Good idea or not?

[G-Force Glockstar]

Do you think it would be a good idea if they had 12 total American Idols, then they'd put all the American Idol winners together and they would compete?! I just thought of that a couple weeks ago, and I think it would be pretty cool if they did that!!

[Cactus Jack]

Thatd be AWESOME!:D

[G-Force Glockstar]

Thatd be AWESOME!:D

:woohoo:

So far, I'd still root for Carrie ;)

[Cactus Jack]

:woohoo:

So far, I'd still root for Carrie ;)
:D

Yeah

[G-Force Glockstar]

But it'd be like in 8 years from now, so some of them would be alot older. Like Carrie will be 30 years old in 8 years.....but of course she'll still be famous :D

[Cactus Jack]

But it'd be like in 8 years from now, so some of them would be alot older. Like Carrie will be 30 years old in 8 years.....but of course she'll still be famous :D
Yeah


But maybe they wont have 12 seasons of it I mean it would get old at some point its the same thing every season only thing differnet are the ocntestants so maybe after 6 or 7 seasons it may run its course

[G-Force Glockstar]

Yeah


But maybe they wont have 12 seasons of it I mean it would get old at some point its the same thing every season only thing differnet are the ocntestants so maybe after 6 or 7 seasons it may run its course

Yeah, maybe.

[Cactus Jack]

Yeah, maybe.
Yeah

[Tibbs]

Do you think it would be a good idea if they had 12 total American Idols, then they'd put all the American Idol winners together and they would compete?! I just thought of that a couple weeks ago, and I think it would be pretty cool if they did that!!

Thats a great idea, Carrie would have some competition!

[G-Force Glockstar]

Thats a great idea, Carrie would have some competition!

Thanks, and yeah she would.....it would be an interesting competition!

[Karen*]

That'd be frickin awesome!! I'd root for Kelly!

[G-Force Glockstar]

That'd be frickin awesome!!

:woohoo:

[EmoJoe]

Sounds cool :D But they kinda already have that...World Idol. Its almost the same only its the winners from all of the idol shows around the world (Canadian Idol, Australian Idol, ect.) but this sounds better cause we'd know all of them :D

[Karen*]

Sounds cool :D But they kinda already have that...World Idol. Its almost the same only its the winners from all of the idol shows around the world (Canadian Idol, Australian Idol, ect.) but this sounds better cause we'd know all of them :D
OMG, I was gonna post about that. I didn't know there was such thing. :lol:

[David]

Sounds cool :D But they kinda already have that...World Idol. Its almost the same only its the winners from all of the idol shows around the world (Canadian Idol, Australian Idol, ect.) but this sounds better cause we'd know all of them :D

I thought World Idol was a great idea when I first heard it was airing, but when it aired... it was horrrrrible IMO. All it did was turn winners into losers.

Kelly was 2nd though, even with a sore throat, so :woohoo: for her.

[vienna waits]

I thought World Idol was a great idea when I first heard it was airing, but when it aired... it was horrrrrible IMO. All it did was turn winners into losers.

Kelly was 2nd though, even with a sore throat, so :woohoo: for her.
yah :grr: to that guy from CI who didn't like her. oh well simon told him off.

anyways, the idols wouldn't come back for this unless forced. Kelly won't even go on the show.. aaaaand Idol isn't going to last for 12 years. plus there's no point.. they aren't going to really be competing for anything because theyre already famous.

[Tibbs]

yah :grr: to that guy from CI who didn't like her. oh well simon told him off.

anyways, the idols wouldn't come back for this unless forced. Kelly won't even go on the show.. aaaaand Idol isn't going to last for 12 years. plus there's no point.. they aren't going to really be competing for anything because theyre already famous.

Simon told him off? lol, I would have liked to see that! :woohoo: