AI5: Top 10 RESULTS- 10 turns into 9!!!

[EmoJoe]

:eek: supposedly a big shocker

http://idolforums.com/index.php?showtopic=413563

^^aunt edna clues

i think it might be mandisa

crying = she sang "cry" once
phone= her phone thing was messed up
holy smokes- her song was religion

OR it could be

Holy- Mandisa (bottom 3, her song was religious)
Smokes- Bucky (his song was a metaphor about a guy selling cigarettes, bottom 2)
Crying- Ace (his song had the words "crying home" in it, OUT)

[Karen*]

Keep Mandisa!! Let Bucky go. Heck, let Ace go. Or even Kellie Pickler or Lisa Tucker. But everyone else should stay, IMO.

[EmoJoe]

its on!!! :eek:

[EmoJoe]

shakira and wycleff performig next. yippee -__-

at least they showed the ice age/photoshoot/daily life thing, to make the results show a LITTLE more interesting...

[Cactus Jack]

Yeah

Why cnat they do group songs?

[EmoJoe]

Yeah

Why cnat they do group songs?
cause for some weird reason, they actually think people enjoy the guests...:confused:

[David]

I hope Katharine and Elliott are safe. If they're safe, I'll be fine.

[EmoJoe]

wow shakira is like half-naked -_-

[EmoJoe]

I hope Katharine and Elliott are safe. If they're safe, I'll be fine.
for me, if chris and katharine are safe i'll be fine

if chris and katharine are the bottom 2 i think i'm going to throw my TV out the window.

[KissMyGrits]

Chris is safe....

I think it is going to be Ace, Bucky and Lisa!!

Lisa is going home....

[Cactus Jack]

cause for some weird reason, they actually think people enjoy the guests...:confused:
Ah



YAY BOTTOM ROW SAFE!!!!!!!!!!!

[Cactus Jack]

:eek:

[EmoJoe]

NOOOOO KATHARINE :(

ugh, my heart is pounding like heck right now.

[KissMyGrits]

I CAN'T BELIEVE Katherine is in the bottom 3!!! No!!!!!

[EmoJoe]

bottom 3: lisa, ace, katharine

shocker :(

[James"Thunder"Early]

Who else is in the bottom 3?

[EmoJoe]

ugh, come on. katharine has GOT to be safe :(

[LuLu Rogers]

bottom 3: lisa, ace, katharine

shocker :(

Awe! poor Katharine! :( Bucky should've left 2 weeks ago! :mad:

[EmoJoe]

Who else is in the bottom 3?

katharine, ace, and lisa

ace is safe

[KissMyGrits]

Lisa, Ace and Katharine....I still think Lisa is going home....

[James"Thunder"Early]

katharine, ace, and lisa

ace is safeThanks

[LuLu Rogers]

Lisa, Ace and Katharine....I still think Lisa is going home....

Kinda hope Ace goes, but Lisa would be ok, just NOT Katharine!

[EmoJoe]

aww lisa is out...

but better her then katharine.

im still sad though

[Dr. John Becker]

Bye bye Lisa.

[LuLu Rogers]

aww lisa is out...

but better her then katharine.

im still sad though


Poor Lisa :( Shoulda been Bucky! :mad:

[EmoJoe]

but WTF? BUCKY NEEDS TO GET HIS FREAKIN BUTT OUT OF THERE!!!

i...hate...him. lisa SHOULDNT have left and katharine SHOULDNT have been in the bottom 3

[KissMyGrits]

Whew!! Katharine is safe!

[EmoJoe]

the themes SUCK this year. COUNTRY!?!?!?!?!?

AI3 country night sucked, didnt they learn anything from it?

[LuLu Rogers]

but WTF? BUCKY NEEDS TO GET HIS FREAKIN BUTT OUT OF THERE!!!

i...hate...him. lisa SHOULDNT have left and katharine SHOULDNT have been in the bottom 3


Exactly!

[Cactus Jack]

PHEEEEEEWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW

Lisa's out :( I was kinda thinknig shed go sometime soon though


BukcyUUUUGGGHHH but the longer he satys the more my fanfic called A Day In the Life of Bucky Covington will make snse so ome mor week

[theshark8777]

but WTF? BUCKY NEEDS TO GET HIS FREAKIN BUTT OUT OF THERE!!!

i...hate...him. lisa SHOULDNT have left and katharine SHOULDNT have been in the bottom 3

I can live with Lisa leaving more than Katharine in the bottom 3, but damn, Bucky's gotta go. Bucky should have left before Kevin!

[EmoJoe]

ugh

lisa wasnt the best but bucky seriously should have gone. im totally going anti-bucky now. why dont we do the same thing we did for scott last year?

[KissMyGrits]

I have to say that I LOVE Country music!! Woo-Hoo!! I can see Chris doing a Hank Williams Jr. Song!! Hmmm or maybe a Toby Keith song....hmmmm the possibilites are endless....lol...

[EmoJoe]

I can live with Lisa leaving more than Katharine in the bottom 3, but damn, Bucky's gotta go. Bucky should have left before Kevin!
bucky should have left before rhonetta -_-

if you ask me, bucky isnt top 72 worthy :)

i kinda liked lisa, not OMGMGMGM i love her but i enjoyed her. so seeing her leave makes me kinda sad.

but it makes me more mad that katharine was bottom 3 and bucky's butt was sitting on the couches safe.

[Cactus Jack]

Exactly!
Did you have another username?

[Cactus Jack]

bucky should have left before rhonetta -_-
LOL yeah he sjhhouldnt have made the top 24 or top 44
DAMN YOU HILLBILIIES! IM TLAKNI TO YOU LARRY THE CABLE GUY!

[eltonfan80]

i am so sad that lisa is gone glad that katharine and chris are safe

[LuLu Rogers]

Did you have another username?

It used to be #1 John Ritter Fan

[Cactus Jack]

It used to be #1 John Ritter Fan
Ah



Chris should sing "Sweet Home Aalabama" or "Freebird" or "Rambilin Man"
Bucky -"Achy Breaky Heart "

[KissMyGrits]

bucky should have left before rhonetta -_-

if you ask me, bucky isnt top 72 worthy :)

i kinda liked lisa, not OMGMGMGM i love her but i enjoyed her. so seeing her leave makes me kinda sad.

but it makes me more mad that katharine was bottom 3 and bucky's butt was sitting on the couches safe.

I definitely agree!! Bucky needs to go!!

[Cactus Jack]

bucky should have left before rhonetta -_-

if you ask me, bucky isnt top 72 worthy :)

i kinda liked lisa, not OMGMGMGM i love her but i enjoyed her. so seeing her leave makes me kinda sad.

but it makes me more mad that katharine was bottom 3 and bucky's butt was sitting on the couches safe.
Ditto!

[EmoJoe]

Ah



Chris should sing "Sweet Home Aalabama" or "Freebird" or "Rambilin Man"
Bucky -"Achy Breaky Heart "
bucky should sing "how far" by martina mcbride so he can be voted off

chris needs to do something different so simon wont be on his case. im thinking a country-rock ballad.

"freebird" might be good, but bo sang it last year and wound up being in the bottom 2.

[Cactus Jack]

bucky should sing "how far" by martina mcbride so he can be voted off

chris needs to do something different so simon wont be on his case. im thinking a country-rock ballad.

"freebird" might be good, but bo sang it last year and wound up being in the bottom 2.
Yeah LMAO :rotflmao: thats wh yI said Achy Breaky Heart

Yeah, ditto

Oh yeah, thats right I remember

[David]

OHMAGOOOOOODNESS

I was seriously on the brink of tears when she was in the bottom 3. I was more pissed at the fact that Simon said that he wasn't bothered by the bottom 3, because it's clear to me that he'll do anything in his ability to put Chris, Taylor, and Kellie in the top 3. Yes, it wasn't a great Katharine performance, but really, there were at least 6 performances that were worse, and her past performances should have saved her. I love Kellie but it was such a lame performance. Suds in a Bucket?! Please. Ace actually deserved to go over Lisa too. And don't even get me started on Bucky. Oh man. If he actually makes the top 8, I think I might jump over a bridge.

So guys I guess it's official, Taylor and Chris are your final 2. No doubt.

And Kellie Pickler is 3rd.

And the theme. Country. Wow. Just, wow. Didn't we learn after past years?

And let me go random for a second. Tonight kind of reminds me of Season 2, because Lisa had the same bottom 3 record as Julia DeMato, and ended up leaving tonight ... and then Kimberly Caldwell surprisingly landed in the bottom 2, and so did Katharine. Both were my favorites of the seaosn.

[EmoJoe]

Yeah LMAO :rotflmao: thats wh yI said Achy Breaky Heart

Yeah, ditto

Oh yeah, thats right I remember
yeah

[Cactus Jack]

yeah
Yeah

[David]

Ugh.

Ugh.

I'm still pissed.

I'm voting TRIPLE the amount I voted this week.

And I'll throw some in for Elliott too :D

[Cactus Jack]

Ugh.

Ugh.

I'm still pissed.

I'm voting TRIPLE the amount I voted this week.

And I'll throw some in for Elliott too :D
Ditto

Wow we all have the same top 5 this year, thats awesome :lol:

[EmoJoe]

OHMAGOOOOOODNESS

I was seriously on the brink of tears when she was in the bottom 3. I was more pissed at the fact that Simon said that he wasn't bothered by the bottom 3, because it's clear to me that he'll do anything in his ability to put Chris, Taylor, and Kellie in the top 3. Yes, it wasn't a great Katharine performance, but really, there were at least 6 performances that were worse, and her past performances should have saved her. I love Kellie but it was such a lame performance. Suds in a Bucket?! Please. Ace actually deserved to go over Lisa too. And don't even get me started on Bucky. Oh man. If he actually makes the top 8, I think I might jump over a bridge.

So guys I guess it's official, Taylor and Chris are your final 2. No doubt.

And Kellie Pickler is 3rd.

And the theme. Country. Wow. Just, wow. Didn't we learn after past years?

And let me go random for a second. Tonight kind of reminds me of Season 2, because Lisa had the same bottom 3 record as Julia DeMato, and ended up leaving tonight ... and then Kimberly Caldwell surprisingly landed in the bottom 2, and so did Katharine. Both were my favorites of the seaosn.
oh no :eek:


anyway i agree about basically everything you said. the whole time they did the bottom 3 my heart was pounding like CRAZY. ugh, i was seriously about to scream

and bucky, in my opinion, should have been gone the 2nd week of the semi-finals. and really, of the bottom 3, ace was the most deserving to go.

and i know WTF? the judges didnt act surprised. that was rude.

[David]

oh no :eek:


anyway i agree about basically everything you said. the whole time they did the bottom 3 my heart was pounding like CRAZY. ugh, i was seriously about to scream

and bucky, in my opinion, should have been gone the 2nd week of the semi-finals. and really, of the bottom 3, ace was the most deserving to go.

and i know WTF? the judges didnt act surprised. that was rude.

Never would I have expected to see Bucky in the top 9, or even the top 24. Oh man.

And it's his theme next week.

Oh dear.

So I guess Elliott's out.

[Czas na Zywiec]

wow shakira is like half-naked -_-

she always wears those tops. plus, she had a long skirt on. I don't see anything tastless with the way she's dressed. http://skyscrapercity.com/images/smilies/nixweiss.gif

but :drool:, I haven't really paid much attention to Shakira lately. but I'm glad I tuned in to the show tonight. :love:

[EmoJoe]

she always wears those tops. plus, she had a long skirt on. I don't see anything tastless with the way she's dressed. http://skyscrapercity.com/images/smilies/nixweiss.gif

but :drool:, I haven't really paid much attention to Shakira lately. but I'm glad I tuned in to the show tonight. :love:
well, its just different to see on american idol...

[EmoJoe]

Never would I have expected to see Bucky in the top 9, or even the top 24. Oh man.

And it's his theme next week.

Oh dear.

So I guess Elliott's out.
i know ugh -_-

bucky is officially the scott savol of AI5...

[David]

Ditto

Wow we all have the same top 5 this year, thats awesome :lol:

:woohoo:

And they all BETTER make the top 5.

[EmoJoe]

:woohoo:

And they all BETTER make the top 5.
yeah, i cant see it being anything else...

but ugh i cant see anyone leaving next week but bucky. i mean, seriosuly. everyone else is in a totally different leauge.

[David]

i know ugh -_-

bucky is officially the scott savol of AI5...

I would have rather seen Kevin as the Scott Savol instead of Bucky.

[EmoJoe]

I would have rather seen Kevin as the Scott Savol instead of Bucky.
me too.

kevin at least has a nice tone to his voice.

[David]

yeah, i cant see it being anything else...

but ugh i cant see anyone leaving next week but bucky. i mean, seriosuly. everyone else is in a totally different leauge.

Agree fully.

[EmoJoe]

Agree fully.
yeah, like i just posted on IDF (:p ) you have 8 great contestants, and then you have bucky, who's just there. by the end of the show i never remember him, even if he's near the end.

its seriously scott savol all over again. lets just hope he doesnt make it as far as scott though...

[David]

me too.

kevin at least has a nice tone to his voice.

And a personality.

[EmoJoe]

And a personality.
:nod:

[consentida]

she always wears those tops. plus, she had a long skirt on. I don't see anything tastless with the way she's dressed. http://skyscrapercity.com/images/smilies/nixweiss.gif

but :drool:, I haven't really paid much attention to Shakira lately. but I'm glad I tuned in to the show tonight. :love:


And she's a belly dancer on top of that. She's supposed to show those portions of her body. But lately she's been wearing t-shirts and pants to perform but she changes it up for "Hips Don't Lie."

[EmoJoe]

And she's a belly dancer on top of that. She's supposed to show those portions of her body. But lately she's been wearing t-shirts and pants to perform but she changes it up for "Hips Don't Lie."
im not saying she should stop doing what she's doing, but it just wasnt american idol like.

[consentida]

im not saying she should stop doing what she's doing, but it just wasnt american idol like.

Yeah I know. I was just saying. lol.

[I Love John Ritter]

Never would I have expected to see Bucky in the top 9, or even the top 24. Oh man.

And it's his theme next week.

Oh dear.

So I guess Elliott's out.
Oh no, don't say that. Elliot rocks!! :D

Ugh, I didn't want to see Lisa go. I thought she would, but I don't think she deserved to leave. She has a really great voice. I think Ace deserved to leave.

I predicted Lisa, Bucky, and Ace to be in the bottom 3, with Lisa leaving. I was so shocked to see Katharine in the bottom 2! I know last night was not her best, but I thought she had a lot of fans. I'm not a fan of hers, but I don't think she deserved to be in the bottom 3. The people who deserved the bottom 3 based on last night's performances were Kellie, Bucky and Ace, IMO.

When Ryan asked Simon how he felt about the bottom 2, he said "especially Katharine". I thought that was kind of rude for him to say in front of Lisa.

[Karen*]

I didn't realize how sad I would be now that Lisa is eliminated. Even though she was one of the weaker contestants in the top 10, I still liked her. :( I think I even cried a little bit...she showed a lot more emotion during tonight's performance than last night's and to see the rest of the contestants stand up for her...just...WOW.

And ugh...I was so frickin nervous for Katharine! Would've rather seen Ace in the bottom two rather than her, even though I like Ace. Tonight was the worst bottom three of AI5 yet, simply cuz she was in it.

I was pretty nervous for Elliott too, but he was safe, so yay. :)

And I agree with you guys...Bucky needs to get his ass out of there!! Go to Nashville Star, BOY. :mad:

I need to rant about someone else though (You might not want to read if you're a fan)...KELLIE PICKLER. pissed: Ugh...I kinda thought she should've made the bottom three. Her performance last night was horrible. The only reason why she's still in the competition is cuz she's a hot (and may I add AIRHEADED) blonde and she's probably getting sympathy votes somewhere because of her sob story (Anyone know how big is the prison her dad's in?). She better not make it in the top five. And if she's in the finale...UGH. She shouldn't because 1) We don't need another Idol named KELLY (At least for now) and 2) We don't need another blonde country singer to rob people who really deserve to win this competition. (Sorry Carrie fans :p :seeya: ). [/end rant]

It's pretty much a given that Bucky and Kellie are gonna be safe for next week though since the theme is COUNTRY. :rolleyes:

But guess thaaaattt's Idol for ya.

BTW...suggestion for next week...Elliott should sing Bless the Broken Road. :biglove:

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

I was so relieved to see Katharine in the bottom 3. I was hoping to see Lisa make it another week instead even though she picks the worst songs to sing. I didnt find it all that shocking.

[HuntingtonM15]

And I agree with you guys...Bucky needs to get his ass out of there!! Go to Nashville Star, BOY. :mad:


Even Nashville Star (which gets trashier by the season) is too good for him.

[Karen*]

Even Nashville Star (which gets trashier by the season) is too good for him.

Yeah...I wanted to add "In fact, go back HOME" in my post...but nah... :lol:

[Karen*]

So guys I guess it's official, Taylor and Chris are your final 2. No doubt.

And Kellie Pickler is 3rd.

I can live with Chris being in the final two. ;) But in a perfect world...Elliott and Katharine should join him in the top three...although I know the chances of that are slim. :cuss:

And I reaaalllyy hope Elliott doesn't get eliminated next week like you just said. If he does, I'll probably slit my wrists.

Did I just say that last sentence? :eek2:

[Karen*]

Wow we all have the same top 5 this year, thats awesome :lol:

Not me. I don't like Kellie Pickler. :p

[Karen*]

yeah, i cant see it being anything else...

but ugh i cant see anyone leaving next week but bucky. i mean, seriosuly. everyone else is in a totally different leauge.

How about...Paris instead of Kellie? :D

But I agree with you on that last one...Everyone beats Bucky. Heck, Bobby Bennett beats Bucky, and I didn't even like Bobby that much. ohno:

[80sTrivia]

I was shocked that Katharine was in the Bottom Two, when she gave the best performance of the group on Tuesday... but I felt it was time for Lisa to go home... next week, let it be Bucky, please...

[G-Force Glockstar]

Aw, Lisa's gone :( I kinda saw it coming, though.
But I can't believe Katherine was in the bottom 2! She did great Tuesday night :mad:
IT NEEDS TO BE BUCKY GOING HOME!!!!!

[Cactus Jack]

And a personality.
:nod:

[Woolworth27]

Reality Shows? SHUT DA F!#$k UP WHO'S NEXT?:happyface :lol: :crazy:

[Karen*]

Reality Shows? SHUT DA F!#$k UP WHO'S NEXT?:happyface :lol: :crazy:
:confused:

[EmoJoe]

Reality Shows? SHUT DA F!#$k UP WHO'S NEXT?:happyface :lol: :crazy:
um...

[EmoJoe]

I can live with Chris being in the final two. ;) But in a perfect world...Elliott and Katharine should join him in the top three...although I know the chances of that are slim. :cuss:

And I reaaalllyy hope Elliott doesn't get eliminated next week like you just said. If he does, I'll probably slit my wrists.

Did I just say that last sentence? :eek2:
i don't think he will.

i think it'll be ace or bucky next week.

[Karen*]

i think it'll be ace or bucky next week.

I think it's gonna be Ace. Idol screws me over like that. :(

[EmoJoe]

I think it's gonna be Ace. Idol screws me over like that. :(
when i made my dream/predicted top 12 at the end of the auditions, i had ace at 9th. it would be cool if it came true :p well not really, but it would be kinda weird.

[David]

Reality Shows? SHUT DA F!#$k UP WHO'S NEXT?:happyface :lol: :crazy:

That was unnecessary.

[David]

BTW...suggestion for next week...Elliott should sing Bless the Broken Road. :biglove:

That would be GREAT!