause really my husband happens to like Taylor, I personally don't like him and wouldn't vote for him. It is after all a tv show and life will go on like always. I can just wait for Chris's CD to come out and go double platinum in no time. Leaving the others in the dust!! That will be the sweetest victory of all for him!!!:dance: :dance:

[LuLu Rogers]

I agree, You're entitled to your opinion as I am entitled to mine. Therefore, I am going to be adult about this and discuss it no further. I'm walking away from this one, so have at it. :bye: peace:

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

The only thing Taylor has going for him is that he dances goofy!! Once he comes out with a CD who is going to buy it? His major audience is in their 50's and 60's! He belongs in Vegas!! If I was to vote for anyone it would be Katharine!! But I am not voting and not watching anymore!! The whole system is a farce when I call to vote for Chris and get a recording of Kat's voice thanking me for voting for her!!

I truly believe that Taylor will be gone and so will Elliott!! Leaving Katharine standing alone. Sorry, she is just so much more marketable than either of the men this year. Not that I don't like Elliott, just from a business stand point there is probably no way he will be the next AI! The whole show is a farce and as far as I am concerned they can take it and shove it up their assets!!
Im 22 years old and have been a fan of Taylor since day one. Honestly, you cant say he wont make it, because with Idol you can never predict these things. Look at Ruben, oh wait nevermind. Or Fantasia, Diana, etc. Yeah sure theyre doing pretty good right now, but they are not at the status Im sure AI wanted them to be at. Then you have Clay who may not be the most marketable, but his fanbase is ridiculous and I have never seen more supportive group for a singer, its like a freaking epidemic.

IMO Katharine is the most marketable but if we get another female Idol Ill seriously chew someones arm off. Taylor may not be the most marketable, but Clay proved you dont have to have that edge to sell records and make a name for yourself. I think Elliott is quite marketable if they know what kind of music he should stick to. In all honesty, Ace would be the most marketable of them all- hes got the looks, voice [sometimes], and that appeal to young girls- who will be the ones to buy every CD like a manic.

LOlz @ 'coach'

And if my dreams were to come true for the finale Id seriously CMP or something.

[KissMyGrits]

I do admit that Taylor has had his moments. I liked his second song on Tuesday cause he wasn't his usual manic self. I just find it hard to watch him perform. My husband loves him. It is a matter of personal choice. No one is ever going to agree on this issue.

Coming in fourth isn't a death knell and Chris will have a wonderful career in front of him. I wish the other idols luck in their career. I just cab't watch any longer, it isn't about the best singer, it's a popularity contest.

Not everyone in Alabama supports Taylor though. I have a friend that lives in Helena. She was rooting for Chris. Yes she is my age and liked Chris. Shocking huh? BTW-I am 34 and proud of it. I loved Carrie and Bo last year and have both of their CD's!! My favorites were voted off early last year, but at least they still had people that I cared about watching.

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

I do admit that Taylor has had his moments. I liked his second song on Tuesday cause he wasn't his usual manic self. I just find it hard to watch him perform. My husband loves him. It is a matter of personal choice. No one is ever going to agree on this issue.

Coming in fourth isn't a death knell and Chris will have a wonderful career in front of him. I wish the other idols luck in their career. I just cab't watch any longer, it isn't about the best singer, it's a popularity contest.

Not everyone in Alabama supports Taylor though. I have a friend that lives in Helena. She was rooting for Chris. Yes she is my age and liked Chris. Shocking huh? BTW-I am 34 and proud of it. I loved Carrie and Bo last year and have both of their CD's!! My favorites were voted off early last year, but at least they still had people that I cared about watching.
It is all a matter of personal choice, I do agree with you on that. Chris did have a good voice, but its not the kind of music I listen to, so why would I prefer him. I thought Mandisa had one of the best voices out of all of them, but I just didnt care for her. Idol is a popularity contest based on personal preferences, looks, style, musical tastes, etc. If people voted for the best voice, the show would be boring.

I hated last year, I didnt like anyone in the top 12 cept Nikko and Mikalah, and we all know how long they lasted lol. Well, I liked Anthony, but I wasnt a fangirl or anything.

[KissMyGrits]

I thought Mandisa had one of the best voices out of all of them, but I just didnt care for her. Idol is a popularity contest based on personal preferences, looks, style, musical tastes, etc. If people voted for the best voice, the show would be boring.

I hated last year, I didnt like anyone in the top 12 cept Nikko and Mikalah, and we all know how long they lasted lol. Well, I liked Anthony, but I wasnt a fangirl or anything.

BINGO!! We agree on something!! LOL!! I am not a fangirl of Chris I just like the rocker edge!! I am willing to give Taylor a shot and lets see! I say I am not going to watch, but with only one tv in the house and a husband that loves Taylor, well you know how that goes!! LOL!! Unfortunately not everyone can win and no one is ever going to be 100% happy, no matter who wins.

I was kind of upset when Carrie won last year over Bo, but they both made excellant CD's and I have both of them.

I agree that Mandisa had a beautiful voice and am glad that Barry Manilow is going to make a record with her!! She deserves it!!

If Taylor wins then my hubby will be as happy as a pig in mud! LOL!! I can see it now, he will be dancing around the house and doing the victory dance!! All the while I will sit there smiling and saying "Wait til next year darling!!" LOL!! :lol: :lol: :lol:

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

BINGO!! We agree on something!! LOL!! I am not a fangirl of Chris I just like the rocker edge!! I am willing to give Taylor a shot and lets see! I say I am not going to watch, but with only one tv in the house and a husband that loves Taylor, well you know how that goes!! LOL!! Unfortunately not everyone can win and no one is ever going to be 100% happy, no matter who wins.

I was kind of upset when Carrie won last year over Bo, but they both made excellant CD's and I have both of them.

I agree that Mandisa had a beautiful voice and am glad that Barry Manilow is going to make a record with her!! She deserves it!!

If Taylor wins then my hubby will be as happy as a pig in mud! LOL!! I can see it now, he will be dancing around the house and doing the victory dance!! All the while I will sit there smiling and saying "Wait til next year darling!!" LOL!! :lol: :lol: :lol:
:lol: Yah its pretty hard NOT to watch Idol! I say every year or even every week 'Whatev! I boycott this show', lol but that lasts about 10 min. and then Im already anticipating next weeks theme. No matter how many disappointments Ive dealt with this show, I always have that one glimmer of hope that something will FINALLY go my way.. hopefully its this year!l lol.

Yah I was disappointed when Carrie beat out Bo. I wasnt Bo's biggest fan, but I wanted him to beat Carrie.. I always get turned off by the 'chosen' one, but I knew shed win anyways. I couldnt stand her on the show, but I do love her now and saw her a couple months ago in concert. Im not a fan of country, but I do love her CD lol. Once the show ends they warm up to me since they are no longer a 'threat' to my favorites.

I would love Taylor to win, too!! But I also want Elliott to win. If they made it to the finals itd be a win-win situation for me.

[G-Force Glockstar]

Chris's phone line was the hardest to get through

[Heart Shaped Box]

Chris's phone line was the hardest to get through

Not for me..but maybe I was just lucky. Me and my mom took turns voting for him and when it was my turn it only took my four times to get through, and my mom maybe about 10-15 tries.

[EmoJoe]

Chris's phone line was the hardest to get through
i was able to pull in a lot of votes, but i was still getting some busy signals all the way till the end

[Heart Shaped Box]

The only thing Taylor has going for him is that he dances goofy!! Once he comes out with a CD who is going to buy it? His major audience is in their 50's and 60's!

I agree with you on Taylor. I think he's mostly liked because he's goofy, but he still has a fairly good voice. If he wins, I don't think he will be a pop singer, and I honestly don't know what kind of music he would make. I could see Elliot and definitely Katherine make pop music though.

[eltonfan80]

Chris will be more popular than any of the other three remaining idols. He has already been offered a lead singing position with the group Fuel. He doesn't need to win this glorified popularity contest.
:nod:

[Joeylova87]

The thing is that with Chris is that he will always be affiliated with some kind of band. I don't think he'll break away from that.

[LuLu Rogers]

The thing is that with Chris is that he will always be affiliated with some kind of band. I don't think he'll break away from that.

I agree. I don't see him doing well on his own. He'll always have that band stigma following him around.