AI5 - Your Favorite and Least Favorite Performances by the Top 12

[Karen*]

So far, what are your favorite and least favorite performances from this season's American Idol top 12?

Here are my picks (Finalists listed in ABC order by first name, favorite and least favorite separated by slash):

Ace Young - Father Figure / We Will Rock You
Bucky Covington - Superstition / Oh Boy
Chris Daughtry - Higher Ground / What If
Elliott Yamin - A Song for You / If Tomorrow Never Comes
Katharine McPhee - Someone to Watch Over Me / All in Love is Fair
Kellie Pickler - Walking After Midnight / Bewitched, Bothered, and Bewildered
Kevin Covais - I Heard it Through the Grapevine / Vincent
Lisa Tucker - Signed, Sealed, Delivered / Because of You
Mandisa - Never / Any Man of Mine
Melissa McGhee - Why Haven't I Heard from You / Lately
Paris Bennett - Work it Out / Wind Beneath My Wings
Taylor Hicks - You Send Me / Trouble

[EmoJoe]

in no order...

Chris Daughtry- Higher Ground

Ace Young- Father Figure

Katharine McPhee- Till You Come Back to Me

Kellie Pickler- I'm the Only One

Paris Benett- All For One, or whatever she sang Tuesday

Eliott Yamin- Heaven cause its one of my favorite songs, but i actually think Moody's Mood For Love was the best, if that makes sense...

Melissa McGhee- When the Lights Go Down, the only performance of hers that I liked

Bucky Covington- Superstiton

Kevin Covais- mehhh One Last Cry

Taylor Hicks- Levon

Lisa Tucker- Signed, Sealed, Delivererd

Mandisa- Never

[-*Forever*-]

Ace Young - Father Figure
Bucky Covington - Superstition
Chris Daughtry - Higher Ground
Elliott Yamin - Moody's Mood for Love
Katharine McPhee - Since I Fell for You
Kellie Pickler - Something to Talk About
Kevin Covais - Vincent
Lisa Tucker - ....none
Mandisa - I'm Every Woman
Melissa McGhee - Lately/What About Love/Why Haven't I Heard From You ((Honestly? I can't decide.))
Paris Bennett - Midnight Train to Georgia
Taylor Hicks - Taking it to the Streets

[Karen*]

:bump

I think we've seen just about enough from the top 12, so I'm editing this thread (and my post) to answer the question "What are your favorite and LEAST performances from the top 12?" Not to mention that I've been rewatching a lot of episodes. :lol: So go ahead and post your choices.

[EmoJoe]

im bored, so yay


Chris Daughtry
Favorite: Higher Ground/Hemorhagge
Least Favorite: What If

Eliott Yamin
Favorite: I Don't Want to Be
Least Favorite: Knocks Me Off My Feet

Mandisa
Favorite: Never
Least Favorite: Praise You

Katharine McPhee
Favorite: Come Rain or Come Shine
Least Favorite: All is Fair in Love

Kellie Pickler
Favorite: Walking After Midnight
Least Favorite: Blame it on the Sun

Paris Bennett
Favorite: Fever
Least Favorite: Midnight Train to Georgia

Lisa Tucker
Favorite: Where I Stand (i changed my mind :D )
Least Favorite: Because of You

Melissa McGhee
Favorite: What About Love (i changed my mind again :D)
Least Favorite: Lately

Kevin Covais
Favorite: One Last Cry
Least Favorite: Part-Time Lover

Bucky Covington
Favorite: Superstition
Least Favorite: Real Good Man

Taylor Hicks
Favorite: Levon
Least Favorite: Trouble

Ace Young
Favorite: Father Figure
Least Favorite: Drops of Jupiter

[EmoJoe]

(and my post)
i shouldve done that, lol

[Karen*]

i shouldve done that, lol
I forgot to edit the title, LOL.

[GoldenFamilyTies]

FAVORITE:

Melissa McGhee - What About Love


LEAST FAVORITE:

Mandisa - Praise You

[-*Forever*-]

Least Favorites

Ace Young - Drops of Jupiter
Bucky Covington - Oh Boy
Chris Daughtry - What If
Elliott Yamin - the Stevie Wonder one
Katharine McPhee - Think
Kellie Pickler - the Stevie Wonder one
Kevin Covais - One Last Cry
Lisa Tucker - All of them. No, but really, Because of You
Mandisa - her gospel one
Melissa McGhee - When the Lights Go Down
Paris Bennett - Conga ((And I have a new favorite of hers - Fever))
Taylor Hicks - Trouble

[Karen*]

:bump

I'm editing my picks. :D

[David]

Chris Daughtry
Favorite: Higher Ground
Least Favorite: What If

Eliott Yamin
Favorite: Somebody To Love/Teach Me Tonight
Least Favorite: Knocks Me Off My Feet

Mandisa
Favorite: Never
Least Favorite: Any Man of Mine

Katharine McPhee
Favorite: Someone To Watch Over Me
Least Favorite: The Voice Within

Kellie Pickler
Favorite: Walking After Midnight
Least Favorite: Blame it on the Sun

Paris Bennett
Favorite: These Foolish Things
Least Favorite: Conga

Lisa Tucker
Favorite: Here's Where I Stand
Least Favorite: Why Do Fools Fall in Love

Melissa McGhee
Favorite: What About Love
Least Favorite: When the Lights Go Down

Kevin Covais
Favorite: One Last Cry
Least Favorite: Vincent

Bucky Covington
Favorite: Fat-Bottomed Girls
Least Favorite: Oh Boy

Taylor Hicks
Favorite: You Send Me
Least Favorite: Trouble

Ace Young
Favorite: That's All
Least Favorite: Drops of Jupiter

[I Love John Ritter]

Hey, I don't remember this post...anyway...

Ace Young - Tonight I Want to Cry / If You're Not the One
Bucky Covington - Superstition / Oh Boy
Chris Daughtry - Have You Ever Really Loved a Woman / Innuendo
Elliott Yamin - A Song For You / Knocks Me Off My Feet
Katharine McPhee - Someone to Watch Over Me / Who Wants To Live Forever
Kellie Pickler - I'm The Only One / Blame it on the Sun
Kevin Covais - One Last Cry / I Heard It Through the Grapevine
Lisa Tucker - Who's Loving You / I Am Changing
Mandisa - Cry / Any Man of Mine
Melissa McGhee - Why Haven't I Heard from You / What About Love
Paris Bennett - The Show Must Go On / Work it Out
Taylor Hicks - Taking it to the Streets / Country Roads

[EmoJoe]

mine have changed :p

Ace Young
Favorite: Father Figure
Least Favorite: Drops of Jupiter

Chris Daughtry
Favorite: Have You Ever Really Loved a Woman
Least Favorite: What If

Eliott Yamin
Favorite: A Song For You
Least Favorite: his country week song

Kellie Pickler
Favorite: Walking After Midnight
Least Favorite: Blame it on the Sun


Katharine McPhee
Favorite: Who Wants to Live Forever (REALLY underrated performance IMO)
Least Favorite: All is Fair in Love

Taylor Hicks
Favorite: A Crazy Little Thing Called Love
Least Favorite: Trouble

Kevin Covais
Favorite: One Last Cry
Least Favorite: Part-Time Lover

Paris Bennett
Favorite: Work it Out
Least Favorite: Midnight Train to Georgia

Melissa McGhee
Favorite: What About Love
Least Favorite: Lately

Lisa Tucker
Favorite: Where I Stand (another underrated performance IMO)
Least Favorite: Because of You

Mandisa
Favorite: Never
Least Favorite: Praise You

Bucky Covington
Favorite: Superstition
Least Favorite: Oh Boy

[Karen*]

Edited my favorite pick for Elliott. :D

[I Love John Ritter]

I edited my picks, too.

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

FAVORITE/LEAST FAVORITE

Elliott - Somebody To Love/Heaven
Kevin - Part Time Lover/One Last Cry
Taylor - Taking It To The Street/Trouble
Ace - Father Figure/Drops Of Jupiter
Bucky - Superstition/Oh Boy
Chris - Higher Ground/What If
Paris - Work It Out/Memories
Melissa - What About Love/When The Lights Go Down
Kellie - Walking After Midnight/Unchained Melody
Katharine McPhee - Since I Fell For You/All In Love Is Fair
Mandisa - Im Every Woman/Dont You Worry Bout A Thang
Lisa - Because Of You/Where I Stand