How would the contestants from AI1- AI4 do on AI5?

[EmoJoe]

yeah, title says all :D

i think...

AI4
Make at least top 5: Carrie, Constantine, Nadia (she would stand out this season), Bo, maybe Vonzell
Make top 9 - top 6: Anthony, Anwar, Nikko, Jessica
Make top 12 - top 10: MAYBE Mikalah, maybe Jessica or Nikko
Not make top 12: Scott, Mikalah (maybe), Lindsey
AI3

Make at least top 5: Diana, Fantasia, LaToya
Make top 9 - top 6: Jasmine, George
Make top 12- top 10 : Jennifer, maybe JPL
Not make top 12: John Stevens, Leah, Camile, Matt, Amy (though she could)

for seasons 1-2, i think the only contestants with a shot at making it are Kelly and Clay, and maybe Tamyra.

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

Clay, Kelly, Tamyra, Diana, and La Toya are the only ones that can pull off every theme thats been done imo.

Clay, Kelly, Diana, Bo, Carrie would make it farthest.